Atrocious customer service. We've ordered the same order every Friday night for the last 6 months, our pizza light on the cheese and crispy. Pie was sent with a ton of cheese and floppy. When I called, the guy who answered said he wrote light on the cheese and crispy which is wrong because we have
2 times I ordered from this place and it has been nothing but an awful experience. The pizza was cold 2 times and we live down the street. They went to the wrong house BOTH times. We call back and they just said “sorry” and did nothing nor did they care.
The good reviews for this place are for the previous ownership and totally different pizza recipe. This place is now awful. Avoid.
Not Coffaros anymore. Now J&J pizza. Not the same quality. Tastes like generic, machine made pizza. Like Chuck e Cheese. End of an era. Will miss Coffaros pizza.
One of the worse places I’ve ever ordered from in all of middlesex county! Stay away
The best restaurants are the small, out of the way, hole in the wall places that you find in any town in the world. This is one of those places.
I have been eating here as far back as I have been eating solid food. I grew up in South River and this was the pizza of choice. Their pizza is fantast
One of the best pizzas around. The sauce is amazing, a bit sweet, which is what I like. The staff is very friendly. Family owned...which I think it is great to support small mom and pop shops and family owned places over big chains.
Only downfall is the place could use updating or sprucing up. The
Terrible. Was told 20 minutes the food would be delivered. Hour and 30 minutes later , 3 calls later, they call me stating “the driver can’t find your address what is it again?” MIND YOU I spelt it out for the person I spoke with because his English wasn’t well to be safe then sorry. Unreal. Waiting
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes