Review Jimmy's Greek American Grill - Sebring

I was in town for an interview and met a friend for lunch at Jimmy's. I was skeptical because the restaurant is in an abandoned mall but I was impressed. My greek salad was great, especially that potato salad! The grape leaves were on a nice platter with veggies and plenty of tzaziki. My friend ordered the souvlaki, it came with a salad and fries. The baklava for dessert was perfect. Everything was great, as was the service. Thank you for this great lunch! We will be back.

Great sub! Be nice if they would put in soda fountain with ice. Staff was very friendly and efficient. Sitting in food court just isn't the best atmosphere.

The food had been made perfect. It is worth getting a to-go box just to get more of it. And I will say the staff is nice and understanding, so it is worth trying it, you will not regret it

Day at Sebring Racetrack was made better by lunch at Jimmy’s Greek Grill. Fantastic food, huge portions and service was excellent. Gyro with the grilled pita was great. Will return for lunch again. Great job.

First time in Sebring: here for the afternoon only. Saw this place on my trip, looked up the menu, and decided to check it out. Surprise bonus: they have a drive up window. I always love establishments with these, especially during the pandemic. I'm uncomfortable eating in many places today, so this is a nice touch. You may want to check out the menu in advance, as there's no speaker box or anything. You just pull up and tell them your order. Service was prompt and courteous, even from the window. I ordered the gyro platter, with extra fries instead of the Greek salad. The food reached me piping hot and in the appropriate containers. The gyro was pretty tasty, especially the roasted meat. The French fries were decent, but nothing to write home over. I appreciated their slightly sweet taste, but to me, they were missing the seasoning bit of a sweet/salty combo. In all, not a bad lunch. Prices are fair for the amount of food received. I would come back for a meal if I visit Sebring again.

So I was skeptical about the food because of the fact it was 1/2 food options in the mall and let me tell y’all… BEST Philly cheesesteak I’ve ever had! They sadly didn’t have A1 but this Philly didn’t even need it because it was so good. The food was made fresh and it felt like a home cooked meal. I honestly am upset I don’t live closer because I’d be here everyday. The fries were fried so perfectly and had a nice crunch but remained soft at the same time. I definitely recommend this place, their portions are great and they’re definitely not greedy. If you’re skeptical how I was don’t be, you won’t regret eating here! With that being said, try their Philly cheesesteak!!

Went for lunch. Quick to sit where we wanted. I had a gyro platter (hold the fries & got extra salad). It was good, flavor was ok... Mom got the Combo #2, she liked it and took some home. Waitress' were great, friendly and quick. 12/26/16: back for Moussaka, good portion and served at a nice hot temp. Thanks :)

Do you want a gyro then I highly recommend this restaurant. It's by far one of the best gyro you can buy bar none. The tzatziki sauce is good with out causing gas. They make other things there great as well baklava is not the greatest but it is great.

Everything was very clean and the wait staff was friendly. We ate breakfast and it's not only cheap but it's a lot of food. I don't care for Greek cooking but they have lots American favorites to choose from, at least at breakfast when I went. I ordered pancakes and bacon for $5.99. I ate all my 4 pieces of bacon but only one of the 3 giant pancakes. Supper yummy and I'll be back again.

Love it and Excellent Customer Satisfaction from the lady in cashier 💯 Thank you 😊 😀 And it's in the lake shore mall In front of AMC theaters food court.. and they have a restaurant hidden as well.

Food was really good. My boys split a Gyro and double order of fries. They ate every bite and loved it.

This little place is in the food court in the mall, we tried the steak quesadilla with fries and a gyro platter, very good, the people there were very friendly, the prices are good. Everything is made fresh and they will do special orders too. Been there 3 times and we will be back.

I love this place. It is sad it will no longer be at this location and closing soon. I am sorry I just discovered it and didn't come in sooner. The food was amazing and the staff was like family. It was like going to your favorite aunts house. It just felt warm and the staff was just so friendly. It will surely be missed. Hope they consider opening soon in the area because I for one need more cabbage wraps, and gyros and that amazing service.

I order the Greek salad with chicken and it is PHENOMENAL!!! Every time! The dressing is delish the chicken has SO MUCH flavor. I wish them every success!

The food here is great, just like the selection. Best gyros in town, but their store hours listed are a bit confusing. One says 7 to 7, another sign says 11 to 2. Worth going for lunch anyway, feel free to call ahead.

Food was absolutely excellent. Even more impressive because one of the cooks was not available today, during the lunch rush; there was only one cook. The food quality did not decrease as result, as one would expect. The quality remained excellent! My compliments, and hats off to the cook for holding down the fort, single handedly, and still doing an amazing job!

Great food, friendly staff. The menu has a great variety of items to choose from.

I love Jimmies.....we go every Saturday and Sunday morning. Staff is welcoming, Jimmy is always amongst his patrons. We eat breakfast, it is always great they even bring me the blackberry jam that I love, when they see me sit down. Great service always. Its nice to see allot of the Sebring families eating breakfast on the weekends there.

The Pastichio is the best I've had since we've been in FL. Media was a very personable server. Enjoyed last nights supper very much.

Great service and the best Gyro and French fries are the best!!

It was pushing it to say it was authentic Green, but the food was fine. The waitress was amusing and that made it better.

Your owner is garbage and likes to harass people that she doesnt even know!

Excellent food, good prices and portions, and a friendly staff! Great little hometown Greek restaurant.

We have been in Florida since Jan 1st and just had the best meal since we been here

Have eaten there twice. Will never again. A roach crawled across our table while we were eating. I could not finish my food.

Great food

Love this place!! Gyro's are outstanding...so is everything on the menu!

Great food anytime! Breakfast, lunch and dinner!

Love that place, especially Jimmy.....we are missing it while in Indiana!!! But we shall return late December.

Love their breakfast and gyros. Will definitely be back.

Great food & service. Always go there while in Sebring. #followthelocals