Reviews Cutillo's

5
Johnny Witchella
+5
Not overly fancy, but not a dive either. Had multiple mixed drinks, they were always well mixed being not too strong or too light. Food is descent, pasta, burgers, and chicken are great, but the cuts of meat for steak I've gotten haven't been the best. Never had bad service while there, the staff is very professional and on point.
5
Jody Beck
+5
Nice quiet place to have a romantic dinner on a Sunday evening. Our server, Eric W. did a great job. All of our food was delicious - cedar plank salmon, Delmonico steak, garden salad, roasted red potatoes, asparagus, rolls, and creme brulee. No wonder the parking lot is always full. Can't wait to come back and have a casual dinner in the bar and again in the summer to enjoy the view of the creek.
5
Maria T Henriksen
+5
My husband and I went to lunch after church at Cutillo's. Their menu specializes in small plates, larger than an appetizer, smaller than an entrée. My husband ordered the Au Poivre. I ordered the Seafood Pasta dish. We both really enjoyed our meals. We each ordered the triple chocolate cake. That too was devoured. The server, Sky, was attentive, sweet, and accommodating. Management came over to our table a couple times to see how our meals were as well as to greet us. We're definitely going back.
5
Kristen Currie
+5
We celebrated our wedding here on Saturday. The staff was excellent, so accommodating from the moment we started planning until the end of the wedding night, Including the owner Mary who went above and beyond. The set up was beautiful, they did everything I had asked for and on top of everything the food was absolutely phenomenal
5
Jane Evans
+5
My daughter's wedding reception was here... The food was great 👍. Good drinks, and staff very easy to work with
4
Shirley Pitcher
+4
We have gone to Cutillo's several times for our annual Christmas party ! Food is always delicious and the staff is exceptional ! Very friendly,accommodateing and joins in the fun !
4
Carmen M
+4
Loved my dinner but I would have rather not sat with a big plant in my face though very pretty its was too much to have to keep bending my head to have a conversation... the waitress Rena? [Not sure of spelling] was very friendly and thoughtful but they ran out of almost everything we ordered had to keep reordering. Nice place and beautiful plants..good food though the fettuccine was thick and undercooked..
5
Amanda M Thomas
+5
Kayci (manager) and Jessica (banquet server) and there was also, a young gentleman server that did a great job for my moms party. Very friendly, attentive and flexible. The food was delicious and I normally am not a fan of cake but the cake they made was amazing! I would highly recommend this establishment. I have been here several times for Easter as well, and it's a great spot for holiday lunches.
5
Toni Dougherty
+5
We had a nice time and our server Sarah was really personable and such a delight. She even mentioned it was her first night serving. She was very good, attentive and knew exactly when we needed something.
5
Elaine D
+5
We had our son's rehearsal dinner at Cutillo. Everything was perfect! We made the arrangements with Mary, who was very friendly, accommodating, and professional. We had the Italian buffet which also included appetizers, ice tea, and dessert...The food was delicious! We also had a wine and beer table where our guest can help themselves and we only had to pay for whatever they drank. The girls serving us were very nice. They even played a collection of love songs that we had selected for back ground music. Such a beautiful place! Sounds like Cutillo's had a difficult time during the COVID restriction, but they are hoping to make a big come back.
4
William Ash
+4
Had a wonderful Prime rib cooked exactly as I ordered it and finished it off with a delicious slice of peanut butter pie. Atmosphere was great, server was excellent! My only complaint is that the tables outside didn’t seem to have been wiped down recently.
5
Marney Stauffer
+5
Food was excellent. My daughter ate more food then she ever has. Our waitress was one of the best we have had in a very long time. Just a great place to go and it was our first time. We will return many more times.
5
James Kieser
+5
My family has enjoyed Cutillos for years. The food is always fantastic. We moved. We are not as close as we were. We don't mind driving 40 minutes to get there. It's a really great place for family gatherings. Also, check out the stream running next to restaurant.
4
Nicole “Smallz” Laws
+4
Stopped here for lunch with a co-worker. First time visit for me. Really beautifully done inside and the restaurant sits along a creek providing pretty views. I had the pleasure of sitting near the windows that looked down on the creek. Nice menu, the food was decent, the service was good until we went to leave. It took a really long time to get our check, we had to hunt down our server to pay. The place was quiet and fairly empty at lunch time during the week.