Review Selah Restaurant - Struthers

I wanted to try this place for a long time since it had such good reviews. Man it was disappointing. Got the crab and shrimp cake appetizer. It was frozen solid in the middle. They replaced it with the fried mozzarella which was not very good either. Honestly I’ve had much better at a regular old concession stand. My friend’s steak was so burned he had to cut the outer layer off to be able to eat it. I got the sausage tortellini which was just ok after adding copious amounts of salt and pepper. Best thing was probably the salad, so yeah. Pretty disappointing.

Had shrimp Florentine linguine. It was yummy and had lunch for my wife the next day.

Looking forward to the gnocchi all week. How the hell does an Italian restaurant run out of gnocchi @ 6pm on a Saturday night? Response: "We have been busy making our Easter breads." So to hell with our menu items, we make more money selling our bread? Yes I gave 4 stars. The food, drinks,dessert, atmosphere was very good.. But when you drop $100.00+ for two people to eat pasta and then they don't have the pasta you want? I see you reserved my table using name cards. If I order my food when I make my reservation can you put my name on it until I get there? Maybe one more time........maybe.....

Brought my wife for her 30th with 2 friends. The food was great! The fried mozzarella was awesome along with all of our cocktails. My wife and her friend couldn't say enough great things about their espresso martinis! Between the steaks, gnocchi combo, and pecan crusted chicken I think everyone left more that satisfied. Only complaint, and seems to be common, was our server disappearing for long periods of time.

Very cozy and interesting atmosphere. The homemade bread and desserts are awesome. Food was fresh and tasty. Service was great. First time there today but will be back!

Selah restaurant is a hidden gem! Selah has been open 15 years but still remains fresh and new feeling. This amazing restaurant features delicious made from scratch Italian cuisine in a romantic atmosphere. Selah's embraced the features from the historic bank formally at the location in a unique and stylish way! From the beautiful marble tellers counters to the private dining vault Selah's style is sure to impress. Have an expresso on the patio, a lunch with friends, or romantic dinner with your significant other Selah's is the place to go. We were told Selah's has live music throughout the summer too. We can not wait to come back and visit again. Our dinner started with fresh baked Italian bread, warm olive and roasted peppers, followed with mussels and the best gnocchi I have ever eaten, and finished with lattes.

It's like a little piece of Manhattan fell from the heavens into the charming town of Struthers, Ohio! The atmosphere is sophisticated with the reminiscence of a once bustling bank! You can almost see the patreons wearing their Sunday best to complete their bank exchanges! Really a great vibe all around with the staff being professional, as well as friendly! Now, the food! My husband and I are extremely particular when it comes to the quality of foods that we take in! I'm a vegetarian and my husband eats limited meat products. We were so pleased with our meals, that now, on a yearly basis, we visit them for an early dinner! We live in Pittsburgh so we make it a day trip! Hoping I can upload my photo to show how quaint the enviroment is and scrumptious the food looks!

I’m a picky guy , and I’ve been traveling all over the europe , tried all the restaurants around youngstown and so on . But the food, the drinks and the experience is on another levele here. Also our hostess Reggie, the bartender and our server Theresa were amazing.