Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Tulsa

"Talliano's has some of the best pizza I have ever had! The two guys who work there are hilarious, polite, and always smiling. Prices are cheap. Their..."

Micah Medina

Jorshicus 84

"I was incredibly nervous reading the mixed reviews, especially trying something new on Mother's Day, but RUSSO'S DID NOT DISAPPOINT!! The food was..."

Sarah JaQuay

"Excellent Italian restaurant for your whole family. Dallas was our server, & you couldn’t ask for better service. He was knowable about the menu..."

Philip Bundy

"Went here with my daughter for a mommy daughter day. Wanted to try it since I door dash here some. The food was excellent, they had fresh bread, and..."

Dawnisha Davison

"Matthew was a phenomenal and natural server! He was so attentive and on top of it the whole night! Did great handling a large party and incredibly..."

Luca Angove

"The first time here we had a subpar experience but it was more than made up for. The owner took responsibility even when he did not have to. To me, I..."

Kyle Jensen

"Great server, and the food was..."

Austin

"To start, we waited 10 minutes for a waiter to finally approach us. Ordered an appetizer with our drinks and it never arrived. Finished our meal..."

Michaela Thibodeaux

"Very good food. I enjoyed myself here a lot! And the waiter was super nice. His name was Matthew R and you could tell he paid attention. I hope he..."

Caleb Tham

"The food was phenomenal! Our waitress, Evelyn, was professional and super sweet! The atmosphere was quiet and cozy. I definitely recommend this place..."

Rhiannon Eads

"The service, atmosphere and food were all great! I believe our waitresses name was Evelyn and she was so sweet, and very efficient. Best waitress..."

Cheryl Feinsilver

"Recently dined at Russo's with a bunch of high school chums who get together when circumstances allow. While plenty of appetizers were available, the..."

Jeff Scott

"Food was awesome and service was excellent. Evelyn took great care of us and made sure our kids were having fun! Highly recommend..."

André Laugeni

"Lovely upscale Italian in south Tulsa. The olive oil and bread is delicious and eggplant super..."

Courtney Cuenca-Smith

"Absolutely love this place! Always great service! Very clean and wasn't super overcrowded like every other nice place on a Friday night! Good prices..."

Sarah Catherall

"Party of 6 for dinner and it was great. Our waiter Sapan was attentive and very responsive to all our requests. Our group enjoyed salads, pasta and..."

Kim Schauer

Oliveto Italian Bistro

82/100 (1552 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

Dinner

Lunch

Mid-range

"My only complaint is that they don't give me breadsticks when I get to go, and that sometimes I feel like I've got more bell peppers than noodles...."

Irish Maeve

"My wife and I went for our anniversary. They were surprisingly not busy, so we were seated quickly. Our server came quickly for drink orders. I was..."

Phillip Bassett

"Wonderful experience! The food was absolutely delicious! The bruschetta was the absolute best we've ever had. Best I've ever tasted and I'm a big..."

Maranda Sharp

"I found a new favorite! I don't know why I've never been here. And I've never heard anyone recommend or suggest it. But this place was wonderful. We..."

our life

"We wandered into Oliveto and I am happy I did. This was my first time there and we shared the Italian Nachos which were fantastic. Wonton chips with..."

Big City

"I really enjoyed my lunch here. It’s like an upgraded Olive Garden in my opinion. Super yummy. I had a Peach Bellini and the create your own pasta..."

Brianna Manchini

"I love the atmosphere and the food here. Especially the shrimps are fresh and crunchy. Oliveto is now my favorite restaurant for Italian. The chicken..."

Luu Tran

"Good - **** Really been wanting to try this italian restaurant for many years but somehow never happened. Today got an opportunity finally to have..."

Cyril Philip

"Fantastic Meal. Pepperoni Bread was delicious. Spaghetti with Meat Balls, that are definitely made in house. Lasagna was fresh and very good. My son..."

Lance Tanner Hottel

"Great service, atmosphere and food was phenomenal would recommend . Signed up for e club and got free pizza for my birthday they gave me discount..."

Danen Doneske

Mario’s Ny Style Pizzeria

"Pizza is probably closest you can get to NY style, but little more than NY in comparison and not as big either. The crust is good, have had a..."

Chris Stewart

"Absolutely the best New York style pizza in Tulsa. I am from New York and I can attest to this. Been going here for over 20 years. The owner was an..."

M Looman

"My favorite pizza in the whole world! I discovered this place as a kid over fifteen years ago and though I haven’t lived in Tulsa for most of that..."

Andrew Wright

"Good NYC style pizza with a nice homemade crust. Pricing is good and offers by the slice or full pies. The staff is friendly and fast. The decor..."

Jonathan Swafford

"Stopped in because we wanted pizza and it happened to be right where we were. The pizza was great - and the service was wonderful. I asked if I..."

