A new favorite spot for me, super under rated place. Excellent vodka sauce I get the grandpa pie aka "old school" margarita Sicilian but with vodka sauce. The Domenico's special pie is also amazing with grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella and balsamic glaze. Great quality crispy fried calamari, good size rings. Ordered 3 times was very happy all 3 times.
Love this place. Made the mistake of trying a different pizzeria tonight due to seeing a hyped up FB post, well I will not make that mistake again. Domenico's has been consistently fresh, good quality and great staff. Their Caesar salad pizza is delicious! I guess trying a different place made me appreciate Domenico's even more.
Great food,great staff i love it.
Domenicos pizzeria on Bay Terrace is my favorite pizzeria, i been ordering for a while from them and i allways will .
Keep up with good work guys The Best
Very good pizza. My kids are picky about pizza. They always love it and Im ordering from here almost 3 times a week. They never disappoint!.
This place is great. Ive tried all the places in the area and I can comfortably say this is the best pizzaria in the area. Try our their buffalo chicken pizza for sure.
Wonderful food, certainly more that just a pizzeria. Salads of all kinds and all dishes are generous servings. Guaranteed to enjoy the food and the service. It has become our go-to place for a quick, delicious but reasonably priced meal or a quick slice (or two). The owners are all so nice and really make sure their customers enjoy! Thanks Dom, Kim and Val for such delightful times at your place. Updated: 2/28/22, great food here has gotten even better!
Really good food!!! The vodka slices and paninis are my favorites!!!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Staten Island
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes