There are 15 restaurants

Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Sandusky

There are 15 restaurants
Selected filters:
Sort A-Z
near you
The Brick Oven Bistro
93/100 (764 ratings)
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Late Night
Chicken Alfredo
Roast Beef
"We yelped this place and went with it due to the good reviews. One thing I have to say is...delicious. The bread can be chosen gluten free, create..."
Chris Pastenes
"Our trip from Chicago around Lake Erie thru Canada found us at this out of the way establishment IPhones’s Siri directed us here as a best of Cedar..."
Kirsten Kelly
"This place is amazing! Our server Matt was fun and Derek made sure he took great care of us when they were rushed with wet cedar point riders. The..."
Terri Hall
"Hands down the best brock over pizza I've had. Next time I am in town, I will 100% be back. Fantastic beer list as well. Waitress was wonderful, and..."
Chris Kinney
"These photos are from last December when we had dinner with my daughter who recently moved to the area. The service was awesome - we were seated..."
Bren Haas
"Very good wood fired pizza. Much different than many other wood fired pies being a very thin crust. The edge crust is more like a crispy cracker. I..."
Eric Lundberg
"My wife and I are not from the area and decided to try The Brick Oven Bistro for dinner. The pizza was made with quality ingredients which made..."
Troy Herbert
"A great casual place with good pizza. The plus is that they were able to cater to vegetarians - vegans and have a full bar. They got our order right,..."
David DiMeo
"Good food , but what I had originally ordered I wasn't able to get because they were out of the..."
Ashley 25
Danny Boy's Italian Eatery
91/100 (411 ratings)
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
"This place is amazing!!! Awesome menu with so many choices, and really good prices. My kids sat down and played cards that were provided on each..."
Marie Kissick Smith
"We were looking for a place to eat after attending The Honda Family Festival at Cedar Point and were so glad to find Danny Boys!!! Our waitress,..."
Dave Johnson
"We rented the party room for our sons birthday party and we could not have been happier. Sarah was our hostess and she was friendly with everyone and..."
Scott Mapus
"We just tried this place yesterday for my Granddaughters birthday. We were staying at Kalahari and needed dinner so we looked online and found this..."
Mary Richardson
"We love this place! Always and amazing meal, and great atmosphere! Never a disappointment. If you're in Sandusky and looking for non-chain food this..."
Lollie Sabo
"Awesome food, friendly efficient staff, great patio. I will definitely make a point to stop here..."
Lisa Hohman
"Mark was our server. Mark always does an excellent job taking care of us. The salad was fresh and crisp, garlic bread hot and fresh and our entrees..."
Angela Carter Carr
"We came here years ago on vacation and loved the whole experience! We have talked about taking a road trip to come back for a while now. While on..."
Amy Dixon-Wyant
"Great service, friendly and efficient! The food is FANTASTIC! Highly recommend! I would also recommend the..."
Jennifer Conn Miller
"We just celebrated a surprise birthday party there and we were beyond impressed with the overall hospitality, service, food, and friendliness of all..."
Nicole Warner Schwarz
"The place is great! Excellent staff, super friendly! The menu looks fabulous although I've only tried the Big Lebowski. This sandwich is..."
Brian Vaught
"The BEST Italian food I've had since grandmas. I so recommend this place. Great service and great..."
Denni Greenlee Gale
"This was my first experience with Danny Boys. I must say the food was delicious, the staff were very friendly and I really enjoyed my..."
Denise Puskar
"The most amazing pies ever! Chicago deep dish was the best I've ever had! Nachos were great as..."
Jorge Barrera
"Tried this place for the first time yesterday. Amazing food and service. Definitely will be..."
Steve Piper
"Our waiter Michael was amazing! We had a large number of people. He was spot on! He went the extra mile. Couldnt have asked for someone better! Also..."
Kimberlina Elena
"Perfect dinner choice to end our quick vacation to Cedar Point and Put in Bay. Food, service, and atmosphere were excellent! Out of all of the..."
Jason McClannen
"Went to this restaurant when staying at the Great Wolf Lodge. Food was quick and really good. My daughter and I got pasta while my fiancé got pizza...."
"Great pasta and pizza with other stuff. Great place to eat we loved everything we got. There bread is really good. The Alfredo is great. I am..."
Robert Hamilton
"Amazing service! They got creative in getting our group seated family style a few weeks ago. These times are so challenging for restaurants right..."
Heather R
"My husband and I had our Valentines dinner at Danny Boys, I had the Steak House Fettuccine, so delicious, great flavor. My husband had the ribs,..."
Denise Dobrowolski
"This is a must go if you are anywhere near the Sandusky area. Every piece of food here is amazing. The wings are some of the best I've had, the pizza..."
Gentik Solm
"Love it there. Been a few times. Bread sticks are amazing. Portions are generous. Staff courteous and helpful. Keep up the great..."
Chris Streidl
"Love the Setting Frank Sinatra the food the staff we came to great wolf lodge for weekend this place is awesome true Italian joint..."
Marin C
Chet & Matt's Pizza
91/100 (984 ratings)
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Late Night
Chicken Alfredo
Chicken Wings
Mac and cheese
"When traveling we like to try local places and we found Chet & Matt's with awesome reviews on Tripadvisor so thoight we would try it. It was awesome!..."
Sarah Schuette Miller
"I have a rule of thumb every time I go eat out of town try to find the place where the locals do. Prices, food and service are great. Didn't get the..."
Jim Fogel
"I ate at Chet and Matt's almost two months ago on my Senior Trip from Swan Valley in Michigan, and just had a 12 inch pizza which I split with my..."
Joe Grzesiak
"I've considered myself a pizza connoisseur for the past 40 years or so. I found Chet & Matt's very good. Crispy crust, great selection on the buffet..."
Walt Sanders
"Great Pizza! My daughter and I split a BBQ Chicken pizza and the Mac and Cheese pizza. YUM! Great combo (better if it was on the same pizza hint..."
Michelle Reising Plumb
"If you’re ever in Sandusky, I highly recommend this place. Great food and..."
Christin Gilliland-Kilkenny
"Thank you to Chet and Matt's pizza for figuring out a way to accommodate our large group of 38 with only 4 days notice during their busy season. Our..."
Jenny Moran Punter
"10 minute wait on a Friday night, our server was enthusiastic, and attentive, and the food was goooood. Price was perfect for a family of four and..."
Tiffany Mitchell Waltos
Cameo Pizza
90/100 (1134 ratings)
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
"Cameo Pizza has been a staple in our family for over 50 years. The food is always fresh and delicious. I remember going there as a kid and while..."
Steve Pitzer
"Let me start by saying this, I'm from Pennsylvania. Most pizza there is generic and predictable. Going north into New York, pizza gets a lot better...."
Adam Stickler
"Excellent place to watch game great pizza, good local people and the owners are top notch! Highly recommend this place..."
Brian L. VanVlerah
"Love Cameo pizza! Lifetime resident. I've had pizza in many cities and other countries, and I'm spoiled because of Cameo pizza....double mushroom is..."
Kathy Erney
"Oh my god, this pizza is fantastic. No better way to end a long day at cedar point. Absolutely delicious! Hats off to..."
Matthew Mergo
"One of our hometown favorites. We’ve tried pizzas everywhere, including Chicago, but none compare to Cameo pizzas. Currently, the vegetarian pizza..."
Lezlie Whaley
"We are from Atlanta, Georgia. Great food, wonderful staff!! We absolutely loved it!! Thank..."
Moni Nalls
"Cameo's white pizza is amazing! Our waitress Demi was an absolute sweetie!! Great service and delicious..."
Sarah Tony Klickner
"We checked out the new upstairs for the first time. Beautiful! And the Tv's by the tables were perfect for my kids, I would love to check it out to..."
Kelli 'Luce' Collins
"Amazing wings and pizza. The quality is outstanding. Next time I'm in town I definitely will come back. Did I mention how golden crisp the wings are?..."
Angelica Vensor
"Excellent pizza, quick delivery! Couldn’t have asked for a better..."