Sean McCoy

"Having lived on and recently moved from the East Coast/NYC area, we were worried about being able to get good Italian eats. Hands down, this is the..."

Phil Camuso

"Best new york pizza in town. I highly recommend this if you like a good crisp crust and tastey cheese and none of that soggy floppy pizza mess. Only..."

Nick Seaton (Spootyman)

"Eating there since Mike and Mario open the place decades ago. Is still as good today as it was then. Mike's wife and daughter have done a fine job..."

Charles the 8th

"As a New Yorker I can attest this is truly NY style pizza and taste like I bought it in Brooklyn. Great prices too I've paid a lot more for less..."

Jim Blauvelt

"We moved right next door to this place and had no idea how good it was. Now we eat here almost once a week! We highly recommend the calzone! So far..."

Amber Washington

"Marios is my favorite place for NY style pizza. Their crust is great and I've always had good service, never disappointed. I highly recommend this..."

Ian Porter

"The calzone is very tasty and filled with lots of cheese. Not the nicest place as far as decoration and ambience but when it comes to food this place..."

Gustavo Schaeffer

"Best Pizza in Tulsa! True NY Style pizza, our friends and family from NY say they can't get pizza this good back..."

Dana Dobias

Andolini's Sliced

81/100 (3614 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

Lunch

Dinner

Mid-range

"Amazing food and incredibly friendly and helpful staff. I also loved the building itself, everything just looked cool. A friend and I ordered one..."

Kaitlin Hicks

"There is pizza, and there is great pizza. STG is so unique, so fresh, so delicious in so many ways that it's great++. The crust is that perfect..."

Elizabeth Espinoza Craddock

"Out-of-towners looking for a different place to eat and stumbled upon this little gem. Our server, Ryan, is my new best friend. Friendly,..."

Jessica Wilson

"Absolutely loved STG! We came from NWA for a fun day away from home and this was the perfect ending to our trip! Pizza was amazing, beer was great,..."

Shelby Lynn Horton

"We have had the opportunity to eat at Andolini’s twice in the last year and I can honestly say it is the best pizza I have ever eaten, anywhere,..."

Dave Trudo

"Incredibly friendly staff. Wonderful tasting gelato. I wish I hadn't eaten before I came here, because the pizza looks so good! I will absolutely..."

Brian Ore

"Always great Pizza with lots of different toppings that is very similar what I had in Italy. Great wine list and a very extensive beer list. Always..."

Andrew Pulley

"Truth be told we were in this area for the Donut shop across the street, which was disappointing to say the least. What was not disappointing was..."

Zac Tincher

"Great people, pizza, and gelato! This is a must see spot in Tulsa and totally doable if you're in a..."

Dana Coelho

"Wonderful service. The chicken bruschetta is my most favorite pizza. Try the biscoff gelato..."

Leslie Elms Nair

"It was my first visit, and they were amazing! Food was delicious and our guy had the best sense of humor. Definitely going..."

Talea Longen

"Salad and Garlic Knots are very yummy. Ordered what they said was deep dish more like thick bread crust. Probably would have been better had we..."

Sunny Shores

"This pizza is fantastic! The slices are huge and the gelato is incredible. We had the Tenbysimmo. It has ALL the meats, including house-made..."

Jeremiah Cooper

"Came in from the recommendation of my friend Dave Burlin, self proclaimed #1 fan at Andolinis, live in Las Vegas now and he recommended I stop in..."

Ronnie Long

"Service was good, the pizza I ordered was not so good, it was very thick and the dough wasn't cooked all the way. But the ice cream was really..."

Gonzalo Valles

"The food is great, the employees are friendly. A little understaffed, so if there are a bunch of people dining in, then expect a little wait to..."

marcie mayo

"Spent a couple’s weekend in downtown Tulsa and found this place. The pizza was great and the service was better. Topped our meal off with some..."

Kevin and Nesi

"We had the fried mozzarella, thin slice cheese and thick slice pepperoni. The fried mozzarella was delicious- 5 stars. The slices weee good, maybe..."

Indmom11

"Wow, I could write an entire paragraph on how amazing this location is. There was a time where it was not as great unfortunately, but the last year..."

Zain Khan

"1st time visiting this location! Found parking easily and was seated promptly. You have a choice of indoor or outdoor seating- we chose indoor...."

Emma Leffler

"I had gelato from Andolini's, and it was heavenly. Truly. It is very much on the filling side, and a small is really all one needs, but also no harm..."

Lily VM

"The great service WAS the atmosphere! Our waitress/bartender was awesome! The menu was personalized with exactly what was on hand the late hour at..."

Shannon Sevart

"Was in a rush and needed some nosh! So we hit up Andolinis for a slice. I had the MARZANO PESTO and it was underwhelming, but I feel I need to go..."

