Sluurpy
Reset

There are 5 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Ice Cream in Tonawanda

There are 5 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Dairy Queen
89/100 (1243 ratings)
Dessert
American
American
Ice Cream
Sit down
American
"What can really be said, it's Dairy Queen. This is one of our favorite places to get ice cream and they never disappoint. They have a nice area..."
Eric Gallo
"Even after visiting this location for the last 30 years, they still know how to make a delicious strawberry sundae every single time. I recommend a..."
Kris Z (ZiggyZ)
"It is hard to find DQ that have a freezer inside with ice cream cakes. Even better they will write on them. Lastly, if you call in advance they can..."
Harland K
"Line was well organized outside store till you could go in, and moved quickly, as usually ice-cream was refreshing after working outside all day. Had..."
Barry Foss
Anderson's
87/100 (1652 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Dinner
Lunch
Beef
Ice Cream
Fast food
American
Lunch
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"Good but overpriced. I would eat here more but when i leave I feel like I could of gone somewhere else that was cheaper with the Better quality beef..."
Steven
"Simply the Best. Better than all the rest. You want Roast Beef? They do some of the best. Ice cream? Again, some of the best. I don't come here for..."
Eric Smith
"Love Andersons. Another Buffalo tradition that should not be passed up. Real good Roast Beef and a great selections of ice cream and other frozen..."
Eating Out In WNY
"Anderson’s has a particularly creamy and delicious custard going on, with a rather pleasant texture. Combine that with the fact that they use real..."
Kaszeta
"Visited 9/2021. If you love frozen custard then this is the place for you! They have a huge selection of ice cream treats, lemon ice, milk shakes and..."
Beth McCullough
"Delicious custard! I’d never heard of custard until my family opened a Ritter’s custard shop in my home town. Anderson’s was stellar custard! I..."
Melanie Alfaro
"Went to Anderson's with some local friends. It was a Friday evening so it was quite busy. The prices of the ice cream were reasonable and the staff..."
Ciara Hathaway
"This place is as Western NY as you can get. The roast beef on weck is spot on and always fresh. I would say this place has one of the absolute best..."
Timothy A El Vin
"I just don't understand why frozen custard isn't available all over. But the scarcity does make me greatly appreciate having Anderson's Frozen..."
Lauren Aquino
"I LOVE IT HERE. I came yesterday w/ my sister brother and aunt. We got mint chip icecream, vanilla milkshake, and a chocolate icecream cone. The cone..."
C Playz Roblox
"Always top notch! As a vegetarian, I LOVE the veggie burgers. And let's be honest -- who doesn't live that frozen custard?..."
Caryn Pasciak
Mississippi Mudds
86/100 (2465 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
American
Fast Food
Fast food
American
Dinner
Lunch
Fish
Burger
Ice Cream
Fast food
Fast food
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Mississippi Mudds is one of the things I love about summer in Western New York. It's right on the Niagara River so it is scenic but the best part..."
Scott Banning
"I absolutely love this place, the food is amazingly good. I love the service and I love how they have the top deck to look at the river. Me and my..."
Crystal Filson
"Really good ice cream in a beautiful..."
Dave Talbot
"I have loved their chicken sandwich since I ate my first one at Berrafato's char pit in Clarence back in..."
Bill Pickard
"Always great there. Foods delicious & staff is super..."
Sue Jeffers-Knoop
"I love going to Mudds, yes quality is changing and prices are rising but such is life. Good employees and positive attitudes and just a great..."
Kate Kotecki Lichtenthal
"Great food and a beautiful view of the Niagara River from the upper deck! One of the places I have to go to (if the season permits) when I visit my..."
Christine Green
"Had my 2 Grandson's with me.ordered lunch,came quickly,and very good quality.Then walked across the street and took a walk along the..."
Frank P. Nagy
"Always delicious and fast..."
Catherine Hriczko Boswell
"Great food, relaxing atmosphere by the Niagara..."
Dave Kaminski
"Oh yea! Great hot dogs, French fries, sweet potato fries and service! That hot dog was really good and hit the spot! Nice view of the river even..."
Joanne Krickovich
"Great place to eat! We were across the street sitting at the lake enjoying the view. Since we are from Ohio we were just trying to find places near..."
Brittney Gibson
"Very cute ice cream place that offers outdoor seating to watch the sunset! I ordered twist custard ice-cream in waffle cone, and love it. It is..."
Nov C
"Great seasonal food and ice cream place! They make a surprisingly large variety of items for such a small place and everything is excellent! Burgers,..."
Michael Schmid
"Love this place good food ,they even have plant based items..."
Jason Velazquez
"The chili cheese fries are so good!!! Everything is made to order and cooked just right. I'm not native to NY but it was a great place to stop for a..."
Kianna Owden
"I ordered the seafood sandwich and I had the Louisiana sweet potato fries. The sandwich was a little to sweet for me. I thought it would be a..."
Shawne
"The staff is always kind and the food is amazing! Quick in and out with great patio seating. The top patio is our favorite because it over looks the..."
Lady Love
Old Man River
75/100 (1036 ratings)
Restaurants
Quick Bites
American
American
Dinner
Lunch
Ice Cream
Fish
Burger
Clams
Ribs
Sit down
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Live Music
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"What a fun spot to stop and get a bite to eat! Really cool atmosphere with ample seating. Perfect for those biking the trail along the river. A few..."
Amber Ferger
"Not bad not great. Got the Chicago dog..not quite what I'm used to after living in Chicago. Friendly staff..very accommodating. My kids said their..."
Susan O'neill
"Food was alright, Clams were a little rubbery. Great for a quick seafood..."
Ronnie Coon
"Super quick and efficient. The seafood, BBQ, and burgers/dogs are all different lines so just be aware when you arrive. Can do dine in or take..."
Lindsey Mentzer
"I had a great time tonight with friends at Old Man River. The food was fresh and delicious, the live music on the outdoor stage was awesome, and the..."
Pam Turner
"First time here and definitely not the last! Came here for a mommy/daughter date - she plowed through some steamed clams and I had the most decadent,..."
Blossom Fox
"Poutine is the shining star, only place near me that has authentic poutine with piping hot gravy and real curds. Love the atmosphere and of course..."
Camryn Porter
"Great menu... something for everyone. Delicious food... Live music... indoor or outdoor dining. Beautiful views... wonderful people who support the..."
thomas lalka
Dairy Queen (treat)
75/100 (1336 ratings)
Dessert
Fast Food
Fast food
Ice Cream
Sit down
Fast food
"This is the only location that consistently has all the blizzard flavors, other locations seem to run out throughout the season and don't..."
Becca
"Took my son here and got a Blizzard yum! Came back the next time and Juliana recognized my son and asked him about the bet that we had made about him..."
Lori K
"Nice location. Easy in, easy out. Very crowded when we were in, but the staff got everything done in a timely..."
Robert James, Jr.
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use