Kally Tisdel
This was our first time in this shop…we just moved here in August. Wholly moly … we ordered two half pies for a family visit-dutch Apple and Key Lime..so excited to taste them especially after we had a slice of the lemon cream pie.. it was crazy good. Such a sweet place -no pun intended- to go to . Why bake pies when Sydney has the most amazing pies.. no fuss no mess and your family and friends will want to know where these pies came from . Delicious ..thank you thank you .
Joanne Rainbow
First time having a pie from Sydney's Sweet Shop and very pleased. My husbands favorite is Banana Cream Pie. Called Sydney's and they said they had only one left. He held it for me since I was already heading there. It was very delicious. The banana flavor was perfect and plenty of fresh bananas inside. Whipped cream was very good and not overly sweet.
We enjoyed it very much. Will definitely be back. Very nice people by the way.
Angelo Moutzouris
Visiting from Australia and had to try my favourite pie - Banana Cream which we do not have back home. Absolutely delicious pie, fresh ingredients, Not too sweet. Simply perfect. The young lady behind the counter was delightful and very helpful. Highly recommend Sydney's Sweet Shop
Barney Hilton Murray
Great variety and you can get a slice, half or a whole pie. But if you get a slice, taste it before you leave the parking lot so you can go back and get the rest 😂. Save yourself a trip!
Sherri Hammons
OMG, just stopped by to see what they offered for a holiday visit with family. The pies are AMAZING. I would recommend this place to everyone. Honestly, you will be the favorite of any gathering if you bring one of these with you. Well done, Sydney!
Ramtin Tebyanian
Had all of our pies from this shop for Thanksgiving, didn’t pick them up or get to visit the location but the pies were absolutely delicious and very well made. Amazing food, excited to check it out in person.
Cheryl Auchenbach
Sydney's pies are a highlight of every Mother's Day and adult birthday at our house! Her apple and strawberry rhubarb taste so much like my grandma's did ❤️.
Alissa Dionne
Been craving a peach pie for over a month, but could find no time to make one. Had the bright idea to call Sydney’s Sweet Shop and they did not disappoint!!!! The crust is so flakey and the filling is perfect! Thank you for doing pie so well!
Soup Stew
Got me every single slice flavor they had available for my family. Very good pie!
Nancy Blomquist
We ordered pies for Father's Day and they were absolutely delicious! You can taste the high quality ingredients in every bite. Highly recommend!!!!!
Harley Quinn73
ordered key lime pie 🥧 o.m.g it was so delish creamy perfect amount of tartiness lime the crust was so good type of pie you want to take your time savor each bite 😋 Sydney knows pies yes its a drive for me to get there since it's all the way in tanque verde like going to mt lemmon but oh so definitely worth it im looking forward to trying the other flavors of pies 🥧 😊 👍👍👍👍👍thank you Sydney 😊 we really enjoyed the pie 🥧 😊
Kelly Curtin
Best pies in town!! I have been picking up pies from Sydney for a few months now and they have all been incredible. The pecan is out of this world! I have family in town right now and I picked up a pumpkin and a banana cream and my family was blown away! My mother said the pumpkin is the best she has ever had. (I agree!) My aunt said the pies are “exceptional.” I highly recommend everyone go try Sydney’s as soon as possible. 😀
Denise
Sydney's has the BEST carrot cake in town! I am so lucky Sydney's Sweet Shoppe is right in my neighborhood at Catalina Hwy & Tanque Verde. I will be back.
Ashley Dobrogosz
I cannot say enough good things about Sydney's Sweet Shoppe! Best pies ever and sweet service as well. For my wedding, I knew I did not want cake as our dessert. After some research around Tucson, I found a few bakeries or cake bakers that also did pie, but this place is ALL PIE. And after trying one slice, it was really a no-brainer. We ordered the 3” mini pies for our wedding guests and my husband and I got our own to cut during the reception. They turned out amazing and our guests definitely went back for seconds.
They are a family run business and you are always greeted with a warm smile when you walk in. Every flavor is incredible and always tastes so fresh. Even if you are not planning a wedding, do yourself a favor and just go pick up a slice or five. Because if you are like us, you will have a hard time deciding on just one.
Sarah Cancino
Our wedding was in the fall and we had sampled a couple of cake tastings in Tucson and we were never blown away or even completely satisfied. We decided to try mini individual pies. We reached out to Sydney to see if she if she catered weddings or not and she said yes and scheduled us a tasting right away. She stayed late and kept the shop open so we could taste in private. After one bite we looked at one another completely blown away. We ordered 150 assorted flavors: key lime, banana cream, apple, pumpkin, and pecan 3” pies for our wedding. Our guests were not limited with just 1 flavor. We had also asked Sydney to make our main wedding cake and she made us the BEST carrot cake we have ever had! Sydney also provided the fixtures, delivered, and set up on our special day. They were able to made our special day even more special. Everyone at the wedding kept saying how awesome the pies were and asked where we got them! We would recommend going to Sydney’s for any event but especially your big day!
Delori Ryleigh - she, her, hers
This place has the reputation of being the best pies in Tucson, and the reputation is well deserved. Make sure that you order for the holidays well in advance because they do not take last-minute orders to my knowledge. Make sure that you try the apple. It is really good.
Janet Payne
We thoroughly enjoyed Sydney’s pies at our volunteer appreciation event. Each 3” pie was beautifully made and tasted delicious. Sydney was prompt, professional and showed great care for our order!
Phil Russell
Delicious baked at home style pies, my favorite is the Dutch apple pie! Soo good!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes