Linda Brown Steigleider
+5
Always a treat to eat at Crabby Amy’s!
I had the lobster roll ( knuckle and claw meat!) and my husband had the crab cake sandwich- both were awesome. It rained a little but other than that it was perfect!
Loved this spot for years!! Friendly service, great, fresh food and perfect sized portions
We had our first visit there yesterday 7/31 and absolutely loved it ! I had the Clam Strips basket and my wife had the Shrimp basket both super delicious!! Service was great quick and friendly. We will for sure be back !!!
nice spot, local vibe, super nice staff!
Nice staff. Food and drinks are great.
Huge shoutout to Amy herself and her Crabby Amy's Bar for outstanding food and service. Sesame Tuna Wrap with a glass of chilled Chardonnay was exactly what the doctor ordered;)
Thank you guys!
Tucked in a marina we were pleasantly surprised to have a wonderful meal at this spot. The raw clams were exceptionally fresh and tasty. Hot lobster roll was definitely a winner, we asked kitchen to scoop out some dough from bun, and they gave us a thinner bun, appreciated the step above on my order. Fried clams came out hot crunchy plentiful serving. Cole slaw crunchy subtle dressing. Music playing outside relaxing and enjoying. Large umbrella shaded us, ocean breeze perfect.
I really enjoyed this place is my first time here I've heard about it a lot of times. It was a cool place to come have a couple drinks by the water, we had some clams and some muscles it was cute and quiet. The staff was very friendly constantly checking on us to see if we want anything else. pretty sure it gets busy at in the evening was starting to get crowded when we left. This parking in the marina itself against the fence so we didn't have to worry about that. Pretty nice crowd mixed families and couples and friends just having a good old time. Definitely we're checking it out.
First time there and the food and service were excellent. Staff is friendly. Great atmosphere and reminds me of a great little hole on the wall fish fry type restaurant... But with the extra added perk of being right on the water...
Good food, great outdoors and super friendly staff !
Delicious food. Great vibe. Highly recommend it.
Excellent relaxing place to enjoy the food and atmosphere of being by docks and water, it has that locals feel but very welcoming to all, staff was great, friendly and helpful would recommend for a relaxed meal with family or friends! Give it a try you won't be sorry!
My daughter and her boyfriend ate here on Tuesday night and enjoyed it. So my wife and I went on Wednesday night. It's outside dining on a deck near the water.
First you wait for or find a table. Then you look at the menu then go up front to order. Tonight there was one (new, first night!) young lady taking orders and taking payment. Then there was only one young man working as the waiter, running around like crazy.
I had the over stuffed lobster roll which was very good. However, the bun was not toasted enough, so it became soggy. The lobster meat was fresh and flavourful. The side of beer battered onion rings was very good as well.
My wife had the grilled fish tacos which she enjoyed but thinks it had jarred salsa in it, not fresh.
They lost the 5th star only for the amount of time it took to get our order.
Next time, I want to try one of the fried seafood baskets.
This restaurant is a bit secluded, but always happy to stop here on the way home from Jones Beach. Seaford seems fresh and they have a few beers, wine, and sangria. The two times I've been here I've gotten the lobster bake which comes with a whole lobster, corn on the cob, white clam chowder, some mussels, and clams. I enjoyed it and had some sangria to go with it.
Pro DJ Productions & Photo Booths
+5
On the water. Good sangria. Good food. Great vibe. Located in treasure island marina. Come here for fresh seafood!
If their were more stars to give i would this place is great but the girls and boys working here are amazing always helpful smiley and always willing to go the extra mile for anyone. I truly recommend it..
The food is excellent. The wine is reasonably priced.
The service is friendly and accommodating.
The setting is perfect for the warmer months: it's outdoors under a shading structure surrounded by colorful potted flowering plants. And on a sunny day, the bay water shimmers.
Jessica Cooper Foltin, MD
+5
Seaside eatery next to / within Treasure Island Marina.
We haven't been here in a bit . Sometimes you just go to the right spot at the right time and this checked all the boxes. Casual, local, waterside, easy and reasonably priced. Check. The menu has expanded and I really enjoyed the clam strips and corn on the cob. Nothing fancy but just nice and easy. Great, attentive service. Thank you, we'll be back
The muscles in white wine were fun. The hot lobster roll was great. My daughter's fried shrimp were huge and cooked perfectly. It was crazy busy and we waited and waited but I can't deduct anything as the food was worth it.
The food was great ,everything was delicious,service was a little slow but I don’t think they expected the crowd they got but they were able to call in backup’s,the little bugs from the water were a little annoying but they were at all the waterfront restaurants
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes