Sluurpy
Reset

There are 6 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in South Yarmouth

There are 6 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Gerardi's Cafe
93/100 (1101 ratings)
Restaurants
Healthy
Vegan Options
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Drinks
Salad
Cakes
Crab
Pesto
Scallops
Fish
Alfredo
Clams
Antipasti
Tiramisu
Calamari
Meatballs
Risotto
Cheesecakes
Calamares
Crème Brulée
Lasagne
Salmon
Cannoli
Shrimp
Carbonara
Beef
Ice Cream
Crab Cake
Prosciutto
Cheesecake
Lobster
Gelato
Haddock
Eggplant
Creme Brulee
Cod
Pasta
Swordfish
Sit down
Italian
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts Discover
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Drinks
Dinner
Mid-range
"Wow! It's been a while since I had some good Italian food at a restaurant! Tomato sauce was on point and didn't tasted like canned cheap tomato..."
Cristina Stan
"A cut above what you might expect in a tourist seafood area. A REAL Itilian Restaurant with home made pasta and sauces that are as flavorful as you..."
Todd Bray
"Lovely establishment. Service was wonderful yet slightly delayed. Server suggested something for my son because menu choices were not to his pallet...."
zelda bergstrom
"Espresso martini, bread with olive oil, chicken carbonara, all top-notch. I sat at the bar and enjoyed watching the mixologist at work. I'll go back..."
R Leonard Myatt
"Our favorite Italian restaurant (besides home). We've been enjoying Chef Diego's food for 20 years. Crab Cakes are insanely good. So many great menu..."
Suz Degiorgio
"Lord knows how I love this place! Was there for a vacation - the food is amazing!! Me and my MIL love the seafood pasta with Parmigiana sauce, that..."
Irenè _
"My husband, my child and I visited this place on our vacation trip.The place is fantastic. Our waiter was super friendly, I think his name was..."
Eliana Sanchez
"We happened upon Gerardi's Cafe upon arriving in Yarmouth around 6:30 on a Saturday night. We didn't have a reservation and they were super busy,..."
Kimberly Maillet
"The food is absolutely amazing. Our server was attentive and helpful. You get free mini appetizers along with your bread and the portions are..."
Margot Powers
"If you want Italian, this is the spot on the cape when you've had enough seafood, plus it was a rainy day and we were ready for some comfort food...."
James Grace
Scapicchio's Bakery
92/100 (197 ratings)
Bakeries
Italian
Italian
Italian
Caffe Gelato Bertini
91/100 (815 ratings)
Dessert
Italian
Italian
Ice Cream
Gelato
Stracciatella
Gelato & Sorbetto
Affogato
Chocolate and Espresso Gelato
Café
Italian
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Cheap Eats
"Still the best gelato I can find in Cape Cod. Only down is this year the haven’t made a lot of the flavors they did last year, Maybe I just miss..."
WTMIWF
"Good Gelato, pricing was high, but it was a nice treat. The pina colada and apricot were tasty. The woman working seemed..."
F. G.
"We spent the day doing an ice cream tour of the cape. This stop stands out as memorable because of the incredible quality and unique flavors. I tried..."
Christopher Harasta
"Delicious gelato in a quaint little cape cod building. We biked down Pleasant St with kids. Very little traffic and respectful drivers. We had fun..."
gadgetbec
"Gorgeous, delicious Gelato with unique flavors and very helpful staff. We could not stop talking about the rose, fig, and milk flavors which were..."
Vik K
"This place deserves 10 stars. Absolutely incredible quality and bursting with flavor (but when I visited they didn’t have nocciola that would..."
Jeanne Hainz
"After a long day at the beach, we stopped at this cute caffe for a gelato on our way home... and to our surprise, it’s one of the best gelato in..."
Sandy W
"A lovely little gelato place on a residential street. Definitely worth a visit. There is very little space inside but there are tables/benches..."
Kirill Evseev
"I go here with my aunt quite often. Very nice owners and the gelato is great. Always something new and delicious every..."
Oak
"Very good gelato and the owners were friendly as well. Great selection and quality. I have been here several times..."
Steve H
"Many people think ice cream is all the same. Gelato is much different….So creamy and fresh. Made daily with all kinds of fruit and flavors. There..."
Kelley G
"Love REAL gelato? Then go to Caffe Bertini! Great regular flavors and special, unusual flavors. All small batch and delicious. Great staff as well...."
C Angell
"This Place is top notch. All the flavors are delicious, made with fresh fruit and homemade ingredients. The staff is even very nice and friendly...."
Jake
"The best frozen treat around. A definite must have when you are visiting the area. Absolutely..."
Jay White
"Fantastic Gelato! We tried several flavors and all were..."
BeckyJean Thompson
"Super great place! Worth coming back. The Hot Choclate Chipotle gelato was unbelievably good! Best day of my life! ;) Went back 2 other times just to..."
Ray Furtado
"Just had the beach rose gelato it was delish!! Inquired taste but it was floaty , it’s all good , all there stuff is..."
nathan day
"Best gelato I've had outside of Italy. Right off Main Street, on Pearl. Very friendly owners who learned their craft in Bologna. Will make it a point..."
Diane Sundstrom
"The gelato here is top notch. Rotating flavors, so there is always something exciting. Ended up with pistachio for one and chocolate/espresso for..."
Adam Broussard
Four Seasons Trattoria
88/100 (837 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Bass
Salad
Cheesecakes
Scallops
Lasagne
Clams
Carbonara
Calamari
Chicken Parmesan
Risotto
Cakes
Mussels
Pesto
Calamares
Fish
Salmon
Shrimp
Cheesecake
Broccoli rabe
Lobster
Eggplant
Cioppino
Pasta
Tiramisu
Sit down
Italian
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Late Night
Dinner
Mid-range
"Best real Italian food in a long time!! I was very surprised, all of it was so good. Service was amazing. Food was amazing. Will definitely return as..."
Cristine Galle
"Great Italian food served in an unpretentious environment. Friendly and attentive staff. Delicious and generous portions. The Limoncello was a great..."
Sean Donovan
"To say I’m impressed is an understatement! Service here is top notch from the moment you walk in the door until you leave. Very causal atmosphere,..."
TheLawrence Homestead
"We had delivery so I can’t comment on service or atmosphere, but I had to come and rate the food. The chicken parm is one of the best I’ve ever..."
Jennifer Mourhess
"This restaurant is a 10 every visit! I am from Minnesota and I visit the Cape a few times a year. This place is a must stop every time. Their chef is..."
Beverly Parnell
"Just like the good reviews. Not impressive on the outside, nice enough on the inside, but overshadowed by phenomenal food and service. Highly..."
Matt Guiltinan
"Dinner for three and the entire experience was wonderful. Calamari appetizer was probably the best ever had. The home made bread was amazing. Entrees..."
Keith Felton
"We were looking for something nearby for a quick bite and ended up here. Pasta is a treat for us these days, and this place didn't disappoint! The..."
Mikenna Greenough
"The food is what I consider east coast family Italian food at its best. The portions are big. The flavors are great. It was delivered hot. Real..."
Chase Woodward
"This is an excellent restaurant. The food is outstanding. The bread perfect. Vodka Penne, sea bass, chicken picata all top notch. The homade..."
Terry Derden
"I had a potato here and it changed my life ever since I bit into their potato. I ordered a meal and it had one potato and it looked like a normal..."
Brady Labonte
"THIS PLACE IS AMAZING!!! We have traveled all over, and we are HUGE FOODIES, and this restaurant is truly 5 stars! The food is so so so so so so..."
Jordan & Andy Wickstrom
"Amazing meal! I tried a special - chicken with mushrooms in a white wine lemon sauce with my choice of pasta and it was so good it should be a..."
Morgan Hunt
"Delicious food from the free bread and zucchini oil they start you out with all the way through dessert. Excellent service and reasonably priced. The..."
Alana Lopez
"The service was excellent. I had the fried artichokes and the ravioli. The articles would have been really good if they weren't from a canned but I..."
Joshua Zupan
"We were visiting from NJ and had dinner with my brother and mom n dad. Wow - what a treat! Server was top-notch, food was even better. Appy's so..."
Richard Constant
"Four Seasons is our go-to for dining out - above all other restaurants in an 10 mile radius. The food is fantastic, ALWAYS. We get takeout 1-2x per..."
Ben Pirri
Sweet Tomatoes Neapolitan Pizza
85/100 (474 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Television
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"I'm a pizza snob and I'm usually disappointed with the pizza in MA. Not so with this place, their pizza is fantastic and i highly recommend trying..."
Lars Haas
"Stopped by since we were at an Airbnb close by and this seemed like a nice neighborhood pizza place. This was by far the best thin crust Neapolitan..."
hari jayaram
"I really enjoyed my pizza! The customer service was great and the restaurant was very..."
Nelcia Medley-Avila
"The pizza here is always a pleaser, it's perfectly thin and delicious. My favorite right now is the "crazy lady" and to get a caprese salad. The..."
Kylie Power
"Stopped here while on our stay on the Cape. Fun atmosphere with great thin crust pizza. Pizza sauce tasted fresh and had chunks of tomato. I'm sure..."
Shauna Vierling
"Ordered from the Yarmouth location and their pizza was FANTASTIC! Thin crust, perfectly cooked, just the right amount of toppings bursting with..."
Mike Kennedy
"By far the best Buffalo chicken calzone. Anywhere. Ever. (Please send me a message if you think you know a better one, I'd love to try it) The pizza..."
Alex Ellis
"Love this place. Lived in New Haven for 3 years. This is where I go locally to get my proper slice fix. Fresh toppings, light on the cheese, great..."
Jon Ungerland
"Pizza is to die for ! First time. Stopped in for a couple of slices. Price is great too. Fast and..."
Jenkitty 67
"Delicious pizza 🍕. Made exactly how I wanted it. The kid waiting on me was very..."
Maria Foley
"Fantastic food and service. Never have had to wait more than 15 minutes. Love the Mozzarella special sandwich and their salad..."
Kyle Martin
"This was the absolute best pizza I have ever had! Regardless if I were in Massachusetts, Connecticut, Rhode Island, or New Hampshire… which are the..."
Nickie0623
"My family and I tried Sweet Tomatoes the other night and were very content with our order. The pizza Sarah was a huge hit, and everyone thought the..."
Joe Sousa
"Not my personal favorite kind of pizza but that doesn’t mean it’s not good they have the tomato dices and I am not a fan of tomato sauce, so not..."
Jessica MacDonald
"Wow. Awesome pizza and salads that are clearly made with excellent ingredients. For lunch they have 8-10 pizzas already available by the slice. They..."
Dana Giuliana
"Needed a place to have lunch on our way back home. Found Sweet Tomatoes pizza and totally enjoyed the food. This is an extra thin crust with a..."
Craig Yarrish
"Great pizza and quick service! Thoroughly enjoyed our lunch. Will definitely be coming back. Highly..."
A B
"Great spot to grab a slice. Big slices for the money and lots of variety. Their normal pizza is thin crust and very good. They also do a nice..."
William Eburn
Papa Gino's
83/100 (667 ratings)
Restaurants
Quick Bites
Pizza
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Lobster
Pasta
Salad
Pesto
Fast food
Pizza
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Thank you so much for saving our Davenport Halloween lunch!! You guys jumped right in with smiling faces!! Can't thank you all enjoy and the Jack o..."
SEASIDE LE MANS
"The staff at this location is fantastic. I order from them personally at least once a month and the food is consistently good. Today I needed lunch..."
Bnawn
"Excellent service.... Walked in close to closing time but they were still extremely welcoming and cooked me a delicious Large pizza. Great crew at..."
richard clifford
"Place I’ve gone to for years. Grew up in this town and this place held my favorite late night treats. Great staff, service and pizza has kept its..."
Anna Levee
"I love this Papa Gino's location, their consistency is so perfect that you forget what bad food or service is like. The staff is always great. The..."
Scotty Roddy
"me personally as soon as i walked into that fine establishment i was greeted with the warmest of welcomes, treated with best service, and the pizza..."
Hayden Bulvins
"This pizza is absolutely amazing. It's hard to see so many Papa Gino's restaurants close but this one is a true gem. Excellent service and..."
Kelly Garofalo
"So good!! Loved all the parmesan cheese, under crust , around the crust!! Had the Rustic pizza, 1/2 meat 1/2 works!! Highly..."
Sue Docken
"This store has exceptional customer service. The manager is friendly, accommodating , and is always making sure you have the best experience. 10/10..."
Samantha Medeiros
"best place-to get mozzarella sticks and chicken tenders and great customer service the staff is so nice I have been coming here every night for..."
Emily Baraket
"Good tasting pizza, ordered well done. It's was very crispy. Ordered chicken bacon ranch pizza, we also ordered mozzarella sticks, and chicken..."
Melissa S
"Shout out to the South Yarmouth location! They took my free birthday pizza to a whole other level with this kind gesture. Thanks for making me smile..."
Noelle Gensler
"We got the pepperoni pizza. It was made in a timely matter and staff was extremely polite. Their sauce is made from vine ripened tomato so it has a..."
Christina Koester
"If you haven’t been in a while …. I highly recommend trying it out again. The pizza has been fantastic. Our new favorite pizza place. Great food..."
Joanne Iachetta
"I love this place why isn’t it on the list when u google pizza it might be because of the prices..."
Charles
"Was the best mushroom onion sausage pizza I've had in a looong time. Whoever was making it took pride in their..."
Debra Santos
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use