Review Pizza Brothers - Sandusky

We did dine in since the place we wanted to go was very full (Saturday night rush). I'm sure they don't do much dine in, but the pizza was great! Good price and tasty. We had pepperoni and the boom boom shrimp.

This is second time we have ordered from here and it did not disappoint. We got 3 different folodovers for a family dinner and they were a huge success. The best part is their service.... our dinner was a suprise birthday dinner for my husband. The driver showed up at my house before our guest, I felt so bad but he responded to my text and agree to leave it on the porch for me. He also left his bag to keep the pizza warm.... way above and beyond. We will definitely order from there again and recommend to all.

Possibly understaffed... pizza's were accumulating on top of each other as no one to receive them out of the oven. The pizza sauce tastes more like a bland spaghetti sauce, pizza looks gorgeous, very cheesy and dough is perfect consistency, but overall very bland and tasteless. We're out of towners who passed through and wanted to eat local, and the staff seemed to know all who came in by name. We paid for & placed our order online with toppings on both of our pizzas, but somehow that translated to just 2 plain cheese pizzas on their tickets. I don't fault the business for that, just sharing our experience. I have 2 stars because while we're unlikely to return, they seem to be a local fave.

I used to love this place but it has changed. Ordered the BLT fold over and the deluxe. I asked for extra sauce on the deluxe but I could barely taste the pizza sauce on either pizza. The fold over had mostly huge chunks of bacon and very little lettuce and tomato. The menu description said “crispy” bacon. Bottom line the toppings of meat on both pizzas were over done and very little veggie to to compliment. Cheese amount was also minimal. Very disappointing. Customer next to me ordered two cheese pizzas. I think he’s got the idea for this place.

Ordered here for delivery was told they’ll get to me when they get to me told them I’ll just pick it up. When I arrived got my order left a 10.00 tip got home all my food was NOT there called the business, and they were rude and nonchalant come get it or get a credit. Rude and the food was half cooked .. Wouldn’t recommend, rude customer service and cold and half cooked food

DELICIOUS!! Staff was so nice. Pizza was amazing and I would absolutely die for their Boom Boom Shrimp. Will be going back again soon!

I Ordered food literally 2 hours ago and my food still isn't here its ridiculous I was told 45 minutes to an hour ... not 1 hour to 2....

Taco turnovers - amazing. I just wish the sauce was more consistent. Everytime I order it tastes different… the most recent tasting strongly of alcohol or straight acid or something - inedible. Ruins the meal not having edible taco sauce with it IMO. Ordered more frequently last year and never had this issue.