Carrina's Pizzeria

I recently moved to Florida from NY. Desperate to find a pizza place as close to NY pizza as possible, I stumbled upon Palermo. Hands-down the best pizza I've had here in Florida so far. Regular slices were thin and crispy (without tasting like cardboard), lotsa cheese and a nice amount of dark/spicy sauce. Very flavorful! Haven't had the Sicilian yet but am looking forward to trying it out. Btw, their ice cream is beyond delicious!!! Definitely give this place a try. A+

Wow!!!! The Best Pizza in Florida. The happiest moment followed by sadness. I finally found the perfect crust with the freshest ingredients and sadly one more day to closing. On the bright side they have homemade ice cream and will be opening a shop here in Gulf Gate in the next few weeks. Another win for me please support this Boston guy who knows how to make it the natural way. If you want to taste the real Pizza stop by Sunday July 31 between 4 pm to 9pm and taste the real crust Jersey, New York and of course Massachusetts.. Your new Fan Virgo Laura..

We visited here because they are ranked #1 pizzain sarasota on TripAdvisor. We were a little unsure as it was in a small plaza off the main road and not too many other people at the restaurant when we arrived. But the pizza was great. The server was so helpful and turned on the video arcade games for our kids to play while we waited thankfully. The best part of the visit was the homemade ice cream. The owner makes his own ice cream, unique flavors that aren't found other places. Will definitely be back.

Amazing is all I have to say. Best customer service I have ever had. We came in late, 10 minutes before closing, planning to get icecream and then leave. We saw the menu and ordered a pizza. He insisted on us eating the pizza right out of the oven because it was better that way. He was right, they ended up staying open 30 minutes late for us, and we were so appreciative of the customer service. The food was delicious and the place was clean. I would definitely go back.

I went there in watch of good New York style Pizza and was surprised by Pete’s Sweet Treats. Pete gave me so many samples and I liked flavors I normally am not fond of. I was amazed at the great pizza and the gourmet ice cream was the best I have tasted. No artificial colors either. I was very pleased until my kids father ate all my ice cream lol. Guess we will both be making a tri back very soon.

This local family-owned and operated restaurant was recommended to me by a good friend. I took my wife and two daughters to the restaurant on a Saturday night. We were greeted with a smile and were sitting at a table quickly. If you’d like real authentic pizza, made with fresh ingredients with the dough made on site by hand, this is the place for you. My daughters are very particular about their pizza and they absolutely loved the pizza. As for me, I’m a big cheesesteak fan and I was not disappointed. The bread is made fresh every day on site. The cheesesteak is made fresh with lots of meat and was absolutely delicious. My wife is a big meatball sub fan and she fell in love with this one. We had such a great time we decided to try the Italian ice and handmade ice cream. Both were excellent. We will be back in soon, and will become regulars, for certain. We were very enamored with this restaurant and the staff; it was a terrific experience all around.

Wife and I just happened to stop in after reading reviews about good New York style pizza. We were not disappointed. Peter makes one great pie. And the kicker is they make own ice cream. Delaney did a great job keeping our Pepsi glasses full (fyi great ice to boot) and wrapping up our ice cream to go. A return visit is required so we can try Peter’s subs. Place is hard to see from US 41 but turn on Brueckner Drive.