Berto Bennett

"My wife and I were on a road trip/vacation with another couple. Saw the rodeo and stopped here afterward. The 🍕 was superb! Very flavorful. ..."

Kevin Jackson

"This place is the bee’s knee’s! No but seriously the food is amazing but I was with my parents visiting Tulsa and while eating on their lovely..."

Mike Smith

"Andolini's was wonderful! We shared one chicken bruschetta pizza between 3 people and each got a salad for a lighter meal. The pizza was sooooo good,..."

Carissa Gabilheri

"The food was so good and the staff was awesome and fast. Very clean..."

Shannon M

"Late night pizza delivered to our hotel room after a wedding. This 20" pizza was giant and delicious. Foldable pieces! We ordered the 'Spring Street'..."

Annie Mouse

Mazzio's Pizza

"Best pizza buffet in Tulsa. The only sour point is the lady taking care of the dinning rooms is so sad and angry. Don't know why she keeps working..."

Allen Woodworth

"The managers here always want to serve their customers with great food and welcoming service. Note: DRIVE-THRU ONLY. Other than that, you probably..."

Gabriel Jackson

"Food was good, however it was very crowded and tables were not cleaned promptly. Had to ask someone to come clean..."

Danielle Johnson

"Great Place to Take the whole Family ! Really..."

MICHAEL ADKINS

"I ordered a cheese calzone, cashier was super nice and when she took my food to the table she made sure to get me a plate which was super nice!! food..."

daisy vega

"Lady at window was very nice she did an excellent job the food hot fresh delicious will be..."

Mr J

"Great service, great food. We ordered at the window and then pulled around to wait. They had the pizza ready quickly, the order was perfect, and they..."

Angie Buchanan

"Hats off to our driver and 74115 neighborhood named Jessica! No hats off to the corporate, half off my order does not help my hungry children. Thank..."

Mel O.

"This is my go-to hung-over fat kid food. I can always count on their consistency with no matter what I order -- it always taste the same and is..."

Logan

"The food was good, the staff went out of their way to make sure our pizza was exactly how we wanted it, the wait was just a little long or I would've..."

T C Ray

"We order delivery from this location fairly often. We almost always have a positive experience. The triple play bundle is our most frequent order. I..."

Chris Turner

Mary's Italian Trattoria

"Amazing food, the waiters and waitresses are polite and always social, the atmosphere is sweet and classic. Their chicken fettuccini alfredo is..."

Amy Elizabeth

"Mary's is my favorite restaurant in Tulsa. It does take time to get your food, but their house salad is good, simple, and the house dressing is..."

Debbie Powell

"Absolutely amazing cuisine in my mind. My father loved great Italian food & this is the place we went for special occasions. Nestled off the side of..."

Grant Wood

"This place is like going to your grandma's house. The atmosphere is cozy and eclectic and the food tastes like it was homemade. The space is..."

Sarah Weisse

"Forget Olive Garden! Come to Mary's, where you can feel like you're at your old Italian grandmother's kitchen again. I have worked here for almost a..."

Brickelle Melton

"Cool relaxing family run restaurant Italian restaurant at the beginning of Cherry Street down by Peoria. Started off with the Baked Artichoke heart..."

Greg

"Just like your grandmother would have made - if she made pasta from scratch. I was in Tulsa to see the Monet exhibit at the Philbrook and picked..."

Patsy Terrell

"Love it. I love it here. I see people complaining about the 'grandma' feel and the atmosphere, but that is my favorite part. It's a tiny place with..."

Kat

"My favorite place for Italian. Homey and everything made to..."

Mols

"Lovely ambiance with genuine family heirlooms and photographs from the owners, and handmade crochet on the tables all with a little touch of your old..."

David

"Best Italian in Tulsa. A quiet dinner with Great service, fabulous food on Cherry..."

Djcooks

"I love it. It might take up to an hour, but it says that on the menu. It might be a wait but that's why we have a bunch of regulars. The pasta is..."

Mike

"Nice little place. Excellent..."

Andrew Saliga

"It is shocking to me that everyone is complaining about the wait!! Everything down to the noodles are made from scratch after you order!! The quality..."

Lauren

"Charming with a few surprises. I love the old-world home feel of this restaurant. Antiques and heirlooms line the walls and all of the table linens..."

Mandalia

"Really enjoyed dinner. Family friendly. We beat the rush & got our food fairly quickly. The house dressing was awesome & the chicken fettuccine was..."

JennyG

"It's OK, but not great. I've been there 3 times - each was satisfying but nothing I have had there has been a..."

Chip

"Great place for a relaxing or romantic meal. Excellent food & atmosphere. If you want fast food in a hurry, try a restaurant chain. My review..."

Debra

"This place was awesome! Great food and desserts too!! I will be going there..."

David Martinez

"The food is amazing. People complain that the wait is too long. This is because all the pasta is homemade and there is an explanation about this in..."

Jason McGinnis

"Marys is a nice Italian cuisine especially the spaghetti all though there is a wait u will be happy by the time u take a bite of the food! I am only..."

Phoebe The 12 Year Old

"The food is unparalled. Pasta made from scratch with good ingredients. There's always a long wait while the meal is prepared and it's always worth..."

Fletch

"My favorite Italian restaurant in Tulsa. Small, romantic, exceptional. I recommend getting whatever the daily special is. It is always delicious and..."

Crichardson

"When i found this restaurant was after the other well known italian restaurant closed down the street. I kick myself for never trying marys before..."

Phil

"Yes, you might have to wait a little bit but the food is worth the wait. Personally I love their house salad dressing, I've heard that it's a..."

Stony Biby

"It was a long wait as they just had a party of 16, 6, 4 and 2 come in with only a waiter and a waitress and 2 kitchen staff. Very unusual for summer..."

David Copeland

"I absolutely adored this restaurant. I enjoyed the classy and vintage style, as well as the family restaurant feel. The meal was fantastic, as was my..."

Christian Blacet

"The food was fantastic and our server was so darling. There are vintage aprons hung everywhere and cross stitched tablecloths. My husband took me..."

Ally Lewis

"When I visited Chicago I loved the food experience, so many different and wonderful foods. This was a taste of my vacation right at home. It's like a..."

Sara Lutz

"I love Mary's Italian! My family and I go there every time we have an occasion to do so. It has everything! Great food, atmosphere, and superb..."

Debbie Powell Powell

"Dinner was amazing. My boyfriend has the lasagna and I had chicken Alfred. We split a bottle of wine and had a wonderful desert. Our server was was..."

Jessica Crumb

"Mary's is the best Italian restaurant in Tulsa. I love the cheese bread appetizer, the fresh salad and Dill dressing. The pasta is very fresh. Plus..."

Jodi Robinson

"Stopped by this little Italian place during our visit to Tulsa. We had the fettuccine alfredo with grilled chicken. Dinner was delicious and the..."

Colleen Susskraut

"My wife and I had one of our first dates there 13 years ago and it is still our favorite restaurant in Tulsa. The ambience is unique, the house..."

Matthew Crum

"First time here, service was great no wait at noon on a Friday. I had the spaghetti and meatball with marinara sauce. It was delicious. The New..."

Eric Lusk

"Great service, great food. Loved the Chicken Parmesan, and our waitress was..."

Mac Fitzgerald

"The love that is put in the food can be tasted like an ingredient. Old world Italian meets Tulsa chic. The quiet restaurant with amazing pasta dishes..."

Ronald Baxter

"This little diamond in the rough has the feel of an Italian grandma's dining room. It's small, quaint, dated and a perfect atmosphere for date night..."

Susan Beaty

"Unreliable. The first time I ate there was on a busy Thursday night. Service was great, welcoming, accommodating, warm and helpful. The champaign..."

Reset

There are 57 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Tulsa

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Katie Fielstra

Indigo In Flow

Haley Hollingsworth

Munci Mundell

Zhuline Phillips

Christian Fernandez

Silky Boi (Silkyboi)

Nikki Dutra

John Robinson

Shawn Black

Cameron Johnson

kevin english

Alexis Anello

Jorshicus 84

David Walding

Joshua Smith (JoshFromTulsa)

Braden Edwards

Jacob Osborn

dency samuel

Margaret Wish

Partime Intellectuals

Rori Adams

Jim Prothro

Cooper Rury

Jacked In

bigJ theSinger

Jonathan Cieplechowicz

Sloane Broeffle

A Allen

Lisa Saturday

Yvonne Hall

Matthew Whisenhunt

Becca Lyons Bergkamp

Dave Compton

Kathy Atkinson Birr

Nancy Myers Martsching

Amy Tindell-Shepherd

Jeanie Butler

Nicci Atchley

Dean Prentice

Cheryl Boyd Skinner Ward

Joyce Fair Harp

Jennifer Henry Lytle

Dottie McGee

Jacob Matta

Eat Well Travel Often

Krista Garcia

Diana

brenda de zauzich

Eduardo Cresensio

Jeremiah Perkins

Melissa McFee

Chonkyfire9

Hildie Jean Brandner-Kraft

Tambra Stacy

Dave Hann

Austin Bailey

Michelle La Rue-Williamson

Kari Todd Jarrett

Chris Ridgeway

Larry Benzel

Ashton Spittka-Rhatican

Christina Morton

Sharon Siftar

Kat Kalista

Christi Williams

Kevin Platt

PE Shearer