Review Roma Restaurant - Tuckahoe

What a nice find! The hosts were really friendly and kind and when they found out it was our first time they offered us a drink and dessert on the house! The food itself was really good and the pie was very good, nice crust! We had the fried calamari and zucchini too. The atmosphere was retro but it works, retro and cozy!

Roma is an amazing family owned dining establishment that offers guests superb and top quality Italian dishes. It is a renowned Italian restaurant in Westchester County, New York, and has successfully operated since the 1930’s. In October of 2023, I brought and treated my wife and myself for dinner at Roma to celebrate her birthday and we absolutely loved our time there!!! We were warmly welcomed by the restaurant’s staff, and were quickly provided with a comfortable table. Our server, Anyelina did a great job on addressing our inquiries, providing great insight and recommendations on the menu options and perfectly documented our orders. Both my wife & I found our appetizers and entrees to be outstanding!!! My wife ordered and enjoyed her steak based entree while I ordered and loved my lasagna!!! It was unquestionably well-cooked delightfully delicious!!! When dining at Roma, my wife and I were fortunate enough to meet with the spouse of the owner of Roma. She was an absolute sweetheart, made us feel right at home and always checked in on us to see if we were having a great time. Moreover, she provided us with a delicious complementary desert and sang a lovely rendition of Happy Birthday for my wife!!! Both my wife and I thank Roma for providing us with an exceptional dining experience and one that we’ll always cherish. We recommend for everyone to visit and dine at this wonderful restaurant!!!

This place has been open for a very long time, at least over 20 or 30 years as my parents used to come here to eat. The food is good, retains a homemade flair by a staff that treats you like family. Chicken Parmesan, and salad were very good. The pizza here is probably some of the best in the area. (You can consult the one bite app). The seating and atmosphere could be better, it reminds me of a dorm cafeteria. Food - 14/20 Service - 6/10 Atmosphere - 6/10 Total - 26/40

Highly, highly recommend this place for pizza A hidden gem, Dave portnoy recently paid this place a visit and gave it a 7.9 I strongly disagree. Born and raised in the bronx and now reside in eastchester, I have eaten from 100's of different pizzas places. I would have to rate this a 8.2 pretty close to his score but definitely not in the 7's . Super thin and crispy and a nice sauce. Pictured above were 2 different pies. Sicilian with meatball Regular pie with meatball...... I suggest you try the meatballs.... thank me later! Buon appetito!

The thin-crust pizza is the best in Westchester in my opinion. It is so uniquely delicious; semolina on the bottom, perfectly cooked crust, amazing cheese, delicious sauce. I eat a large once a week, and it is something I always look forward to. Come here if you value a crispy slice with minimal flop - it’s one of the best.

This is an old school Italian restaurant that specializes in pizza. They don't serve gluten free crust so I couldn't partake. I had sole fish instead while coworkers ate pizza. The restaurant was packed when we went. They serve pasta, but other non pasta dishes like seafood. Overall very good

Over 80 years selling pizza pies and fabulous italian food in Tuckahoe - much history here - typically known for their thin crust delicious Pizza - Love the dining room menu too - Bartenders & wait staff attentive, fun & knowledgeable - prices just right - Bar area always a great time / everyone friendly - best - thin crust - pizza 🍕 pie money can buy. Meatballs, Lasagna, Eggplant Parm, Baked Ziti, broiled Chicken- all on the 💰 money. Private party 🥳 room...Owners Michael, wife Philly & brother John Tavolilla treat you like you've dropped by their home for Sunday dinner 🍽.

Amazing Italian restaurant and the best pizza I've ever had. The whole staff is excellent and the owner and his wife make you feel like family. Everything on the menu is cooked consistently and perfectly, and I've been coming here for over 10 years.

My initial purpose is to sample the pizza. The pizza was crispy the crust flavorful the sauce excellent. I ordered the sausage and meatball pie and it rivaled any pizza from Manhattan. A lady to my left ordered sole with spinach which looked yummy. I will be back again

Always a nice place to bring the family. Unfortunately my last visit my food was cold in the middle and my server who was friendly, but seemed annoyed my wife asked for my food to be reheated. But when my food came back it was very good, and the rest of the staff were great as always. I highly recommend Roma's.

Very family friendly restaurant although they have a separate bar area too. The cavatelli and salmon were good. As was the roasted red pepper salad. I definitely want to go back to try the pizza since everyone seemed to be having that

I’ve had many different pizzas in Westchester including Frank PePes, Johnnys and Flames and this one is by far the best one. I don’t know how many slices I ate that night because I lost count after 4…. Highly recommend.

Very good thin crust pizza. One of the best in Westchester! Very friendly staff.

Fantastic old school, Italian restaurant. Family owned since 1931. Check it and out ask for "Philly." She will take great care of you. Right down the street from my house so I will be visiting often. Definitely get the baked clams.

First time here. We must have driven by it the hundred times. Caprese salad was excellent, the pizza (eggplant and pepper s) was very good crispy and light. We were treated very well. We will be coming back.

I've never been here before but knew this place has existed my whole life. The pizza was amazing ( worth burning the roof of my mouth) the staff was awesome too! I highly recommend it here and I will be back!!

This is one of my favorite places to go out and enjoy a good meal. The people there are great and treat you like family.

It's good the crust is very crunchy

Roma! Roma! What a wonderful family owned Italian Eatery! We’ve been here twice- first time on our own and the second with nine year old son. First time we went for a nice walk along the lake at Twin Lakes Park in Eastchester, NY and wanted to find a place to eat. Our criteria: someplace close-by, not too expensive yet with good food. A search on Four Square and we decided on Roma. Absolute best choice by a landslide! Exceeded our criteria and has become our favorite eatery when we’re in the area. They’re very close. The place has been owned and operated by generations of the same family dating back to the late thirties! Tell me- how often can a restaurant even boast about such an achievement these days? The interior is fairly large with a full service cocktail lounge near the front. And…shouldn’t a respectable Italian place be playing “Ol’ Blue Eyes” to just set the right ambiance? Well, if you’re answer is “Yes”, and it should be, then that’s another initial reason to like this place before even sitting down. If you don’t know who “Ol’ Blue Eyes” is then shame on you! Go add some class credo points and create a playlist of his music, or several. And, by the way that’s coming from a guy who grew up on 80’s-90’s music. First obvious clue to this being a good place is there are a lot of locals frequenting it - and different generations; families with children, younger and older couples as well as large groups celebrating someone, something or other. All good initial signs. Tables are far enough apart with several lining the windows and the lighting is just dim enough to create an individual sense of space at each table. Our server was a sweet helpful woman - friendly, funny, courteous, helpful and prompt. Great! You’re brought a basket of nicely warmed crusty Italian bread - and, as my son said from watching Disney’s “Ratatouille” - “Papa, I k now is going to be good because it has the right type of crunch sound when you break a piece off.” Smart boy; he’s right. And, of course butter to go with it. BTW, don’t be shy about asking for another basket because this is also the type of restaurant with the right answer to that “oh, sure, of course- right away.” None of that sniffy slight sneer look down your server’s nose at you as if you’re an uncouth barbarian. They have whatever you’re inclined to drink- different wines, beers or something from the bar. Moderately priced- so go ahead. BTW, at this point you’ll also notice that the servers have all worked here for sometime- another good sign. And they’re all friendly with one another and seem to know the guests by first name. Who doesn’t like any of that? You feel…that they feel…they like the place and like working there. Well, those are all signs that you’re going to have a good experience here; and you certainly will. They have a full Italian menu and if you just want pizza? Boy…do they HAVE pizza! Collectively, over two visits, we’ve had the following: specialty salad, chicken cacciatore, eggplant parm., a fish entree, different wines, homemade chicken soup, baked ziti and meatballs and, oh; apple juice for my little man. Entrees are large, enough so that almost everyone is seen leaving with a bag-to-go. You will leave Roma’s very sated and very pleased by the food’s amount and flavor. This is a mainstay classic neighborhood eatery with only the positive associations to that moniker. Go here, you’ll thank me I assure you. Bring your children, they’ll like it too. Because there are few places like this in today’s highly combustible cut-throat competitive make or break restaurant culture. We need a place that makes you feel GOOD…in your spirit, in your stomach and yes, in your wallet. Remember I said it’s family owned? For generations? Well, pssst., a little gem of a truth- their secret weapon towards making you feel at home and realizing you just ate at your next go to favorite place? One word; “Filly.” Who? What? “Filly”, like the cream cheese, she’ll be the first to say is one half of the Dynamic Duo couple who run and own the restaurant! Sadly I’ve run out of space!

I have been coming here since the 1970s. Although we don’t live close by any longer, the staff still recognizes us when we come in. No pizza comes close. All of the food is great, but we have to satisfy our pizza cravings whenever we visit.

One of my all time favorite places. I love the pizza, owners and staff! I drive all the way there from Pleasantville and it's well worth the trip.

The pizza is as good as I remember from when I was a kid. Friendly bartender and staff.

Good food and a very friendly staff. They always make you feel welcome

Had the Roma special with my parents. It was excellent!!! Mom really enjoyed it.

BEST PIZZA EVER. Do not walk, RUN to Roma's. Forget the decor, forget the location, forget the rest of the menu items (which are pretty darn good too) and SIT DOWN AND ORDER A PIZZA AND EAT IT THERE. It is life altering. Do not take them to go, they do not transport well. Thin crust pizza rarely does. Get a large pizza, a pitcher of coke/sprite/beer and enjoy. All other pizzas will pale in comparison.