Sluurpy
Reset

There are 12 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Dinner in Shipshewana

There are 12 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Millie's Market Cafe
92/100 (103 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Cafe
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Chinese Chicken Salad
Chicken Sandwich
Salad
Key Lime Pie
Mushroom and Swiss Burger
Coffee
Chicken Noodles and Mashed Potatoes
Chicken cheese quesadilla
Orchard Chicken Salad Sandwich
Orgional Chicken Salad Sandwich
Reuben and Corn Chowder
American
Café
Wheelchair Accessible
Seating
Lunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"Great lil cafe with a great view on the patio overlooking the shops and sounds of Shipshe. Food was delicious. Wished we weren't so full to try some..."
Melissa Joshua Genther
"Marsha Slottag Smith and I went there for lunch after shopping. The cafeteria was very clean and the hostesses were very helpful. The Cheesy..."
Tom Smith
"Nice roof top area for lunch. The beat grilled chicken sandwich & fries I've ever had! Great..."
Stacey Collins
"Love their soup and pie! Have eaten there many times while in..."
Joan Liebl Canfield
"The food is..."
Jennie Clark
"the..."
Mark Gibson
"Top of the Mercantile in Shipshewana! Having peanut butter pie and tea..."
Alvin Miller
"Nice restaurant on the 3rd floor of Davis Mercantile. Pepsi products and a simple menu. Chicken and noodles served over mashed potatoes with a..."
David Current
"Cute little place to grab a quick bite to eat. Waitress was the only one waiting tables and she did a great..."
Lisa Carlson
"Great place! Best Reuben I've ever had!! Husband and I got the corn chowder. It was amazing and definitely homemade... He got the mushroom swiss..."
Kristin Steffen
"It is a small restaurant, but good food, would go there..."
Karen Yoder
"Wow amazing delicious lunch. Chicken salad sandwich was mouth watering. Husband had the chicken strips, juicy and crispy. Will absolutely come again...."
Peta Pastor
East Of Chicago Pizza
85/100 (527 ratings)
Restaurants
Quick Bites
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
American
Pizza
Italian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Wings
Sit down
Italian
American
Pizza
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"good but not the best pizza i’ve ever had :-) it could’ve been a little heavier on the cheese and less sauce. the bread (cheese garlic) was good..."
Sarah
"Delicious thin crust large veggie pizza! It was Sunday and we arrived late at our hotel and needed dinner — most places were closed but East of..."
Suzanne Millan
"We are from the Chicago area and this pizza was delicious and greatly impressed us. The pan crust and ingredients were cooked perfectly and the taste..."
Martha Garza
"The best deep dish pizza our family has ever tried. We visited here when we were staying in Shipshewana and it is now a family favorite. The deep..."
Curtis and Erica
"We enjoyed the buffet. It was a reasonable price and you could enjoy pop at a very low price compared to most establishments. The lettuce and salad..."
Heather S
"Out of all the East of Chicagos this one is the best. All others that I have gone to messes up the order or it’s cold. Only problem is My last one..."
Dalynn Grant
Blue Gate Restaurant And Bakery
85/100 (6848 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
American
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Roast Beef
Cakes
Fish
Pork
Noodle
Beef
Dumplings
Meatloaf
Salad
Sit down
American
Buffet
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Private Dining
Accepts Credit Cards
Street Parking
Takeout
Accepts Discover
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Mid-range
Pumpkin Vine Cafe
85/100 (272 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Cafe
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Cheesecakes
BLT
Burger
Salad
Cheesecake
Ribs
"2nd time here and we have decided it's the best Diner in the town of Ship. We will always come here. The staff are super friendly and prices are..."
Tonya Newburry
"I love the cheeseburger on pretzel bun! The best ! Love the lemon dessert also! The owners are great! I give this restaurant 10 star..."
Mary Guevara
"All 3 times I've eaten here have been great. The food is delicious and so was the pumpkin frappe I had today! The pulled pork on pretzel bun is the..."
Erica Kay Dice
"Had the fajita salad , perfect! Good food nice people nice..."
Laurie Anderson Furness
"Loved the food, atmosphere and staff!! It was the perfect stop before our show at Blue Gate Theater, would def go..."
Pong Spencer
"It was our first time visiting Pumpkin Vine Cafe and I must say - I was impressed. The decor, the ambience, and the food was all amazing. We came to..."
David T. Farr
"Cozy little nook in Shipshewana, love to meet there by myself as much as with friends. Food is..."
Char Eash
"I love Pumpkin Vine Cafe. They have awesome sandwiches. Want to try there pizza and..."
Paula Worthington
"Food was great and prices were ok also. There was food for kids..."
Harold Aldrich
"Very delicious food and the staff was very pleasant. The decor was..."
Michelle Dickerson
"Great lunch sandwiches, salads, pizza and more. Try the Poor Man's pot roast..."
Paul Franz
"We had breakfast and dinner here and both meals were fantastic. Great food and..."
Rachel Bedel
"This was our 1st time to visit Pumpkin Vine Cafe although not the 1st time we have noticed it and said we should try it sometime. We were definitely..."
Myra Bohner
"I got the chili and a pot roast sandwhich with a garlic rosemary sauce it was absolutely amazing they were very friendly great service..."
Sandra Moody
"I had some great ribs!! I loved the environment!! I had a great chat with the owner!! I'll be back for sure..."
Corban Privett
"Delicious food, at a great price. Very clean and comfortable atmosphere and has corner nook with a fireplace and couches. I had the turkey cucumber..."
Family Fun Adventures
"Wonderful service, and the food was fantastic. Salad and a half sandwich of your choice with chips and a drink for about 10 bucks. (Give or take a..."
Marty Mar
Red Bud Gourmet Coffee & Tea
83/100 (35 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Sandwiches
Pretzel
Takeout
Wheelchair Accessible
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
Four Seasons Diner
82/100 (295 ratings)
Restaurants
Diner
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Quaint little diner in Shipshewana featuring a variety of breakfast and lunch menu items. Large selection of burger options. We came for crepes or a..."
Debbie Mccomb
"This is a must place to go when you are hungry. Atmosphere is delightful, employees are friendly, food was fantastic, you will leave with a very full..."
J L
"Very friendly service. Food was good. I had the patty melt and fries. Patty melt wasn't greasy, which I like. My wife had the chimichanga and she..."
Paul Alexander
"Great food and prices. This place was quite the hidden gem as you xant really see it from the road, but it definitely worth looking for. Breakfast..."
Nick Kovarik
"Great little diner with friendly staff. I have never had a burger with chorizo on it before my trip here. It was very good in my opinion. I can't..."
Jamie Davis
"Very good menu, fries with sandwiches were the best and more than enough, potato bacon soup delish. Cajun chicken sandwich big and tastee. The Cajun..."
Jay Buchtel
Amy's Pizza
81/100 (299 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Takeout
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Found the best pizza in Shipshewana when I found Amy's pizza. Great friendly staff and great..."
Kimberly Cumpston
"First time to eat here. I had a Phlly beef sub and definitely the best I've ever had! Highly recommend this..."
Connie Vander Reyden Holmes
"Pizza was great! Fried green beans & fried pickles were good. Chicken club sub-substituted ranch for Italian dressing-was so good! Service was fast...."
Joshua Reed
"I love Amys Pizza friendly,clean,and a great place for date nights and they have wifi.The pizza burgers are the best in..."
Kris Bontrager
"Great food, reasonable prices! I had the Stromboli, my wife had the pizza burger and we shared the garlic cheesie bread...."
Jay Oakes
"Omg this is the best pizza EVER hands down �� thank you..."
Vonda Schrock
"Visiting from Murphy, NC and love this place! Pizza, garlic bread,..."
Cindy Cooley Brockway
"Great subs n..."
Mary Ann Bontrager
"The great reviews here did not disappoint! We were staying in a cabin with no kitchen, so we had to get all of our meals in town. I called for carry..."
Glenn Johnson
"Great place to eat. It's a family owned business and doesn't have a lot of help but they manage just fine. The food is great for the..."
Chellsea Weaver
"The food and the atmosphere are great, and the people who work there are have always been very nice and welcoming. It's one of my favorite places to..."
Morgan Kelly
"We decided to try Amy's Pizza while we were traveling and we're glad we did. The owner waited on us, she was very nice. The food was delicious...."
Ginny Lyon
"What a quaint, wonderful little place. The decor is an amazing chunk of Americana. The food was very inexpensive and yet extremely tasty. I had the..."
Mark Lorenz
"Wonderful place to eat! Love the decor! Fast, friendly and great prices! I think it's funny how people get so bent out of shape over a picture..."
debbie reel
El Zorrito 2
81/100 (541 ratings)
Restaurants
Mexican
Vegetarian Friendly
Mexican
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Mexican
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"The best salsa I have ever had. I never liked salsa before but I am in love with this salsa. Very flavorful. Homemade in house. The Al Pastor tacos,..."
Lianne Hart
"Awesome experience. Great host, great food, very friendly. Id honestly drive the 2hrs..."
Jodye Joe
"First time and really enjoyed it. Plenty of food and very tasty. Enchiladas were delicious. Until next years visit to..."
Jackie Legan
"The food was excellent and service great! Made our trip to Shipshewana extra..."
Laurie Springs
"Awesome service and great tasting food we will come..."
Amanda Nicole Tucker-Hansen
"Always love the food! I could eat the salsa all..."
Vicky Martin
"We love the food and the fresh salsa and the Arroz con pollo!!! Yum Yum! It was our first time and we will def be going back!!!! Love the take..."
Brenda Carpenter
"It was good they actually have some goooddd hot..."
Veronica Ayala Ramos
"it has awesome..."
Michaela Noelle Burniston
"Spent the weekend in Shipshe. We wanted Mexican and was not disappointed. Lots of locals eating there is a great sign for good food. Next time..."
Karrie Ratcliff
"Shipshewana,IN Excellent food,got double steak fajitas,for 3 people it costs $37 with extra sides,clean,and very friendly friendly nice people,our..."
Deb Hagger
"Their food is always awesome great service great people go back whenever I get a..."
Elva Miller
Shipshewana Auction Restaurant
80/100 (275 ratings)
Restaurants
Barbecue
American
Diner
Asian
American
Cafe
Soups
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Sandwiches
Burger
Noodle
Meatloaf
Salad
Cakes
Sit down
Soups
Asian
American
Barbecue
Diner
Café
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Takeout
Breakfast
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"OMG! With covid out there,haven't been doing much. This place was a treat. 40 acres of stuff to..."
Dorothy Parrish
"We visited in 2021 and had the best experience EVER! From shopping at the Flea Market to all the little stores, they have everything you may want and..."
Tracy Hornback
"Want a day full of fun and market shopping, you must go to Shipshewana Flea Market! It has hundreds of great booths. This is not just antiques, but..."
Jessica Lyn
"My family and I have been coming to the Shipshewana trade place for some time. It's always the same old stuff, but last time we went we were so happy..."
Krista Mehl
"We were at the flea market on the two hotest days of 2022. However we managed, stayed hydrated and sat down in shade when we needed. Felt sorry for..."
Judy Bloom
"You will not be disappointed with a trip to Shipshewana especially during the summer and flea market and quaint stores downtown and the Amish country..."
John Hilligoss
"We have been coming here for about 30 yrs. Always a great time! Even when some of those times have been rainy and cold in early..."
Larry Templin
"Perfect weather day. Wasn't crazy crowded and the food was great. We had an awesome..."
Tim james
Subway
77/100 (112 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Fast food
Fast Food
American
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Sandwiches
Fast food
American
Fast food
Takeout
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"Little busy. Food was fresh. Staff was fast and..."
Bill Utterback
"Best subs ever employees and the dine in area could..."
Tyrone Nerdhead
"Best lowcal sandwich I've had in a long time..."
Robert Shemberger
"Great service, and good..."
Shar
"Located inside a gas station but they have great seats! This location is one of the most unique subway locations in the United States. Because you..."
Ahmad A
5 And 20 Country Kitchen
77/100 (2471 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Gluten Free Options
American
Vegan Options
Asian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Pasta
Meatloaf
Salad
Chili
Mac and cheese
Sandwiches
Burger
Hamburgers
Ribs
Noodle
Toasts
Shrimp
Fish
Beef
Pork
Sit down
American
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Great Service, Good Food!. Great place to stop and eat when visiting Shipshewana. Their service is efficient and friendly. It was Griday and I had..."
Nov1754
"I love this place. The food is all home cooked and the people are very friendly. The price is very reasonable as well. I use to go to the blue gate..."
Michael Mitchell
"Not the best, but better than average. LOL, title doesn't sound very positive, but honestly, 'tis good food. Service was friendly and prompt, no..."
Hobbes
"Nice place. We ate there twice this summer and we have no complaints at all. A whole lot cheaper than eating downtown at that fancy..."
Robert Harold
"The fried chicken and green beans were..."
Jdunn002
"Omg if you stop here!!!!! Get ready for them to try and hurt you with the food n stay away from the desserts n the homemade stuff at the register ( I..."
Paul Blakey
"Went here for breakfast. Hubby had the buffet; he said the french toast with creamed chip beef was delicious. He said the potatoes would have been..."
Ginny Lyon
"Was a great restaurant! Only one open later in the evening. Many Amish there having a meal. Good food. Friendly atmosphere! Good prices. Right there..."
Tamara M Smith
"Very clean, very friendly waitress. It was busy, yet our waitress was in top of making sure our food was hot when we were served. Excellent prices...."
susan Johnson
"Delicious and affordable home cooking and comfort food. Just as good as more more popular places but without the ambiance and crowd. Nice..."
Kathy Mankowski
"Food is always amazing. I've had breakfast and lunch here and everything tastes delicious! The fried chicken is amazing and definitely generous..."
German Genzelis
"Some of the best food in Shipshewana. Very clean. Nice staff. Prices are..."
GR H
"One heck of a delicious pretzel bun turkey and bacon sandwich. Very flavorable and prices won't break the bank. Wait staff very friendly and..."
Don Lewis
Wana Cup Restaurant
77/100 (1043 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Sandwiches
Cheeseburger
Burger
Salad
Chili
Fish
Pork
Sit down
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Cute little restaurant! Amazing for the family to have a tasty meal! Also have such a hard working and friendly staff for how busy it gets! I love..."
Shianna Smith
"Pizza burger was delicious. Staff was very friendly. The skinny blonde who was working in the kitchen needs to quit being so rude to the staff...."
Kendra Kratzer Peterson
"Always get their homemade root beer - it's the best anywhere around! Also great burger and fries. Any time we come must have my root..."
Marianne Campbell Wells
"Best hometown restuarant I've been to in a long time.Best cheeseburger and root beer.Loved the staff seemed like they really loved what they were..."
Mattie Oxender
"The people and food are outstanding I highly recommend this..."
Gerry Kat Navarre
"We stopped in to try the homemade Rootbeer we heard so much about and it was fantastic! The service was so friendly, we decided to return later for..."
Debbie-John Redman
"The greatest home made root beer around! Great home made food and desserts. Nice..."
Wendy Shoudel
"Good food at a good price. Root beer was very..."
Jon Harkrider
"Great friendly service! Great food. Best homemade Root..."
Megan Ford
"Good!. Enjoyable little place. Had tenderloin for lunch on way up to the Dunes via Bristol - good sized sandwich, meat was tender [hey, that's its..."
Hobbes
"Great place! The lady was very friendly, I think the owner? A storm moved through while we were inside. The power went out briefly. The workers..."
Jo Schmo
"Nice little place to grab a bite to eat. We got dinner our last night in town. The food was fresh and tasted good. Lady working was very friendly...."
Woodworker24
"We stopped in today and the food was great! We were anticipating general diner food and it was far above that. The staff was friendly. The ice cream..."
Kayla P
"Their homemade rootbeer is absolutely the BEST I ever had!!! The rootbeer floats are fantastic too. The food wasnt bad, but they were so busy when we..."
Sandy Potter
"Nice people, quick service. Best BBQ pulled pork sandwich I've ever had! Good ice cream..."
Brad Porzelius
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use