Joey Lenig
"Miss Paulie but the best pizza in the area!!!! Sandusky,by Kalahari & Huron also..."
Willard Shupe
"I really love me some Cameo's. Born and raised in Sandusky, every Friday evening when dad got home he would take us all to Cameos for dinner. The..."
Cheri Walton Hahn
"The original! I know the family branched off with chet n matts, but their pizza is not good. Grew up here, so ive been to both places. Cameo is way..."
Dianne Trout
"I grew up in Sandusky and I now am in Cleveland. Whenever we can we go home and have cameo pizza. It’s the best pizza ever. Our waitress, Hannah,..."
Angie Bruene
"Not just good food but great customer service. Highly..."
Dave Burling
"Obviously the most amazing pizza around Our servers was awesome. I have never gotten a beer this quickly anywhere else!!!! And he was by himself..."
Christine DeSalle
"Love Cameo Pizza. Friendly staff. Awesome food. Great..."
Andy Ouriel
"I love coming home and taking my kids who are not from Sandusky to the Cameo. They love it as much as I do. We come every time we're in town. Keep..."
Bret Schee
"Great food and service. The upper level is great and easily..."
Gail Reeder
"Terrific pizza and cheese bread. Service was great also. We go whenever we are in the..."
Pat Lindner
"My family and I came from Indianapolis, Indiana to visit Cedar Point where my son proposed to his girlfriend on the beach (she said yes) and then..."
Lorrie Shepperd
"The best pizza I have ever ate! Nice atmosphere and..."
Robert Long
"Loved hanging with The Hibbard clan, great time great..."
Tracy Adcock
"Great food. Grew up eating there every Friday night. Still great..."
Craig Fish
"Absolutely amazing pizza!!! We both loved it. Great atmosphere even on a Sunday..."
Christine White
"Great Pizza and cold beer. Chef Salad is..."
Adam Etherton
"We chose this pizza spot based on other's reviews and we LOVED it!! The atmosphere is cute and the food was delicious. We had the meat lovers pizza..."
Kaitlynn M
"It was not as good as we remembered. Usually when we go to Put In Bay it is a requirement that we make a golf kart pit stop at the Cameo there... and..."
Robb Loyd
"Me and my family ordered it while at great wolf lodge in Sandusky. They were timely and friendly over the phone. My favorite was the cheese bread. ..."
marlene moore
"Simply the best! The pizza is amazing! The service is great! They make you feel at..."
Matt Maschari
"Great pizza, great drinks, & a historic and wonderful atmosphere make this place a must..."
Robert Burch
"It was the best pizza ever. Service was great. I will go here the next time I am in..."
Linda Smith
Mona Pizza Gourmet
90/100 (270 ratings)
"By far the best pizza in Sandusky! This is my absolute favorite place to get pizza. The customer service is excellent and they never..."
Dani Jones
"Awesome pizza...try the Tuscan! This is the best pizza Sandusky has to offer if you like good..."
Alice Fanning
"Best Pizza place in town!!!! Gryo's and Soup are always on..."
Valerie Nicole
"Always love their pizza. Only place in Sandusky to get by the slice. Nothing beats..."
Brandon Bowe
"Best sub in Ohio the best service and the price too good Best place to go have some good food and great..."
Denis O. Frankart
"A real pepperoni pizza has to be done with care, excellent products and a lot of technique, here besides all have an excellent service, this pizzeria..."
Leonardo Teixeira
"Amazing pizza. Stopped in for a slice and a Pepsi. Very similar to NY style. Very..."
Bob Cooper
"The pizza is great and Bill, the owner, is a heck of a nice guy! I eat there every time I'm in Sandusky. Do yourself a favor and getcha..."
Sergio Jardon
"Mona's is the best pizza in town; with a great & cute little shop to go along with it. It's like a refreshing taste of home ! Mhmmm Good..."
Ashley Lawrence
"Visiting from the Greater Cincinnati area, excellent..."
Scott Rains
"Best pizza, subs, soups and gyros in town not to mention great customer..."
