Islamorada Fish Company

The gentleman that took our order was fantastic. He was very personable and polite. Some of the folks in our group wanted specific cooking instructions and they nailed it. Atmosphere was fantastic. The restaurant itself was very clean. Prices are definitely fair for the quality of food you get. Our complements to the chef and cooking staff as the fish fillets we ordered were perfect.

Nice little place, waitstaff and manager very polite. Very impressive structure and their fish tank is also elaborate. It's a little pricey for what you get (I was actually told this in advance by a friend before I went), but that's ok, it's just something I mention because you might want to know in advance. The calamari and shrimp are good. Do not order the clam strips! If you don't believe me, order them. It wont be what you're expecting. I sent mine back and the manager was very accommodating which was good because I felt bad doing that; on the other hand I wasn't paying $25 for what they call clam strips. They didn't make me feel awful about doing it and that was nice. Place could definitely be 5 stars at some point, just isn't quite there yet. Was my first time there and I'll go back again, at least occasionally. It's worth checking out. They are one of very few places here that have alligator and conch fritters, which alone makes it worth a try if you like those things.

We ordered the fish and chips and the fish of the day sandwich. Fish was amazing, flaky batter like a beer batter, not oily very tender fish. Fries were cold didnt eat and slaw was on point, very creamy. The sandwich we ordered was snapper all i can say is i will be ordering it again! Fresh fresh fish! Flaky and tender. Again fries were cold but slaw was creamy.