Best pizza and wings south of Syracuse. I spent 14 years working in pizza shops and am very picky about my pizza. I choose Valentine’s every time we have pizza at home. There sheet pizzas are the best I have ever had, not like everyone else’s that are nothing like there regular pizza. Wings are great too. Staff is friendly and efficient. A+
Stopped in for lunch on a day trip - great selection, good prices, and the best tasting (and looking) calzone I’ve ever had. If you’re ever passing through, this place will not disappoint!
Love this place. The staff are always curious and helpful. The pizza here is delicious and the subs are also filling and freshly made. This is one my favorite pizza places!
Best pizza around the area! Haven't had pizza this good (and wings & salad) in a long while.
Great Service To start and comfortable setting of you have kids. Prices are great I fed six people for under 26$ ! Great bang for your buck we will
Be back
Friendly staff. Excellent selection of items to eat and drink. One of my favorite spots in the village.
This is an outstanding place to visit in Skaneateles, right across from the lake with good food and outstanding service. If I could eat here everyday I would.
We liked everything and will return soon. A perfect place to dine.
Great pizza/ food/ people!!!
Pizza was overall really great and well priced. Many different types of "by the slice" were ready to eat. I would give their cheese pizza a 3 star, as the sauce or cheese needs a kick but the 3 Cheese Chipotle Chicken pizza was a 4.5 star, as the crust and toppings were in perfect harmony. This place is worth a visit if you love pizza. The staff was very friendly too.
We stopped into this wonderful place during the Dickens Christmas 2023 festival and could not have left any happier. They have a great selection of pizza slices and side dishes ready to go along with plenty of made to order options. The food was delicious and sampled quite a bit of it. The icing on the cake was our group contained 6 adults and 2 small children and the bill for our feast was LESS than $100! Valentine's was a fun part of our day and will definitely be part of our plans when we return to Skaneateles.
I love valentines for me it’s the last thing that makes this town what it is I been getting pizza here my whole life and hope I can continue to for many more years some of the best pizza I’ve had in NY. Staff is very nice and the inside has a good atmosphere and is nostalgic to me and they always have slices available. Only problem if any is parking but what can you do. I hope they continue to do the amazing job that they have been doing.
The service was superb and the pizza is to die for. I recommend the sausage & pepperoni, buffalo wing, and waffle fries. I will definitely be back 🤗🤤
I moved to Skaneateles from Ohio recently. I'm a guy who feels that home isn't quite "Home" until one has found a blistering local pizza joint. Well, I've found it. Valentine's is dynamite. The pizza is excellent (I recommend the extra-baked option, but suture yourself), and so are the wraps. The wing sauce is also top notch, and the heat ratings are pretty accurate; if you order wings extra wet/saucy, they'll come out absolutely swimming, which is just a beautiful thing. The service is fast, and even with my annoying habit for customization, they've messed up exactly ZERO of the things I've ordered over numerous weekends. Highly recommend.
We had a Hawaiian pizza and chicken wings. They were very good! We ordered from the boat, hoping they could deliver to the pier (directly across the st). But sadly, they didn't.
Ordered a large pizza July 4th evening... it was absolutely delicious and cooked perfectly! Not surprised since we always have delicious meals there. Excellent end to an amazing holiday weekend... Thanks Valentine's!
Always a great stop for lunch. Many varieties of fresh slices always available along with hot and cold sandwiches and wraps made to order.
Great spot for pizza and wings. The sandwiches looked fantastic too but we didn't try them. We ordered and the food was ready quickly. The wings were cooked perfectly and the pizza had nice melty cheese and a great flavor. As of today it was just under $30 for a large cheese 12 rings and a 2L. Thanks for having us today. You guys are great.
It's worn out but the food is really good. The pizza is more NYC style and the sammiches are very good. They also have beer in the cooler. 🤟 The food comes out fast which is great if you're hungry from your long day of shopping all the overpriced, bourgeois shops or if you have hungry kiddos.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes