Sluurpy
Reset

There are 16 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Shelbyville

There are 16 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Monical's Pizza Of Shelbyville
93/100 (836 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Pizza
Italian
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Its predominantly a thin crust kind of pizza and the breadsticks remind me of soft pretzels. Would recommend but their pizza is vastly different from..."
grr blah
"This was some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. As a truck driver picking up a load down the street from Monical’s; I was able to call for a..."
Antonio Myles
"Very accommodating on short notice... friendly,..."
Jen Beck
"The pizza is always excellent here. I'm a native of Shelbyville but haven't lived here in decades. But, when I can, I love to eat Monical's..."
D Largent
"Very delicious tortellini the best i've ever had..."
Baron Padori
"Always a pleasant, clean and prompt place to eat. Mark Shanks and his crew are definitely a delight in this..."
Dawn Conder
"Very good pizza, very nice customer service. The gluten free pizza was very good. Did like it more the first time I ordered it because it was more..."
Christina Eggert
"First tome eating here ccx and the pizza was fantastic, their thin crust was absolutely perfect. Will definitely make sure that that stop here again..."
Brian Minick
Bellacino's Pizza & Grinders
88/100 (999 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Brunch
Drinks
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Delivery
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Free off-street parking
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Drinks
Brunch
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
Pasghetti's Italian Restaurant
85/100 (396 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Lakeside Pizzeria And Grill On Gun Lake
81/100 (288 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Lunch
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"I absolutely love the pizza and I absolutely adore the customer service the environment is friendly open and welcome and I always enjoy the smile on..."
Bruce “Brewster” Gouin
"We ordered 3 pizza and they were delicious! One was pepperoni and mushrooms, sausage and green peppers, and one topping ham pizza. Bread sticks were..."
Rebecca Wolowicz
"Great local pizza place! They offer a wide variety of pizzas plus many other options. Such as cheeseburgers, subs, appetizers, burritos, pasta,..."
Rebecca Clark
"Stopped by as a friend highly recommended the pizza. Amazing! Great crust and plenty of toppings. Worth the drive from Grand..."
Chris Lewis
"I was stuck 2.5 hours from home with a broken down car and they accepted a delivery after-hours. I was stranded and starving and SO THANKFUL! & the..."
Kenna Garrett
"These people know what they're doing when it comes to making good quality. Always good proportions and filling definitely recommend this place to..."
Joe thiel
"Love Lakeside pizza! When on a trip and get pizza someplace, always comment "This is OK but Lakeside is better". LOVE THAT..."
Jo Anne
"Stumbled upon the Baypointe Inn aa a last minute getaway. Decided to order pizza and glad we did. Very impressed with quality of the pizza. The crust..."
Pamela N
"We ordered our pizza from the lake, docked at the landing, and picked it up. We ordered the deluxe, it was a little light on the sauce but still very..."
Terri Jordan
"When I grew up in the area this was south side pizza. The new owners have remodeled and it is amazing. I always visit in the off season but this..."
Kevin Denzel
"These good folks were not on my radar until yesterday. We'd made plans to go boating with friends on the lake, and stopped in here to grab subs for..."
Dick Terpstra
"Every time we get their pizza it is awesome thin crust and the homemade pizza sauce are the best!! Never had a bad pizza from this..."
m w
"Great place right on the water. The Italian sub with added jalepenao is my favorite or the cheese bread..."
Brett Bauman
Hometown Pizza
85/100 (1083 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Pasta
Salad
Sandwiches
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Free off-street parking
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Seating
Accepts Discover
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Buffet
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"I ordered take out & made a mistake on the order. Got there and they did it right, I was wrong. They made another pizza and....wow!...they were..."
Michael Carson
"Ordered the margherita crisp w/ grilled chicken, & a turkey club, w/ a garden salad for a side. Everything was delicious. Service was excellent. We..."
Dawn Shrum
"Pizza and breadsticks were delicious! This was my first time ordering from here, staff was attentive when you walked in. The whole experience was..."
Chelsey Dixon
"Awesome food and wonderful wait staff/management make this location an easy favorite for anyone who decides to dine here. I've seen some reviews..."
Adrien Kooyman
"We drove from Oklahoma to Kentucky for a wedding. We were in snow and slick roads most of the way resulting in a long trip. We arrived in town and as..."
brad faulkner
Joe's Pizza
76/100 (352 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
American
Italian
American
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Italian
American
Pizza
Dinner
"Pretty good pizza took a really long while to get it about 45 minutes but worth the wait foods overall very good the staff is a bit off no one..."
sharon Lily
"Great Pizza in a small town. Be coming here for years and is always on my list when I am back in Shelbyville. Megan will make sure your meal is..."
Todd Furr
"Great food, good service. I love Joe's every time I..."
William Gambill
"Their pizza is good. Is usually cut in squares and is light on sauce so you could ask for more sauce ig, just a preference thing tho. I enjoyed it..."
Endeavor
"Very good. A little disappointed with the potion size of the chicken breast on the Italian sampler. It was less than 1/2 a chicken breast. Very..."
Carol S
Cagney's Pizza King
75/100 (1100 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Shrimp
Salad
Sit down
Pizza
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Delivery
Takeout
Private Dining
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Mid-range
"Super impressed!!. If you know shelbyville, you know they don't have the best restaurants. Met the hubs out at work and went to lunch here with a..."
Armywife
"If your in Shelbyville, this is a local favorite. Best pizza, breadstix, and appitizers..."
Del Denney
"Cagney's is unlike any other Pizza King! I've yet to visit another PK and get anywhere close to the same quality of food. The burrito supreme w/ sour..."
Jason Myer
"Good food, could use less corn meal on the pizza crust, and more lighting. Very dark, no windows anywhere. Waitress was nice. Would go back for..."
Scott S.
"The food was good, pizza and bread sticks. The server was slow and rude. Plan on slow service if you..."
Greg Martin
"This place is fancy and amazing, I love the spaghetti and garlic bread, service is amazing and even though the sauce in the spaghetti is a little hot..."
XxSlothGirlxX
"The best pizza around. I have been here many times, the waitstaff has always been amazing. Highly..."
Jason McCoy
Don's Pizza & Pasta
74/100 (305 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Pizza was very good. Delivery took longer than expected, would definitely order again but just pick it..."
Salesman
Domino's Pizza
74/100 (254 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
"Its right across the street from me! I love the pizza, wings, and sandwiches! Such great friendly service..."
Elisha Abney
"Just wanted to say how GREAT 3 medium pizzas were i just got about 30 min ago. They looked PERFECT!!! Works of pizza art. These looked like they..."
Randy Compton
"Love that it's open until midnight! It's a shame that taco bell and the rest of fast-food places close when the sun goes down. Very disgusted..."
Keith Smith
"Saved us big time as nightshift workers during the pandemic! They took care of us so we continue to express our loyalty…good food, fair price, and..."
David Ashcraft
"UPDATE: after “reaching out to the store” as instructed by the staff I was contacted by a regional rep named Josh that the store manager has..."
Steve Wakefield
Little Caesars
72/100 (2367 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
"I have to applaud the employees at this place for balancing their time so well, they really did a good job of meeting everyone's needs, giving a..."
Spencer Hirschi
"Pizza is always fresh and loaded with toppings. Staff is very friendly and I love the fact that you can order with the mobile app and pick up your..."
Jessica Miller
"Little Caesar's might be the most cost effective. But, their pizzas are delicious. Their sauce has to me be the best flavor. Always pick up. ..."
Larry lagoy
"I placed a walk in order for 3 pizzas and bread sticks. I got home and one of the pizzas was wrong. I called and talked to Paul the manager and he..."
Sarha Dittz
Little Caesars
72/100 (2583 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
"I have only been to the little Caesars in shelbyville twice, but the first time the young lady at the window was not as friendly as the young man..."
Misty Anderson
Little Caesars
70/100 (2442 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
"It was hot and ready, but the price is to high. I'm not saying anything about it, I think u shouldn't sell out like that General insurance Guy did...."
Dennis Delaney
"The people working here are the best. No matter how busy or hectic it gets, they are always helpful and..."
Sir
"Great employee service...but they were out of breadsticks..i ordered online and paid for them but they didn't have any when i showed up...need to put..."
cory crickmore
"Was quick and the employees were friendly. Good hot and ready..."
Terri H
"Fantastic quality. Some of the resturants vary i suppose but most i have been to have delicious pizza, wings are incredible also surprisingly. Some..."
Jessica Johnson
Domino's Pizza
70/100 (287 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
"Every experience I've had here is good today was great even. Compaired to the competitors in town who I have recived undercooked food from or got..."
Ashley Pristavec-Stine
"One of fev in pizza from hometown best wings..."
Arpit Dream
"Not only the best pizza in town but also good alternative foods like sandwiches and chicken. The people who work there are great..."
Iron Kitsune
"Great prices an good food. Never had a problem with employee or..."
debbie Long
"Their pizza has been very delicious the past year or so and is great for the price. Definitely would recommend trying..."
Logan Peterson
"Good Good Pizza tonight !! ..."
RANT ANDERSON
"Delivery was less than 20 minutes. Thank you for the prompt service with a..."
Richard Clark
"I used to only get pizza at Cagneys, but my order was seldom right. I thought I would try Domino's, and it is my new pizza place. I have ordered here..."
Marcella Gabbard
"I ordered a small hand toss with pepperoni and a order of lava cakes. Ordering was the best and delivery time good and the gentleman that delivered..."
Teresa Miller
Domino's Pizza
70/100 (881 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
"Fast and efficient staff team at this location. Love the Dominos tracker for pick up..."
Parwinder Taank
"Ordered at 9pm and was able to pick up my pizza within 20 minutes. Ulysses was helpful in taking my order correctly and helping me choose the optimal..."
aboywithabag
Riverfront Taproom
70/100 (633 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
American
Bar
Pub
Vegetarian Friendly
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Wings
Burger
"We traveled from Richmond IN. I'm not a craft beer guy. Bud light for me. Having said that though, their afternoon delight beer is awesome! The wife..."
William D. Sponsel
"Great selection of beers, both domestic and craft. Great wines too! Must try The pizzas, brick oven cooked! Far better than ANY corporate pizza..."
Gilbert Smith
"The food is fantastic. But the server I had was the absolute best. Amy was her..."
John Morgan
"Visited tonight for my birthday celebration with the family. The salads & pizza were EXCELLENT - beer cold and delicious, and service fast and..."
Brian Nentrup
"Great place for the beer lover. Food is really good! Great liquor selection and a really great staff working here. Nice friendly atmosphere. I'll be..."
Scott Lesker
"Food was absolutely delicious! Would recommend this place to anyone traveling through town. We will be back for..."
Sherri Browning
"The atmosphere is great and so is the food. Highly..."
Annie Alabaugh
"Great place! Fun atmosphere for women and families. Fantastic beer selection, plus a full bar. Samples available. Jo-Ann worked hard to make sure..."
Susan Monroe Sjoquist
"A neato setup inside the dining area where you can see the beer brewing at work. Well done layout of bar area and extensive beer selection. Lots of..."
Dave and Kyla Bartle
"Great place, good selection of their own brews plus a large selection of local guest taps. The portabello burger is done nicely and makes a good..."
Kristin Bridges
"View of the river is nice and relaxing. We ordered the wings naked and a breaded tenderloin sandwich. Tenderloin was great, best I ever had. Fresh..."
Madonna Herman
"Delicious burger and appetizers. They have the option to sample beer in a flight of 4. Paper straws in your drinks mean they are environmentally..."
Daniel Read
"This place is a breath of fresh air for this town that desperately needs a hug. The good things first: nice open concept for loud screaming kids and..."
beth chesser
"We had a group of 7 including a 5 year old child. We were seated promptly and the server came over seconds later. The food was hot and good. I had..."
Joni Curtis
Pizza Hut
70/100 (124 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
"Always great, fast, and friendly service! Thanks for always making my dining experience..."
Aaron Harkins
"I couldn't find one bad thing to say about this restaurant. I don't understand the bad reviews and I truly think it's some small town mentality..."
Megan Chelf Fisher
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use