Shea Michelle
"Awesome Pizza. You got to try some of their gourmet specialty pizza. I know it doesn't sound good but try the chilli dog pie it is wonderful. Wish..."
ray weithman
"Great slices for a even better price!..."
Stephen Love
"Pizza was very good! And I work in a pizza place so I'm..."
Shannon Howard
"Was downtown for a State Theater event and wanted to try somewhere I've never tried, local and close to the theater. Wasn't disappointed. Don't..."
Fred Coffey
"Absolutely amazing small town pizza shop! If you ever get the chance to try out their BBQ pulled pork pizza with cheddar cheese stuffed crust I would..."
Ole Mann Logan
"Crab Rangoon stuffed crust pizza is delicious!! Garlic butter crust was crispy and absolutely stuffed with crab Rangoon. Highly recommend!! The owner..."
Bree Hamilton
"Delicious pizza & subs. The bread was so soft and flaky. Plus excellent service when dine in. Highly likely to..."
Shamario Jenkins
Sortino's Little Italy Ristorante
88/100 (1351 ratings)
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Late Night
"It’s a must stop for me every time I’m in Sandusky. The veal parm is top notch, salad is crisp & staff makes you feel like..."
Dave Umina
"We go back every year when we visit Cedar point. Best Italian restaurant we’ve ever been to. You have to have the mozzarella cheese balls! And my..."
Tom Allen
"Visited Sortino's on Wed 8/1. On vacation with my wife(Ginny Delfino Lamneck), my Son and my two Grandchildren. What a Great place! We were treated..."
Robert A. Lamneck
"Sortino’s is always the perfect place for a celebration! We had a wonderful time honoring my parents’ 49th anniversary (who drove an hour just so..."
Tara Henzler Toft
"It was an awesome time with friends and the food was delicious.. the portions are plenty.. I think we all had leftovers... Everyone had something..."
Anna Fontana-Smith
"This is one of the best authentic Italian restaurants in Ohio! Fantastic flavor and the portions are gigantic. The staff and owner are make you feel..."
Mitch Miller
"Awesome ambiance , food is great. I had the lobster ravioli it was awesome.. The owners are so nice to..."
Kevin Smith
"Dear lord was this place delicious! Started with the bread and dipping oil, then a marvelous Caesar Salad and then what ended up being a three meal..."
Nikki Weborg Weidner
"Best Italian food ever!!! We love going here to eat every time we are in Sandusky!!! Also the best atmosphere in a restaurant they treat you like..."
Scott Rady
"Visiting cedar point and was recommended to eat here, so glad we did food was amazing and service as well. Large portions could not..."
Robert McGillen
"Great food, great atmosphere, great people that make you feel at home. Hands down the best Italian food west of Cle. The Veal Parmesan is amazing &..."
David Umina
"Highly recommend!!! Here for cedar point and decided to give it a try. Their customer service is amazing. They treat you like family. The owner..."
Emily Quin
"*****EXCELLENT ***** Atmosphere, food, and the staff were AMAZING! We went shortly after they opened, so there was no wait. Needed take home..."
Joy White
"Great food, down to earth servers, casual atmosphere. I would eat here every week if I lived..."
Karen Kratochvil Veselsky
"Perfect place for a rehearsal dinner. Excellent food. Excellent service. Amazing time. I would give it a 100 star review if I..."
Grace Ruiz
"This place is fabulous! I was very comfortable with their service, and how they are handling precautions for Covid. The food is amazing! We had to..."
Amy Gassel
"Fun decorations and atmosphere, superb service, great food. Gluten free pasta available. Our server, Hannah, put together cheeses and peppers..."
Andrew Kalemkarian
"Excellent food. Nice atmosphere. Friendly staff. The owner stopped at my table to say hi. Great..."
Tim Ali
"Wow first experience at Sortino Italian and the food was AMAZING!! It was very authentic Italian food, the flavors of the sauces(I tried 4 of them,..."
Monica Scott
"Absolutely fantastic food and a great atmosphere ! The fettuccine alfredo with shrimp is the absolute best I have ever had. I will miss the old..."
lori kruse
"As always fantastic. Good service and great food. Sorry that it is moving to..."
william herb