Sluurpy
Reset

There are 4 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Selden

There are 4 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Nick And Gina Restaurant
85/100 (266 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
"My cousin ordered pizza from here and not gonna lie it was amazing. It was 2 regular pies we had along with some garlic knots. The crust had an..."
Ahtasham Ali
"Read about this local spot on a facebook group and I have never felt more like family! Kim was our waitress and she was attentive, charismatic and an..."
Meagan Louise
"Great food and friendly service. The chicken night special is a great..."
Amanda Morris
"I wish I had taken a picture before I devoured this cake but I wanted to share how great it was. This was the best slice of rainbow cake I've had...."
Lauren Genzale
"Excellent customer service ! Very kind and professional food is always fresh and delicious . The place is very clean ! I recommend anyone to try this..."
Lili
"Great Pizza. Nice and thin crust. Order well done you'll love it...."
Paul Pryor
"I have to say that the food is DELICIOUS! I have been here a few times and ordered all different types of food....pastas, pizzas and hero's and..."
QCM
"Can not beat the quality or service for the food. Great atmosphere for the holidays as..."
Eric Reimann
"I ordered from Salvinos for the first time and was very happy with delivery time and the portions were huge. The food was amazing. Definitely my new..."
Anita Garifo
"We love Salvino's! Always friendly every time we come in, with a lot of great deals for takeout. Dining in is even better with the delicious fresh..."
Marc Lee
"Garlic knots are AWESOME! Definitely order the penne alla..."
nicole strong-minchin
"I loved the chicken Parm and the garlic knots with the Caesar..."
Christopher Bowen
"Delicious crispy slices great on the carriage good..."
Jason Andria
"Salvino's is a great place their Pizza is great they're pasta dishes are great too their service with dining is very well very professional as well..."
Grayson Gustavson
Caffe Amici
81/100 (1655 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken Parmigiana
Shrimp
Bakery
Eggplant
Slice of Pizza
Salad
Chicken Marsala
Ceaser Salad
Seafood Delight
Tiramisú
Cannoli
Tortellini
Pesto
Shrimp Francese
caesar salad
Pasta Purses
BBQ chicken wings
Chicken Capriciosa
cheese pizza
Rigatoni Filetto
Lobster ravioli
Pollo Mona Lisa
Garlic Rolls
Eggplant Slider
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Takeout
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Delivery
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"First time visiting this pizzeria restaurant. It was great! Very busy night though during pasta night. It's best if you make a reservation. I didn't..."
Ariana Ferrin
"MAN! that was good! I’m so stuffed! Pasta allaVodka with meat was fantastic, minestrone soup, garlic knots and red velvet cake with raspberry..."
Shawn Noonan
"Caffe Amici is fabulous! The waitress went out of her way to check to see how a particular menu item was prepared. She was patient and attentive. The..."
Anne DeSimone
"We went on pasta night. I had the lasagna, and a side of sausage. Nice portions, we all brought food home. Everyone was happy with their meals. Our..."
Darryl Brooks
"Best Italian Restaurant in Central Suffolk, possibly all of Suffolk and possibly all of Nassau too. As a matter of fact… I think they have Queens..."
James Thomas
"Always a great experience. Food, atmosphere does not dissappoint. Just wish there was another restaurant closer to my home, but will travel..."
Marybeth Spano
"I love italian food and this restaurant have amazing pasta and the sangria is really good and the dessert so delicious. the price is reasonable,..."
Elizabeth Fuentes
"If i could have given 10 stars for service, I would have. The front counter team was extremely friendly and helpful. I walk with a cane and ordered a..."
Ed cernyar
"Excellent service, friendly and attentive staff. The parking lot offers plenty of parking. The linguini pescatore came out too hot to eat, and..."
Executive Group Realty
"This place has the best food. The best servers and the atmosphere is amazing. Everyone is laughing and enjoying the food and spirits. They also have..."
Uncle Bishoppe's Kitchen
"Absolutely delicious authentic Italian cuisine. Wonderful service, portions are tremendous, and everything tasted delicious. Joe is very attentive to..."
Alison Elizabeth
"The food and the service was impeccable. I highly recommend. The waitress was excellent. Loved everything 5 ⭐ in my..."
Theresa Fitzpatrick
"Mr. Jonathan didn’t know how to make a Espresso Martini however he asked for assistance from Amanda. Excellent drink and got I got 2. Well done..."
Maria Vilardi
"Great restaurant. Had my boss’s retirement party there and we had no complaints. Been there for lunch numerous times. The price is very reasonable..."
Stacey Stephenson
"the food is amazing, the only thing i could complain about is the minestrone soup is nottttttt minestrone soup .. it was just a huge piece of..."
laura G
Zara Pizza And Restaurant
75/100 (2116 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
"I live in Selden for over 20 years and almost behind your backyard. but I’ve never been there . My taste buds were asking for home made pasta with..."
Suely D'Andrea Vera
"Very good margherita pie! Good sweet sauce! Crispy crust..."
Mikey ponyboy2992
"I ordered a large catering order for my daughters second birthday and the food was all fantastic. Our favorite was the eggplant parm it was one of..."
Victoria Lin
"I always order from here when we have parties at our house. Always very impressed with everything the offer. Had a party today for my sons 9th..."
Anthony Pavone
"Consistently delicious food, good sized portions and friendly staff. Have used them for a few catering events and all my guests raved about the food...."
Fatima Martins
"Love this place! The food is always outstanding! Highly recommend the chicken Francese and the Buffalo wings! and it’s perfect set up for a..."
ruoxi li
"Best reg pie on Long Island... Prove me wrong... Its not everyday that a gem is found in Selden but this slice is outstanding. I don't know how it..."
Justin Deptula
"Man.... One of my friend told me they have really good chicken francese and yes it was really good and I also had slice a pizza next to it.. bread..."
sezgin mavzer
"I shop there all the time and they never fail. Always fresh food and friendly staff. Love their calamari and always fresh pizza pies. Also perfect..."
Burcu Soyseven Naz
"Since moving to selden from Flushing where we had great pizza. This place is my go to spot for a good solid typical pizza. I love my pizza welldone..."
Jeffrey Cousin
"The pizza here was always good with a slightly crispy crust but my wife and I always thought the cheese was the achilles heel of the pizza. Now that..."
Arnie Jonassen
"All of the food is delicious I recommend trying it favorites are the vodka sauce, chicken bacon ranch pizza, the Zara salad and very good shrimp..."
Christopher Manzi
"When I first ate the pizza, the first thing I thought of was Dominos. I actually really enjoyed it. Great..."
Hormuz N.
"Best Buffalo Slice I have ever had in my life and I have tried many different..."
T F
"First time trying this place. It was amazing food. Definitely will be back next..."
Kaitlyn Lohan
"Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. Found it by accident since we had a soccer tournament close by and took the kids there between games...."
Dwight Henning
"This is my new go-to for lunch! Staff is friendly and go above and beyond, the food is delish and the overall service is top notch! Zara’s is a..."
Ashley Markellos
Boccone Pizzeria & Ristorante
71/100 (524 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
"Had my first meal sitting in the dining room. It was perfect. The service was amazing and food as well. We had a table of 10, and the service kept up..."
Ben The Handyman
"We will drive past four other pizzerias in our area to patronize this restaurant and it as nothing do do with their inflation buster prices. Their..."
Charlie & Paula
"This place is the bomb! All inclusive dinners for 17$!!!!! Including wine and dessert. You have to try it. I am here from Florida, and I go once a..."
Robert Desanto
"Midweek $12.99 lunch special was a real deal. Entree, salad, drink, cookies and cannoli. Food was prepared correctly and portion sizes were generous...."
Richard Dorfman
"Can't beat the food. Everything is delicious. The atmosphere is festive and welcoming. We have eaten in and have had our parties catered prices are..."
Cindy Serra
"The food is amazing! Nelson was soooo amazing helping my sister & me place a large catering order in a short period of time! The food we ordered..."
Erin D.
"We absolutely love this place! The food is excellent, the Mon-Wed, three course dinner is exceptional value, but what really sets them apart is the..."
BC340
"Recently visited for a friends wedding reception and was pleasantly surprised by the quality of the food. We had a set menu, so we didn't get to..."
Alex Wolfe
"Hosted my SILs baby shower there in November of 2022. Everything was fantastic! The manager Nelson was MORE than accommodating to all our needs, we..."
Marialla Santos
"This place is the greatest pizza place in the world ever. The managers Sebastian and Nelson really care about their customers. Always a smile and..."
Kenny Tax (Long Island Foodies)
"I ordered the chicken parm, and it exceeded all my expectations. The portion was generous, and the chicken was thick, juicy, and cooked to..."
Jake Tuohy
"WOW, just WOW! This place is AMAZING! With it having been such a rough week, my GF & I went out to Capellini's for dinner. We'd never tried it..."
Ryan G.
"Had dinner here for the first time and it was amazing!! I had the Eggplant Parm and hubby had the combo with meatballs, cheese ravioli, manicotti and..."
kristina paternostro
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use