Sluurpy
Reset

There are 4 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best New York Style Pizza in Sarasota

There are 4 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Rico's Pizzeria
89/100 (1154 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Lunch
Dinner
New York Style Pizza
Sandwiches
Pesto
Pasta
Salad
Wings
Meatballs
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Television
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Honestly some of the best food we've had. And the service was amazing. Our server was so nice and attentive! Thank you, Rico's for an amazing..."
Kimberly Pitts
"Sibel and Adrianna are the best!!! I recently had the pleasure of dining at Ricoā€™s Pizza, and I must say, it was a truly unforgettable experience...."
Marshall Jones
"I have eaten here many times 5stars- pizza is wonderful & staff is always helpful. Tonight I planned a takeout meal- my order took more than normally..."
L J
"Authentic Italian pizza and pasta right here! The food was AMAZING, and tasted just look food I've had in Rome. Portions were huge, and I will easily..."
Kristina Pannone
"Went in this morning to finally try Rico's as it's talked about so much on social media. Delish!!! I ordered 2 different slices and both were..."
Jason Collins
"I am in heaven right now. I just stopped here and got a chicken sandwich with roasted peppers and jalapenos, and the cheese Pull is out of this..."
Sarah Brockie
"What a little gem of a place. We were visiting the States from the UK and we had ride out to Venice and stopped at this place on the way back to our..."
Emma Small
"Wow.. where to start... I was in the area looking for pizza.. this shows first on the list.. we we weren't disappointed! Walked in got a seat waiter..."
Kurt Parker
"The pizza here in excellent. Every time we are in Sarasota or even close by, we will go out of our way to get the pizza here!..."
Andy Petterson
"Had pizza delivery to our office a few weeks ago & sadly it wasnā€™t the greatest.. Today gave em another shot & So Happy we did. Knocked it out of..."
Monica u
"Great pizza! Ordered 5 pizzas 2 weekends ago! Delivery driver did a great job making sure we were takin care of! Buffalo chicken pizza was..."
Westin Wilson
"I went to Ricoā€™s tonight for dinner and I want to compliment how the girls handled a situation tonight that I witnessed. I heard them getting..."
Robert White
"This was so good, the pizza crust Is delicious, I'm not a big fan of pizza tails but I ate these ones! It was so well balanced! I ordered the Arugula..."
Sabrina R
"It seems like every time I go to Ricos I always get the new girl that just started that week. Heā€™s having a hard time hanging on the people. I..."
Anthony Recupero
"Went here for lunch today. They've been here for 30 years and nothings changed...Still great. Had the lunch special 2 slices and a soda for $10. The..."
Neil McStravick
"Our favorite pizzeria in Sarasota. You can enjoy anything from pizza to pasta and anything in between. Salads are always cold and so fresh. Pizza..."
Maria Sarullo-Wieand
"People were nice, the food was absolutely delicious!! We got a margarita pizza, Brischetta and a Caesar salad. They were all amazing and HIGHLY..."
Kevin Huggins
"Among the best pizza you can have in Sarasota. Always consistent. Service was pretty good in the evening rush. They had a birthday party and a..."
Jared Schaeffer
Il Panificio Usa
79/100 (862 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Deli
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Lunch
Late Night
Breakfast
Dinner
Pepperoni Pineapple Pizza Slice
Cakes
Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Pesto
Sandwiches
Chicken Parmesan Sub
Cola
Eggplant Pizza Gluten Free Pizza
Any 1 2 Salad
Ricotta Cheese Pizza Pie
Hawaiian Pizza
Italian Salad
Eggplant
Pizza by the Slice
Pasta
Salad
Cannoli
Marguerite Pizza
New York Style Pizza
Sit down
Deli
Pizza
Italian
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Iā€™ll Pacifico has the best New York style pizza I have ever tasted. Their thin dough comes from the owners grandmother and is over 100 years old..."
Joe T Woods
"Literally the best most flavorful pizza Iā€™ve ever had. Love the thin crust. They have more seasonings on table if you wish. Very nice cozy place...."
Lin G.
"Best pizza on the key. Not cheap but the best. Rip fire is also good for individual pizzas with any topping combinations. A couple of our door tables..."
Mark Mulone
"The pizza here is delicious. I actually called the Main St. location after calling 5 different pizza places because I really needed curbside pickup,..."
Itzayana Mares
"Found out this place has breakfast pizza! I introduced this kind of pizza to my girlfriend and both of her kids and they loved it! I'm so very..."
Florida Traveler
"Great pizza. Great variety of toppings. While pies or buy a slice. -..."
Jonathan James
"Is this place a little rough around the edges? Do you you feel like youā€™ve just stepped into an authentic New York deli? Is it a great pre or post..."
Tim Whitley
"Every Sunday I head out on the boat and order the Sicilian pizza half and half. Itā€™s the closest thing to ny pizza Iā€™ve found so far. Must try...."
Lori Soldi
"Delicious!!! Taste of NYC right here in Florida. The meatballs are bursting with flavor and very tender. The cheese is high quality and the sauce..."
Susan Stender
"Best pizza I've found in Florida for thin crust, semi-new York..."
Dave Kelly
"The BEST pizza we've eaten since coming to FL in the 80s. Discovered this place 27 years ago while working downtown. The original owner was the..."
phyllis cruz
"Great pizza. A new building is going up in their current location - I hope they relocate somewhere close by; I'd be a shame if they shut..."
Greg Moore
"The food here was good and service was great. I made a mistake and ordered from different restaurant and they called and cancelled for me and made my..."
Brian Williamson
"Excellent pizza. A beautifully crafted thin crust, great texture, crisped..."
