The best Paella in St. Augustine | Sluurpy updated in June

Casa Maya Restaurant

76/100 (2363 ratings)

Restaurants

Vegetarian Friendly

Spanish

Latin

Gluten Free Options

Spanish

Mexican

Central American

Latin

Central American

Vegan Options

Mexican

Vegetarian Friendly

Gluten Free Options

Vegan Options

Brunch

Dinner

Lunch

Late Night

Burrito

Tortillas

Pancakes

Fajitas

Omelette

Salad

Octopus

Crab

Hanger steak

Oyster

Ceviche

Mussels

Paella

Queso

Tapas

Fish Taco

Cakes

Tacos

Lamb

Shrimp

Fish

Beef

Pork

Sit down

Latin

Mexican

Central American

Spanish

Outdoor Seating

Takeout

Accepts Mastercard

Accepts Visa

Accepts American Express

Reservations

Live Music

Seating

Table Service

Accepts Discover

Wheelchair Accessible

Serves Alcohol

Highchairs Available

Full Bar

Accepts Credit Cards

Dinner

Lunch

Late Night

Mid-range

"We drive all the way from Jacksonville for this Mexican food. It is the best in all of North Florida. The Ceviche is something else, we love to throw..."

Brianna Carmen

"Fabulous, Authentic Mexican cuisine at its finest! A very classy twist on Sangria you can’t go wrong with white or red recipe. Staff was polite and..."

Prncesa Cristina

"We had dinner there yesterday evening. I ordered the lamb� and it was absolutely delicious!� I highly recommend that dish and this restaurant...."

Guillermo Delacruz

"Stopped in for the first time for brunch and the food was amazing! Sat outside and had great service. The oyster shooter is a must try!!! Great place..."

Christina M Campbell

"My husband and I recently enjoyed a delightful lunch at Casa Maya. The food was fresh and delicious with ample choices. The bar was also very..."

Heather Alonge

"My girlfriend had shrimp tacos I had the mahi-mahi tacos !! It was awesome! Place was clean and in order , the waiter was on point with all of the..."

Jerry Wholaver

"Amazing atmosphere, service, and delicious food! Enjoyed amazing cocktails before dinner on the patio and the wait flew..."

Alexander Healey

"This was an awesome place, great food ,great atmosphere. We will definitely go..."

Shirley Woodlee

"Excellent food and service. I highly recommend the mahi..."

Jodi Garland

"Great vegetarian menu. Delicious fresh food and staff was..."

Lisa Willow Dunne

"The food was cooked to perfection. I had the green burrito and it had jist the right amount of rice, beans, and veggies and not too much cheese. ..."

Patty Gamez

"This was our second time here....The first time was awesome so we brought my in-laws with us and the second time was just as fabulous as the first!..."

Gabe Saldivar

"Loved it! Awesome vegan burrito, fresh veggies, black beans, avocado and salsa plus a small container of venegrette because I didn't get cheese...."

Marilu Dempsey

"Scott, Liam & I had late brunch here today; it was very tasy! I had the Hangover Skillet with over-easy eggs, potatoes, peppers, onions and chorizo...."

Cindy Ross

"I've eaten here twice. Both times the food was delicious. First time I had the carnitas, the second time the shrimp tacos and black beans and rice...."

Baldibanks

"A-flipping-Mazing. We sat at bar on patio, drinks were amazing, oysters were perfect, we're coming back for breakfast. I recommend cucumber..."

K8Bro

"I got the vegetarian burrito. It was filled with veggies, wrapped in a green tortilla, and covered with salsa. The guacamole was so tasty! The black..."

Laura

"Need service training. This is a great restaurant with delicious food and drink menu. We have repeatedly had bad service the last 3 times we've dined..."

Lynn

"The Hot Chocolate in the Mug is Great...."

Paniaguausedcars

"Had dinner with my friends and everything was AMAZING!! The food was delicious, great service and the Margaritas. Everything is fresh and with great..."

Food Lover

"Delicious food and fun atmosphere. Definitely a St. Augustine favorite. Cozy tiny restaurant with GREAT..."

Miccosukeerootcellar

"Fantastic flavors. Mango on fish was fantastic. Not very many options for..."

Emily

"We had the cochinita pibil platter and queso fundido and sangria! We are delighted, the queso is amazing! We shared the main dish and the Mayan..."

Rc

"Great food and service. Highly recommend the freshly made guacamole appetizer, chicken quesadilla and flan. Will definitely..."

Mary

"Impressed!. Delectable food and excellent service! Be sure to stop by and at least try their Mayan..."

Withasideofpeanutbutter

"Amazing food and great atmosphere. Very friendly staff, the food is excellent, we ordered the chicken Quesadilla, mushroom and maya soup and steak..."

Danielle

"Absolutely fabulous!! We eat here each time we come to St. Augustine. It gets better each time. We loved the Mayan soup, Aztec pork, Xaman-Ha Mahi,..."

Mandy Lancaster

"What a pleasant surprise! My wife and I were floored with the quality of the food at Casa Maya. We couldn't get a seat at out favorite French..."

Joe

"Restaurants like this are the reason people are addicted to food!!! LOL! If you want a perfect lunch out or dinner this is the place to go. I have..."

M

"Quaint relaxing atmosphere, friendly service, unique menu, fabulous fresh food. I am a vegetarian and had many many great options to choose from..."

Tiffany Klemetson

"My husband and I recently stumbled upon Casa Maya on a recent trip to St. Augustine. I did an Urbanspoon search and since the restaurant had a good..."

Debbie Keneipp

"Decent guac but awesome salsa. Everyone hypes the guac but I thought the salsa was so much tastier. Thick with a lot of flavor just excellent. Guac..."

Elduder

"Atypical Mexican. In general we liked the food here, though it's not your typical Mexican fare....... Nopales salad anyone? My carne was very good,..."

Janderwee

"Overall the setting and food were very good. The only part I didn't like was the chips and salsa....not good enough for a restaurant serving spanish..."

Justine Cyr

"EXCELLENT!! If you are considering Casa Maya or Acapulco, its not even comparable. The guacamole and salsa is absolutely incredible, as well as the..."

LKA

"Delicious food, fantastic service. We had a great lunch, the owner Marco was very thoughtful and attentive. Would definitely come..."

Maria

"Best Breakfast in Town. When ever we visit St Augustine, we have to stop here at least once for breakfast. Their chilaquiles are..."

Belle

"Absolutely delicious! You should get the queso fundido. If they ask you if you want to try the habanero hot sauce, say yes! It was awesome. I had the..."

Peggy

"Tikin Xic fish was amazing and the roasted chicken with green sauce just as flavorful. Friendly staff was amazing. Excellent..."

Trinette101

"Found this place last night while searching restaurants on urban spoon....Awesome! Good food, great service...ask for outside seating for the..."

Mrs. A

"Casa Maya is a must stop when in St. Augustine. Dined there this evening & dinner was above excellent! I went for the special suggested by our..."

Tommy Y

"Mmmmm!. Amazing food, wow.. This is easily my favorite restaurant in St. Augustine. We got grouper tacos and a Pepito steak sanwhich and a basket of..."

Kelly

"SUPER GOOD!!!. Great mexican food! TOP notch! great options for vegetarians! GO HERE best meal in St...."

Danneskjold

"Best guacamole on the face of the earth and the tortilla soup is possibly the best soup ever created. Ever. Seriously,..."

Stauggirl

"Best fish tacos I've ever had!!! Organic everything which I love as..."

Jennifer Nelson

"Loved it. My boyfriend and i were at st. Augustine for the weekend and we had breakfast at casa maya on sunday morning and the food was delicious,..."

Nubia Roman

"Amazing food. Wait staff took great care of us. There is a house Pinot if u like that to try its..."

Vicki

"I went to lunch and had an amazing experience. Im gluten intolerant and they were happy to swich any items on the menu i couldn't eat. Really enjoyed..."

Brannon

"The best sangria in town. This is where the locals eat. Don't miss..."

Brian Hasty

"Little House, Big Flavor. As locals, we are always looking for downtown restaurants that not only please us, but also the many friends from out of..."

Table For Two

"We ate here last night. Hole in the wall is an understatement! But delicious food!! We ate on the outside patio and enjoyed everything we had. Will..."

Jamye Phillips

"Sitting here now, enjoying the lamb and the carnitas. We just stumbled onto the place. What a find. Will definitely be..."

Christopher Jackson

"Tucked away on a side street in downtown St Augustine is a jewel of a restaurant. I had the chicken wrap and it was the best I have ever had. Will be..."

John Tesh

"Holy Mole Chicken is excellent as is the guacamole. Will be going back again..."

Linda

"Great authentic Mexican food! Exceptional dinner. Small an unassuming this was the best Mexican food we've had in Florida. Thanks to a friend who..."

SC

"Delicioso!. The breakfast is my favorite here! Sweetwater coffee is outstanding. Smoothies are refreshing. The meals are creative and authentic..."

2Romos

"Awesome place. Finally found the best mole in..."

Jeff Thomas

"Impressed. My family and I usually eat at the Columbian which is right up the road from this small restaurant. Very casual dining. I had the shrimp..."

Suz

"Chips and guacamole are a little pricey at $8 but I would have to agree with them that they have the best guacamole in town. I had the fish tacos..."

Aaron Kleyla

"I love everything here. Would eat here everyday if I could...."

Meme TimesTwo

"My husband and I were there for lunch and we had the guacamole appetizer and the fish tacos and shrimp tacos. Awesome food, great service. Will be..."

StAugustineMom

"Delicious!. Everything we had was great. Loved the Sangria & the..."

