Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews (8)
Amazing place. The food was great, we had Chicken Parm Hero and Eggplant Rollatine. The atmosphere is nice and the people that work there bring it all together. I travel quite a bit and love to find hidden gems and TPR is definitely one of those places.
Google
My friend, who lives in Tenafly, told me about TPR. Went for the first time this afternoon for lunch. The luncheon portions are substantial. I ordered capellini with spinach. When I received my order it far exceeded my expectations. The dish was the thinnest spaghetti cooked to perfection (al dente), spinach, roasted red peppers and garlic. It was the balance of flavors that was impressive. The garlic was noticeable but not overwhelming. Go and enjoy well prepared Italian food at reasonable prices. I certainly look forward to going back.
Read more
Google
The calzone was good, the dough and filling were delicious, but the cook could have spread it out to the corners better, instead of heaping it up in the center and leaving unfilled dough on the corners. The dipping sauce however was horrible. It was like a canned sauce without seasoning. I could have made a way better marinara sauce with a little bit of tomato chunks and some finely chopped onions and basil and a touch of oregano.
Read more
Google
The kid that took our order over the phone maybe is young or new but sounded distracted the whole time. They couldn't find our order in the computer when I went to pick up, had to recheck 3 times by name, by phone number, by items, finally they checked name again and saw it. They had to double check what one of the items were to make sure he wrote it right because we had changed our mind on one while placing the phone order. I don't know if that kid was high or what but he just seemed lost and confused lol. The food wasn't bad, but I've had better at other local Italian spots. The veal was such a small portion compared to other places. I will say the MEATBALLS were great. That was the best part of this, definitely get those.
Read more
Google
Almost as good as the original Rudys!
Very good pizza with crunchy crust, good mozzerella and sauce.. so so so close to the best Rudys! We ate inside during the stupid lockdowns of 2020. No masks! We were able to sit down and eat like normal human beings with no masks! Very good! The dinning room is nice. They have lots of tables. Comfy leather seats. Free yummy bread made fresh and hot.
Pros:
Great pizza, almost as good as Rudys
Free yummy bread, fresh and hot
Free parking
Indoor dinning
No masks!
Friendly employees!
Good menu selection
Cons:
None
Suggestions:
Buffalo wings were a bit too hot. Maybe add plain fried wings and a sweet dipping sauce like Grant St or Rudys.
Please add Joes Tea (raspberry, lemon, peach)
And please add diet rootbeer and diet dr pepper
Read more
Google
Met the work family here for a retirement party. The meal started w still warm Italian bread & butter. Appetizers were salad & pizza, both served family style. That was followed by a bowl of delicious penne vodka. For my entree, I ordered eggplant parm, but honestly couldn't even eat it because I was already full. I am very much looking forward to having that for dinner tomorrow.
Read more
Google
Great Italian restaurant and pizzeria! Excellent food variety and friendly employees. They always take care of us when i'm in town visiting family (i'm now in the Midwest). I especially respect the fact that they care about, and treat my autistic brother with understanding and kindness. I love this place!
Read more
Google
Delicious food! The only thing and reason for my 4 stars is their prices! Way over priced for the menu! They are in an affluent town, Tenafly. And can charge any price and they will still patronize the restaurant! Enjoy, bon appetite!
Google
📊 Compare with Other Restaurants
| Restaurant | Score | Tripadvisor | Reviews | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Zhang Zi | 70% | - | 2.0/5 | 1 |
| Simply Vietnamese | 88% | 4.3/5 | 4.0/5 | 930 |
| U'i Shrimp | 70% | - | - | 0 |
| Celebrity Bagels & Restaurant | 80% | 4.1/5 | 4.5/5 | 399 |
| Tea Garden | 74% | 3.3/5 | 3.5/5 | 408 |
| The 130 Club | 97% | 4.8/5 | - | 165 |