Daniel R
Patellini's Pizza
78/100 (1803 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Lunch
Late Night
Drinks
Dinner
Salad
New York Style Pizza
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Reservations
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Delivery
Takeout
Television
Dinner
Lunch
Drinks
Late Night
Cheap Eats
"Just what I needed. Would like to eat next door at Duval's--but that will have to wait (and is a little out of my league). This place has lots beyond..."
Bruce Richardson
"Below average. It wasnā€™t terrible pizza, just seemed to lack enough stuff on top of the crust. I had the lunch special, 2 cheese slices and a..."
Art
"Pizza was fresh, excellent quality food, nice atmosphere, great salads..."
Laurie Denomme
"Had the calzone and it was very good. Would of liked to try the pizza but needed different items for multiple family members and the calzone was the..."
Food Traveler
"White Pizza To Die For. This was undoubtedly the best pizza I've ever had. One slice was the size of my head and was at a great price. It's located..."
Alex Arnett
"Great pizza! I would definitly recommend it if you like NY..."
Jb
"Lol. I was gonna write the same thing as someone already did..... THE BEST PIZZA IN SARASOTA OR IN FLORIDA!wow and I had a hot New Yorker..."
Nicole
"The best pizza in..."
Lindsay Lee
"So the pepperoni pizza I got is really good! They did bring the pizza outside to us but it's self-serve you get your utensils to the right of where..."
Spangle Taylor
"Very traditional New York style pizza: like you'd find all over the New York City area. Sauce is delicious, as was cheese and toppings. Crust is a..."
Craig Cunningham
"We had a craving for a good cheese pizza and we decided to give Patelliniā€™s Pizza a try. It did not disappoint. The New York style cheese pizza was..."
Mike Hopkins
"Now this is really good pizza! The crust was perfect and there was just the right amount of toppings. Haven't had a pizza this good in years. The..."
Kells (BossLady_K)
"We ordered delivery and can report, this is the best pizza we've had in Sarasota. The sauce in particular was delicious. The crust could use a bit..."
D I
"Biggest pizza Iā€™ve seen personally. I have to say that most pizza I order that you would consider NY style pizza is usually dripping grease...."
Maurice Jones
"Best pizza. Excellent crust. Can order by the slice with whatever toppings you..."
Jennifer Hancock
"This pizza was awesome! The flavor wasnā€™t strong, the cheese wasnā€™t too thick. The crust was the right amount of crunchy and chewy. I wish I..."
Ryan Coleman
"Never had NY Style pizza before so I canā€™t give it the most proper judgement, but the cheese slice was delicious and didnā€™t break the bank! Got a..."
Xander Cantrell
"Pizza and salad last night during a hurricane. It was our backup plan to sushi which was closed. Grew up in NY, worked in Manhattan for years. ..."
PJ Guthy
"Pizza here is pretty good. They have a great deal with 2 slices of pizza and a drink for a great value. And adding toppings is only 55c. It's always..."
Matthew Parvin
"Day of christmas boat parade, they accommodated my party of 10. Pizza was huge and fantastic. 20 inch is massive! Some crusts were a bit under cooked..."
shauna stallings
"Very high quality pizza! We enjoyed the 2 slice and a drink deal for $5.99. I would say it's a phenomenal value for the size of the slice of pizza..."
Zach Starnes
"They always run a special, today it was 2 slices cheese pizza and a drink for $7.99 plus tax. I go to the movies at the downfown Regal theater and..."
Sadler L. James
Il Panificio Usa
77/100 (1217 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Deli
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Deli
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Lunch
Late Night
Breakfast
Dinner
Cannoli
New York Style Pizza
Sandwiches
Cakes
Pesto
Eggplant
Pasta
Salad
Fast food
Deli
Pizza
Italian
Television
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Iā€™ll Pacifico has the best New York style pizza I have ever tasted. Their thin dough comes from the owners grandmother and is over 100 years old..."
Joe T Woods
"Literally the best most flavorful pizza Iā€™ve ever had. Love the thin crust. They have more seasonings on table if you wish. Very nice cozy place...."
Lin G.
"Best pizza on the key. Not cheap but the best. Rip fire is also good for individual pizzas with any topping combinations. A couple of our door tables..."
Mark Mulone
"The pizza here is delicious. I actually called the Main St. location after calling 5 different pizza places because I really needed curbside pickup,..."
Itzayana Mares
"Found out this place has breakfast pizza! I introduced this kind of pizza to my girlfriend and both of her kids and they loved it! I'm so very..."
Florida Traveler
"Great pizza. Great variety of toppings. While pies or buy a slice. -..."
Jonathan James
"Is this place a little rough around the edges? Do you you feel like youā€™ve just stepped into an authentic New York deli? Is it a great pre or post..."
Tim Whitley
"Every Sunday I head out on the boat and order the Sicilian pizza half and half. Itā€™s the closest thing to ny pizza Iā€™ve found so far. Must try...."
Lori Soldi
"Delicious!!! Taste of NYC right here in Florida. The meatballs are bursting with flavor and very tender. The cheese is high quality and the sauce..."
Susan Stender
"Best pizza I've found in Florida for thin crust, semi-new York..."
Dave Kelly
"The BEST pizza we've eaten since coming to FL in the 80s. Discovered this place 27 years ago while working downtown. The original owner was the..."
phyllis cruz
"Great pizza. A new building is going up in their current location - I hope they relocate somewhere close by; I'd be a shame if they shut..."
Greg Moore
"The food here was good and service was great. I made a mistake and ordered from different restaurant and they called and cancelled for me and made my..."
Brian Williamson
"Excellent pizza. A beautifully crafted thin crust, great texture, crisped..."
Daniel R
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use