Reviews Wheatberry Bake Shop

5
Eden Haylee
+5
She did a FANTASTIC job! My mother in law surprised us by ordering a wedding cake from her and it could not have been better! The colors are perfect, design was perfect, taste was amazing! I am dairy free and the rest of the family is not and she made us a two tier wedding cake the top being vegan and the bottom regular! They were both SO good. I am so so so grateful. She even delivered it to their home for us! If I could give 10 stars I would!!! Thank you so much!
5
brian dickens
+5
Exceptional bakery experience! From the moment I stepped in, the aroma of freshly baked goods was enchanting. The array of pastries, bread, and cakes was not only visually stunning but also a testament to the craftsmanship of the bakers. Each bite was a burst of flavor, showcasing the use of high-quality ingredients. The staff's warmth and attentiveness added to the overall delightful atmosphere. A must-visit for anyone seeking a delectable journey through the world of baked delights!
5
Melanie Dickens
+5
When I walked into this bakery I was instantly in bakery heaven. The smell of the place was amazing! Being a cookie cake pastry conissour I have to say everything I tried was absolutely delicious and the owner was so very friendly and helpful. I ordered the almond bear claw, chocolate topped cream puff, white chocolate raspberry cupcake, mocha shortbread cookies, and the Cinnamon Brioche bread which we made French toast with! All of it phenomenal!!!
5
Barbara Danielson
+5
Excellent bakery, warm and friendly atmosphere. Their signature "Wheatberry" bread has become a regular in our home. Scott makes the most wonderful bear claws packed with a delicious almond filling. His eclairs are the best European choux pastry, creamy custard filling and topped with a chocolate ganache; not too sweet, just perfect.
5
Morgan Brown
+5
Recently ordered a cake here and was beyond amazed. Such a low stress experience and the baker was willing to work with my inspiration and absolutely nailed it. Not only did it look beautiful it also tasted wonderful! Definitely the place to get the best cakes and treats!
5
Anna C.
+5
They did such a beautiful job on our sons moving up day cake!! Everyone there is so wondeful!!! It made his night so much for his special day! We will be coming for his birthday cake and our babies smash cake in October🥰🥰
5
Lauren Bobeck
+5
Their front of house service was very helpful and friendly as I worked with them on my daughter’s first birthday smash cake, serving cake, cupcakes and cookies. I didn’t have any interaction with the baker, which did make me slightly nervous as the party drew closer, but she nailed the design I requested, and my guests raved about the quality and taste of the desserts! I also had to move the party up one day due to weather changes, and they were able to still accommodate my order, thankfully!!! I would recommend Wheatberry!
5
J Hunt
+5
Ever since Haye's Fish market left this building, i never cared to go to any other business that would have taken over the vacant spot. I did pause for a second though, when Wheatberry Bake shop appeared. But still i never stop, I assumed it was just another gluten free/vegan bakery. It wasnt until I became more active on Yelp and read the positive reviews, along with teaming up with Evelyn (a yelper as well) to see and post our reviews on all the bakeshops near us. So my mission, if i choosed to accept was to finally go to Wheatberry. Once I opened up the door I was standing in front of a glass counter showcasing all the best looking desserts your heart desires. The smell of the place is amazing, you know your in a place that makes their desserts on site. Now on to my purchases, I will start with the peanut butter cookie. As you can see from the pic it is huge, it was good it really was. But I prefer more of a peanut butter taste and a little more chewy, but it still is a soft cookie but not as soft as i would have like it. I got 4 cupcakes, but will speak on the one I tried. The german chocolate, was good as well but again i felt the cupcake couldve been a little bit more moist. It wasnt dry to the point I felt my money was wasted. For me though, it couldve been a bit more moist. If it was, I wouldve ate the other 3 cupcakes i have waiting for my family to try. Next up is the Lemon bar, OOOOh boy the lemon hits your taste buds right out of the gates. I like the smooth texture of the lemon bar, it coats your tongue and the sweetness seems to intensify to calm the lemon flavor down some. This bar was a great balance of sweet verse bitter, I could only imagine eating just one though because its soooo rich. Last but not least is the pecan bar, imagine the best pecan pie you had and picture it condense. Thats what you get from this sticky, pecan pack bar. I had to eat mine with a fork because it was so sticky and if i was out in public. How many people would think i was weird for constantly licking my fingers? lol There were vegan products there, I did not try. I will go again at some point, but for now I am on to my next mission.
5
Caremine Seemueller
+5
Absolutely amazing I love love love this bakery went here for my Fiancé’s 30th birthday cake AND for our anniversary got the cutest most amazing Oreo mini cake AND even with it being small and perfect size for 2 they were still able to put a cute message on top of the cake. The cake was absolutely amazinggggg Oreo with Oreo cream filling. Love this spot and refuse to get cakes anyplace else. 10/10
4
Passion8 4God
+4
Great customer service! (Tuscan) garlic bread was out of this world! Vegan cupcakes were BEAUTIFUL to behold 😍 but D-R-Y! 🥺😫
5
Lindsay Bender
+5
Lindsay had made our wedding cake and it was absolutely AMAZING!!! We had a very small/ private wedding reception due to the current circumstances and we were thrilled by the presentation of the cake in addition to the cake flavor itself. It was perfect and we are still getting compliments on how wonderful the cake was!!! The cake was almond with a custard and fresh strawberry filling. We will definitely be coming back and truly can't thank her enough for making such a beautiful masterpiece for us!
5
sterling hutchinson
+5
Had an excellent wedding cake made, was delivery right to my house and tasted amazing!!!!
5
Abdul Khan
+5
The people are so sweet. I coming here again. Their sweets are really amazing. I feel at home.
5
Travis Ballard
+5
As a 62 year old African American male who grew up near the recent Tops tragedy, I have become jaded and cynical about race relations in this county and in this country. I enter stores especially suburban establishments with trepidation. I've been ordering deliveries this bakery for over a year but this week I went to pick up my order. There was some grubhub confusion but they prepared my order. They even replaced a loaf I had incorrectly selected and had sliced. They were incredibly gracious throughout the entire encounter Today I discovered they hadn't received payment for my last order. I called and was told not to worry about it. I immediately jumped in my car and went there to make additional purchases. I was first attracted to the bakery because they sell scones and GREAT bread. Although I'm not a man who eats " sweets ", I'm going to be shouting from the rooftops about this wonderful establishment, their incredible products, the welcoming employees and the engaging owner You made my day.....Thank You
5
Rebecca Barrett
+5
Wheatberry catered the desserts for our wedding and they were great!!! They were such a great family-run business to work with and were so flexible! We chose a bunch of small desserts, cupcakes, and a 2-tiered cake, the guests RAVED about it (especially the fudge cups)!
5
Leonardo DiBella
+5
The absolute best vegan pastries out there, highly recommended! Their variety of different breads is also awesome, lots of great choices, you can't go wrong with any of them!
5
Carri Przepiora
+5
I live around the corner from this bakery for 13 years and today was the first day I actually had time to go in. First thing manager Scott introduced himself as manager and fulfilled his wife dream to own a bakery. This place is fitting on our little town of Snyder. I chose a cookie a loaf of bread and 2 cupcakes. Scott game me the sugar cookie on the house as first time visit. Very good banana foster cupcake. Will be going back and maybe do a birthday cake in the future.
5
Amanda Seitz
+5
Everything we have had from Wheatberry has been beyond exceptional! The staff is friendly and welcoming and the baked goods are amazing. We recently had a “smash cake” done for first birthday photos, it was absolutely perfect! We did a Winnie the Pooh theme and the “hunny pot” cake came out perfectly and was so adorable (it also tasted AMAZING)!