Sharon

"A MUST TRY IN ST AUGUSTINE!. I've eaten at Casa Maya several times now and each time it gets better and better! It's not your traditional Mexican..."

Pat Piper

""Mayan Soup" We always eat here when we are in St. Augistine and have never been disappointed. Love a bowl of Mayan soup for a..."

RIchard

"Closed on Tuesdays. I always come here for lunch when ever I am in st Augustine. Nice..."

Darth Smith

"Great Place, Better Food!. Such a great restaurant. A must if you love authentic Mexican. Great family run place. Love..."

DE

"Not your ordinary Mexican food. The steak tacos were..."

Patrick Sikes

"LOVE IT. One of the top-5 restaurants in St. Augustine. The food is unique and the soups are..."

Rob Wenger

"Excelent stat of the day!. WOW! Mary and I had breakfast here this morning and enjoyed greatly. We both had the vegetarian omelette. it brings a..."

Brian

"Hot sauce!. I just got a Cuban and a beer and the Cuban was good...but the most memorable thing was the hot sauce! Its homemade and awesome so I..."

Asher

"MY OH MAYA!. Absolutely fell in LOVE with this place! So far in the last month, I've visited twice.. yep, that good! On my first visit I was..."

Danny G

"Amazing flavor. Very small restaurant with amazing food. We ordered the queso fundido with chicken. The seasoning was just amazing. Very rich. Fish..."

Mike M

"Casa Maya. The service was great, even though it was one guy during a semi-busy lunch hour. Food was absolutely awesome. Blue-corn chips and salsa..."

Mike M.

"Good food. But, not many tables and slow..."

George

"A hesitant yes-the food tasted very fresh, very quant atmosphere, it the food was a bit bland. Wife and I got Mayan Soup, the pepito sandwich and the..."

Chris Cox

"I love this place! The dining room is small just like being at a friends house. Especially with the place also being tucked away from the main drag...."

Michelle Kerr

"Great fish tacos. Warm chips and excellent salsa. Decent sangria. Atmosphere is more..."

Keith

"Had lunch here. I really enjoyed all the different flavors of the food. Our waiter Daniel was a real Gem. Love that there wasn't a wait when we..."

Ashleigh Perkins

"This is a really great restaurant. It was a nice atmosphere with great music playing. I order the Tacos Al Pastor and they were delicious. I was..."

Yippo Raymond

"Fun spot, great atmosphere. (Only sat outside) live music was good and the food was great. Absolutely amaizing fresh guac. Plantains we're cooked..."

Shawn Waite

"This Amazing gem has flare, delicious food, live entertainment, trendy bar area to drink while your table is made ready. We were seated by Larry,..."

Maria Varela

"My mind was blown and some other parts, by our bartender Xavier, he was very welcoming, knowledgeable, kept us entertained, and humoured. The..."

Женя У

"Oysters were large and from from Maine. The guacamole was tasty but Kirstyn made the visit with her excellent service! We came back from the jalapeno..."

Lisa Greer

"We dined at Casa Maya on February 21st for lunch. We were immediately seated in the upstairs balcony which has a wonderful view of the street..."

Dottie Guerrasio

"We came to Casa Maya for drinks. Really enjoyed the vibe of this place, especially the outdoor seating. Great place to chill and catch up with old..."

Reset

There are 8 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Paella in St. Augustine

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Cabi Style with Leza

Wendy Clarke Phelan

Ivonne Rivera Blessed Home Team

M Lytle

Maria Schwartz

Maria Nuta

Darian Mendez

Katie Clark

Kim McBride

Teresa Meares

Marty Kirkley

James P Barry Jr.

Zachary Gragg

Oscar Melendez

Joe Potter

Beth Hyde-Hood

John Dill

Morgan Reynolds

Mark Whisenant

Indra Moedjio

Alisa Jones

Mary Trenty

NANCY PEARSON

Wes Simpson

Ron Rogers

Melissa Wu

Laurie KOVACS

Jayne C

Dani Adams

Susan C Soforenko

Karl Burtzloff

Teresa Carter

Christine Vetter

Diana Gomez

Kitty Wells

Brandon Bautista

Rhea Schweiger

Tina Armonas Smith

Maria Leber

Jan Thomas

Dustin Kelley

Nitin Koka

Michael Harding

Dana Gold

Riana Kreuz

Cynthia Pierson

Counseling Care Singapore

Cecil Mowdy

Jessica Victores

Diane Vermillion

Robin Pharr

S Ybarra

Carlos Junod

Fritz Whittemore

RobertsMom NC

Farz Tex

Deanna Faircloth

Tony Hann

Marjon

Brianna Carmen

Prncesa Cristina

Guillermo Delacruz

Christina M Campbell

Heather Alonge

Jerry Wholaver

Alexander Healey

Shirley Woodlee

Jodi Garland