Sluurpy
Reset

There are 4 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best New York Style Pizza in St. Augustine

There are 4 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Carmelo's Marketplace
90/100 (864 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Salad
Veggie Pizza
Garlic Knots
Wings
Fried Zucchini Sticks
Calamari
Spinach Pepperoni Calzone
White Pizza Slice
Ham and Bacon Pizza
Tiramisu
Cheese and Pepperoni Slices
Cheesesteak
Supreme Pizza by the Slice
Meatballs
Kids Spaghetti & Marinara
Lasagne
Sandwiches
Meat Pizza
New York Style Pizza
Peppers
Pesto
Wine
Fried Mushrooms
Greek salad
Meatball Sub
Stromboli
Italian Sandwich
Pasta
Veggie Supreme Pizza
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Cheap Eats
"We go to Carmelo's often, mostly for the pizza. We live in Palm Coast and have tried pizza from about 10 places in town and none can measure up to..."
June Allen
"I had the Carmelo's stuffed pizza, it was very flavorful. While I was in line for my take out order all 3 people ahead of me said it was the best ..."
Tammy Cruikshank
"Delicious pizza! Don't let the connection to the gas station fool you- this place is a fun atmosphere with great..."
Sara Boden Pickering
"Second time in 3 years we have eaten here! Great food with generous portions. And the pizza is served on a raised silver tray giving it the..."
Rhea Allard Kennelly
"Always a great place to eat! Great food & friendly..."
Carol Kline
"The pizza is incredible and the buffalo wings are the absolute best wings I've ever had! I always come here whenever I visit St...."
Violet Olsen
Pizza Time Of St Augustine
84/100 (3331 ratings)
Restaurants
Fast food
Pizza
Fast Food
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Lasagne
Cannoli
Ice Cream
Gelato
New York Style Pizza
Eggplant
Salad
Sit down
Fast food
Pizza
Italian
Takeout
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Pushy staff and cash only but very good pizza. Very crowded but I guess that's what you get when your voted 2nd best pizza in the USA. Love the..."
Abigail Renee' Davis
"Best pizza in the south east!! The line is typically out the door during lunch time but do not panic it moves fast and is worth the wait. The..."
Ximena Barnes
"Pedimos 4 trozos diferentes de pizzas y todas estaban deliciosas. Tienen una masa fina y crujiente, y suficientes ingredientes que no decepcionan. La..."
Francisca Orellana
"The pizza's are great here. They have so many different types of gourmet pizzas - Eggplant pizza, Hawaiian, Lasagna pizza, Chicken and Spinach, Pizza..."
Alayna Shergill
"This pizza place is good not excellent.WHATCH OUT THEY ONLY ACCEPT C A S Hand if u dont have cash, dont worry, the also will..."
Elle
"The pizza was really tasty. The have the really nice red pepper blend that added heat and flavor to any slice it was added to. I'd definitely go..."
Nicoli Delchimsky
"Amazing pizza!! Our family of 4 ate really well on $30!! We will definitely be coming back. Only thing to know ahead of time is that's it's CASH ONLY..."
Holly Ford
"I was visiting St. Augustine and stopped for dinner at Pizza Time on St. George Street. St. Augustine's Christmas parade apparently happened earlier..."
Watch Me Eat
"So, if someone would have told me I would make this statement, I would deny it to the very end, but I am here to put it in writing today. ƂĀ I..."
Anna Heise
"These guys have a trip advisor review stating that they have the second best pizza in America and after trying the "grandmas" and the pepperoni I'd..."
Dan Meadows
"I'm not a pizza fan, but boy oh boy has pizza time converted me! Amazing is all I can say. Has all the Brooklyn flavor and then some. Thank you for a..."
LeLe D
"Night = made!. When we got there around 9:30, there was only a few selections of pizza left. I'll preface this by saying that I eat like a 3 year..."
Sam H.
"5 stars. Pizza Time not only has the best pizza in town, it has the best restaurant owner I've met in my 72 years. He was very graceful to my family..."
Robert Bob Smith
"Grandmas style pizza was so amazing. As weere the garlic..."
Zachary McDonald
"Love this place! Huge slices of delectable, flavorful pizza. Margherita pizza was awesome! Great place though not a lot of seating inside. But the..."
Visitor
"Beyond amazing, probably the best pizza I've ever..."
Mikaila Hall
"Never ate a new york style pizza before, and is 10 time better than all pizza..."
Lisa Negron
"Great pizza always. Love the garlic rolls. Yes you have to pay with cash and there is a ATM on the premises. Don't be discouraged by the line to get..."
Krystal
"Pizza time is phenomenal!! The owner, Domenic, is very personable and makes the experience memorable! There are other pizza options in St Augustine..."
Ken B
"We tried a bunch if slices, white, lasagna, pry outta, pepperoni, cheese, they were all really..."
MJ
"Delicious large slices of pizza! (Not much seating in restaurant..."
FrasJF
"Excellent! Great flavor. Loved..."
K
"Most amazing pizza we've even ate cant wait to bring the kids..."
Jennifer Crawford
"The best pizza in town.. Hands down Pizza Time has the best pizza in St. Augustine. It.s done just right. I've been there a hundred time, and can't..."
Mike F.
"Hands Down: The Best Pizza in St. Augie. As a transplanted New Yorker, I often pine for the type of pizza I grew up with down at Sal's on Mam'k..."
Table For Two
"Great pizza. No need for long winded stories with this place, probably the best pizza that I have ever..."
Bob Zingloc
"Best NY Style Pizza in St Augie!! Staff were awesome!!!Not your average pizza joint, we ate here almost everyday of our..."
Jennifer Finch
"Loved it! My husband and I each got a slice and shared them. It was huge and only $4 for a slice. The employees were friendly. We also tried a..."
Aubrey
"Best pizza in Florida!!! The owners are great & are actually from NY! Real NYC pizza..."
Jennifer
"Pizza Pizzaz. I have not yet eaten a pizza slice there that did not hit the spot in all the right ways!By far, Pizza Time is THE BEST PIZZA..."
Lisa Averill
"THE BEST pizza place in St..."
Barb Leaders
"By the slice quality. Outstanding pizza with lots of variety, reasonable price and great service. Had a slice of lasagna pizza and a slice of the..."
BillPG
"Divine! Not an exaggeration. I had the breaded eggplant pizza Perfect sauce. Perfect amount of basil. Perfect crust. Best pizza I've had in a while...."
Erin Hope
"Best in Town. When the pizza guy across the street from you needs a carnival barker(pizza alley) just to get people to come in the door then you know..."
Ross
"Love it!. My boyfriend and I went recently and I had their white pizza and he had the Hawaiian. The white pizza was INCREDIBLE! We also got some..."
FoodFan
"Best Pizza in St Augustine!! Direct from Brooklyn, this true New York pizza is the most tantalizing pizza in town for your..."
StAugustineLocal
"The best pizza I've had. This place is about ten times better than most pizza places. They have a great creative selection. Remember, cash only and..."
Knh
"Best pizza in town!. You can't go wrong with the grandma's pizza, breaded eggplant, or meatball contandino!If you want to go in for a slice..."
Chunt
"Hands down the best in town. I am from New Jersey and have had the best of the best when it comes to food. Let me tell you this is legit New York..."
Elizabeth Betancourt
"Pizza tastes awesome!!! Staff was very friendly. Will return for sure when I come back. Like bringing Brooklyn to..."
Weaksauce
"Finger-Licking Good!. This pizza is amazing! from the thick dough to the sauc to the cheese and other fresh toppings. its definitely a must if your..."
SimplyDelicious
"This place when it first opens a few years ago was great now the staff all seem to have bad attitudes and never smile only the owner is nice and he's..."
Cara
Antonio's Ii New York Style Pizza
79/100 (481 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Lasagne
Gyros
New York Style Pizza
Pesto
Pasta
Salad
Wings
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Takeout
Television
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Delivery
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
Borrillo's Pizzeria And Beer & Wine Garden
77/100 (467 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Risotto
Roast Beef
Cheesesteak
Meatballs
Sandwiches
Lasagne
Cannoli
Baked Ziti
Philly Cheesesteak
New York Style Pizza
Eggplant
Pesto
Pasta
Salad
Fast food
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Parking Available
Accepts Visa
Free off-street parking
Accepts American Express
Highchairs Available
Street Parking
Delivery
Live Music
Outdoor Seating
Accepts Discover
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use