The best 10 restaurants and places to eat in Stock Island, May 2024

Hogfish Bar And Grill

88/100 (11847 ratings)

Restaurants

Gluten Free Options

Bar

Vegetarian Friendly

Soups

Bar

Seafood

Vegan Options

American

Seafood

American

Gluten Free Options

Vegetarian Friendly

Vegan Options

Brunch

Dinner

Lunch

Late Night

Ceviche

Calamares

Sandwiches

Burger

Shrimp and Grits

Cakes

Fish

Chowder

Pork

Fish & Chips

Shrimp

Lobster Roll

Tapas

Fish Taco

Tacos

Lobster

Ribs

Salad

Fish Sandwich

Fish & chips

Crab

Scallops

Tortillas

Calamari

Key lime pie

Tuna

Sit down

American

Seafood

Bar

Outdoor Seating

Takeout

Seating

Television

Table Service

Accepts Mastercard

Wheelchair Accessible

Accepts Visa

Accepts American Express

Live Music

Serves Alcohol

Waterfront

Gift Cards Available

Accepts Discover

Parking Available

Highchairs Available

Full Bar

Accepts Credit Cards

Family style

Dog Friendly

Brunch

Dinner

Lunch

Late Night

Mid-range

"Find this place!! You’ll think you might get mugged on the way. You won’t. You will find a locals place on Stock Island that you’ll tell your..."

Cliff

"Always receive excellent food. I love the fact that they have chef's specials, which are not the "usual" meals you see everywhere else. And they have..."

Stanislav Komsky | Maryland AG

"A little bit off the beaten path but outdoor atmosphere and service was great! I had coconut shrimp, rice and the hogfish margarita. All were..."

Smilvey

"Down side; they allow smoking. Upside, great drinks, great service, great food. Ceviche rocks! Do your Duval thing then get to Stock island for..."

J. Hed

"A dear friend that lives in Key West took us slightly off the beaten path to this wonderful place. Very low key on the water.. picnic tables.. cold..."

Meredith Ann Carter

"Great food, great atmosphere. Parking is annoying, only downside is we sat in the sun which was fine but we went through water so fast and waitress..."

Alexis S.

"Well worth the drive to Stock Island. The signature hogfish sandwich is excellent. The grouper Ruben is also excellent. The sides and salads are..."

Sue Ann

"Ate here after a deep sea fishing trip. Took the captains with us for lunch. They cooked our fresh Blackfin Tuna three different ways, all of which..."

HungryGirl

"The Hogfish Grill. The place where the Conchs go. Populated by Fresh Water Conchs as well. I learned a little vernacular on my trip to The Conch..."

Robert Johnson

"It is amazing place is on waterfront in stock island..i love it ....wowwww it is really excellent sea food . service is also good.the special thing..."

Andrew Pogson

"This is local, authentic and off off the tourist route. A real cheeky hut feel bar and grill. Feels like old Key West from the 80's...."

Chill Travelers

"Conch fritter here are excellent!!!! Lobster bisque was good but cane out Luke warm. Very fun place great atmosphere. Service was also very good,..."

Frogpawg

"We heard about this place from a friend who used to live in Key West, she said it was hard to find but we had to eat there. She was right. The food..."

Chrismelody

"By far the best place I've been to in Key West. It's off the beaten path, away from the Duval experience. You get the seafood feel by its on the..."

Matt Gilley

"Totally off the beaten path. Thought I was lost the first time I came here. But it's become my go-to place for shrimp and fries when in town. ..."

AZ

"Hands down, one of the best meals of my life! We had the lobster bisque, crab stuffed hogfish, shrimp and grits, and the mixed grill. Everything was..."

Kai

"Great Local Hangout. Nice, quiet, relaxing little restaurant/bar to eat and have drinks. Our server, Karen was great!! Never had to ask for anything,..."

Angela Garner

"Perfect atmosphere for a beach restaurant (ie. napkins on the..."

Jordan Wolfinger

"This is a must stop place to eat when in the key west area. The whole family loved their food. Amazing atmosphere accompanied by such great food!..."

Derrick D

"Sooooo Good!!. This place is unreal. The hogfish tacos and shrimp ceviche were the best ever. Want to eat there every..."

LaLaMike

"Hogfish heaven. Loved the location (ask to sit on the deck), friendly service and laid back vibe. The hogfish tacos were excellent, my only complaint..."

Pascalle

"This place is awesome! The food was outstanding, and the service was incredibly friendly. It isn't the easiest place to find, but you'll be happy..."

DJ

"True hogfish tacos. . ...."

JCW

"Great little dive.. If you want something fancy, this isn't your place. But good food, reasonable prices, and a friendly staff make it a great..."

Kear30

"Yes HogFish. Great food, cold drinks, great atmosphere and friendly prompt service. All 5 in our party got different items and all were..."

Coach

"Just ok but hoping for better. I wanted to like this place, I really wanted to have an awesome time here, but it was just ok.Stopped in on..."

Vgonzalez2034

"Went to Hogfish on a recommendation from our Charter Boat Captain while on vacation. Glad we listened. My wife had their seafood enchiladas..."

Kevin O'Neill

"We visited this summer a found this restaurant via a kayaking mike marker guide. It was such a pleasant discovery. Mostly locals, fantastic..."

Ashley

"The smoked fish spread is awesome. Fresh grouper sandwiches. Lots of lobster in the lobster bisque and conk in the conk chowder. At the..."

Marty

"Lively fun place. Go during happy hour & get the terrific smoked fish dip. Also loved the fish..."

KUhoopsNut

"Good atmosphere. Let's start with the bad. Not the easiest to get to and the neighborhood isn't ideal. My friends questioned my suggestion for this..."

JoeF

"The conch chowder is superb! Highly recomend this place - friendly..."

Louis Fernandez

"Worth the trip to Stock Island. Great fish sandwich. The asparagus crab soup was perfectly spiced. Overall a wonderful outdoor dining..."

Food Is Fun

"Had the lobster blt, I swear I had two tails on each sandwich half. Great atmosphere, good food, stiff drinks and great view. Definitely coming back..."

Travis B.

"I felt like a..."

Stacey Seward-Vandiver

"YUM FISH TACOS. Best I've ever had. Can't wait to go back and see the rest of the..."

Gia

"A definite bang for your buck. The food was incredable! Portion size was great and the service friendly,accomidating and prompt! Great for..."

Glenn

"Worth the Visit. If you want to get away from the busyness of Duval Street this is a good escape. Do not let the part of town scare you, the food is..."

Hubby_88

"If you happen to have a car in Key West, I strongly recommend heading over to Stock Island to visit the Hogfish Bar & Grill. It is a bit challenging..."

Erika Grimm

"Good Food.. First time I tried hogfish - delish! I thought it was expensive (15.95 for a sandwich) but it was..."

Lelli

"The food was very good. Hogfish sandwich , we enjoyed an would definitely come back. Cannot beat the price..."

John Eric Ibert

"This is a true diamond in the rough. Food is great and you can't beat the prices. Little hard to find but with google maps it was a..."

Armando

"Great Seafood. We stopped off for dinner here last October the service and food were very..."

Josette

"Best kept local secret. Freshest seafood in..."

SolDesigns.net

"Out of the beaten path, but worth it!. Traveled by scooter fifteen minutes to this restaurant. After cruising through some dimly lit streets, I was..."

Emily Martin

"Great Atmosphere, Fun Place. Hogfish Bar & Grill is located on Stock Island right by working docks. Open air location has a great atmosphere and the..."

HookemHorns

"Happy with the Hogfish. First off, ask for the dockside view! We asked the hostess which place was best to sit and eat and she said(in a friendly..."

Laura Adams

"Love It. Good food, good drinks, and I like the location. Old Keys style place. Some might not like the neighborhood or surroundings, but its worth..."

Kempshark

"Found it finally..... It gets a thumbs up for being pet friendly and great attentive staff, however, food was lacking a little in orginality and..."

Forkingitup

"A true bit of old Florida Keys style.. This is a throwback to a simpler time. Gritty, old salt crowd, excellent seafood and great drinks. Served with..."

Chartacourse

"Difficult to find but worth it. I wouldn't say Hogfish was the 10 that everyone claimed but it was an easy 8. Our server, Lisa, was wonderful...."

Sarah

"For some of us, visiting the Keys isn't about just taking a simple vacation. It's also a quest to find the perfect fish sandwich, served in an..."

Chalin'

"A fun place to eat. The food was excellent. Portions were perfect and the sides were fresh asparagus and coconut rice pilaf. Way better than frozen..."

Bryan Zevotek

"Really good. DELICIOUS lobster bisque. I've been there a couple of times and prefer to sit outside next to the..."

C. Cain

"Love it! A must. I can't say enough about Hogfish. We eat there probably once a month and love their food....the hogfish sandwich is fabulous, their..."

K Starfish

"Fresh fish, on the marina where shrimp & lobster boats come in, great server, sit outside,,,ahhhhhhhhhhhhhh! Have smoked fish spread...yum! Cerviche..."

Lynne

"Locals place. Good drinks good food, might be tough to find, but worht the trip on stock..."

Richie Rich

"Def will come back again!. Their KW pink shrimp is super good that we ordered twice. Their hogfish is nicely cooked as well, tender and juicy. We..."

Relyon

"Yum! My only regret is not ordering a larger portion of the KW..."

Joel

"Two words says it all. Fresh fish. So good. You got check this place out on Stock..."

MTR

"Definetly a locals place. Good food and good music. A little hard to find but worth..."

Jen

"It’s also a quest to find the perfect fish sandwich, served in an authentic Keys restaurant on the waterfront. After conferring with the locals,..."

Chalin'

"Enchanted place. Right on the water. Delicious food. Amazing views. Typical Keys ambiance where you get to enjoy your time and their food. Prices..."

Daniel Ocampo

"This was our first time there and the food was just outstanding. Our server was extremely helpful. Everyone had the hogfish that was grilled and..."

Charles Monico

"Lovely place for seafood, music, and a nice atmosphere. We ordered hogfish and conch ceviche. Craig Jolly gave some nice performance with his nice..."

Rosa Z

"Our first time here. We wanted to try something different and saw all the reviews and pics. Great food, super-duper fast service, atmosphere is 6..."

D Harvin

"Way off the beaten path, but well worth the effort. Ceviche is fantastically seasoned with conch, shrimp, fish, and calamari. Coconut shrimp with..."

Tim Summers

"This was a great place to get some pink Key West shrimp and a Hogfish sandwich. Excellent food. Excellent..."

Scott Mueller

"Food was very salty but still good. The buffalo shrimp was so yum. The atmosphere and live music was also..."

Lizzie Dowling

"Hogfish Grill has been hyped up to me for so long because of the sandwich. It was a little bit of a hike for us to get there (we rented a golf cart),..."

James H

"This is the spot to start your culinary trip in Key West, hands down! The fish tacos are definitely worth to try, either the mahi ones or the hog..."

Daniela Anaya

"Casual atmosphere sit down dining (mostly long family style benches, dimmer lighting, kid friendly). Service was exceptionally efficient and fast..."

Sean Hyde

"The restaurant is next to a dock yo loved the atmosphere. We were here in the evening time during sunset. We tried Hogfish the first time, and..."

Snehal Jadhav

"Great atmosphere for a beach bar. Food was delicious and came out quickly for our large party. Service was excellent. The Jamaican jerk wings were..."

Jeremy Pizzi

"Great out of the way place to have some great food. A little hard to find but worth the..."

Robert Mueller

"Yummy. Get the hogfish platter for the most succulent fish with a hint of tropical coconut. Just follow the signs once your on stock island. ..."

Matt Davies Realtor

"One of the most popular places for seafood and drinks. Located on Stock Island right on the docks with great views. The must try is the famous..."

Jim Pitman

"Was recommended this restaurant from a local, and it was by far the best food I’ve had on my entire trip! Service was great! Our server Ervin was..."

Melly P.

"My seafood dinner was “dock to dish” grilled swordfish with blackened shrimp. Absolutely delicious. My husband enjoyed the hogfish tacos and we..."

Diane Donahue

"Very island-laid-back environment. Food was absolutely wonderful and our server was great as well. We shared the fish dip appetizer, and ordered the..."

Jessica Jones

"Excellent service and a wide variety of food options will be a hit! We had the hogfish sandwich with fries and the beer broiled shrimp. Both were..."

Reset

There are 8 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Stock Island restaurants

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Cliff

Stanislav Komsky | Maryland AG

Smilvey

J. Hed

Meredith Ann Carter

Alexis S.

Sue Ann

HungryGirl

Robert Johnson

Andrew Pogson

Chill Travelers

Frogpawg

Chrismelody

Matt Gilley

AZ

Kai

Angela Garner

Jordan Wolfinger

Derrick D

LaLaMike

Pascalle

DJ

JCW

Kear30

Coach

Vgonzalez2034

Kevin O'Neill

Ashley

Marty

KUhoopsNut

JoeF

Louis Fernandez

Food Is Fun

Travis B.

Stacey Seward-Vandiver

Gia

Glenn

Hubby_88

Erika Grimm

Lelli

John Eric Ibert

Armando

Josette

SolDesigns.net

Emily Martin

HookemHorns

Laura Adams

Kempshark

Forkingitup

Chartacourse

Sarah

Chalin'

Bryan Zevotek

C. Cain

K Starfish

Lynne

Richie Rich

Relyon

Joel

MTR

Jen

Chalin'

Daniel Ocampo

Charles Monico

Rosa Z

D Harvin

Tim Summers

Scott Mueller