Bagel Basket Cafe
105 State Route 71, 07762-1824 - Spring Lake
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#19 of 22 restaurants in Spring Lake
Updated on
€€€
Cafe
American
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
60/100
Data Completeness
72/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🚚
Delivery
🥡
Takeout
🍽️
Dine-in
♿
Wheelchair accessible
📊 Popular Times
Not busy
Moderate
Very busy
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
132
Google reviews
Has really good bagels and staff was nice and helpful.
Google
From NY so nothing beats a NY bagel, but was still impressed and the staff was very nice! Wish they were working with a little bit more urgency when they were busy - otherwise would 100% recommend to someone visiting!
Google
ABSOLUTELY THE BEST EVERYTHING BAGEL EITH VEG.CREAM CHEESE AND LOX EVER!!
Google
Been coming here for years happy to see them still going strong. Friendly staff and plenty of seating, the parking lot can fill up quick. Fresh baked items and a standard menu, there's something for everyone. Bagels are covered in toppings and the porkroll egg and cheese will knock your socks off. Fresh ingredients and super filling, Bagel Basket is a must stop when I'm in the area
Read more
Google
Their winter blend coffee is superb. Bagels are top notch and their raisin bran muffin is always very tasty and moist.
Google
We were in Bradley Beach and asked our server read the best bagels were and she suggested the bagel basket. You can actually get meals to eat and eat in the restaurant, but we just wanted to take a dozen home. We got a lot of varieties- everything bagel, jalapeno cheese, asiago, garlic, onion, plain, etc. We also got four different types of cream cheese as they make their own. We got blueberry, strawberry, garden, vegetable, and Sriracha. Was not disappointed and absolutely loved it. Would highly recommend.
Read more
Google
Tried plenty of items throughout the week and not one let me down. Amazing taste and fresh. A really good find if your in the area no questions asked.
Google
Stopped in here for the first time on Thanksgiving morning to get two breakfast bagel sandwiches. The two guys behind the counter were very friendly and the sandwiches they made for me and my girlfriend were quite good.
Even got to watch some rodeo on the television while I waited for my order.
Highly recommend!
Read more
Google
The best egg salad sandwich on a hard roll ever. Such nice people. And I enjoyed my first salt Bagel today. I'll be back. In memory of my friend Geoff Blake
Google
Guys!!! I had minimal expectations! I just needed a local sandwich! No one ever has good bread for a sandwich and ‘it’s always ok’. I don’t complain. I was so happy about the sandwich I got from you today that I had to brag!!!! Loved it!I! Good luck and I’ll def recommend and order again!
Google
Explore more in Spring Lake
Help improve this page: