Olisi's Ny Pizza

Ordered March 11th 2022. First and last time every eating at this place. Spent $50 on pizza, wings and garlic knots. Garlic knots tasted more like bread knots and were stiff like they sat out for awhile and super dry. The pizza had a ton of grease just sitting on top. My husband tried to dab it with a paper towel and it still had so much grease. The wings weren't extra crispy and were barely sauced. It was so bad we ended up bringing the food back. Some staff were smiling like it was funny but its not. They should be ashamed allowing something like that to be served. Me and my husband both feel sick. I'm surprised cause they had good reviews. I hope someone higher up reads this and seriously makes a change. Pic below is grease that was dapped off of pizza.

Ordered take-out twice. First time I would have given them a 5☆ rating, 2nd time only a 2-3☆ at best. Obvious different cook. Not consistent, which is a giant no-no, but due to 1st visit being extra delicious and fact I like Pagliacci-style pizza, I'll give them one more try, but won't order 2 large pizzas, only one, just in case!

(I would appreciate if you follow and like if this helped you decide which pizza place to order !) I found this place by chance. I was looking for pizza place nearby my favorite pho place. And then I found that this place seemed like a decent NY style pizza place. I ordered ny style cheese pizza with extra sauce. The bottom line is that this place is the best place I've ever tried since I moved to Buffalo. Dough was crispy and chewy which reminded me of a real New York city pizza place. I was also satisfied with an extra sauce. Next time, I will try other menus as well!