Alba A
Stopped here by chance because it came up on my google maps recommendations for lunch in the area. Saw the pictures of the pizza and stopped in immediately. The location was quaint and quiet. We ordered Caesar salads and a medium pizza, half cheese half pepperoni and mushroom. It was the perfect amount of food for 2. You have to try it for yourself, it is absolutely delicious. The price was also very reasonable for the amount of food we ordered. The water had a funny taste to it has to be my only complaint. I will definitely be back for more pizza and to try more menu items.
el mago
The salad was okay, but my girlfriend thought the wings were phenomenal and I LOVED the pizza! It was perfectly crispy and the fresh basil tasted great (I had the medium sized margherita pie). I'll absolutely come back and I definitely recommend this place!
Michael “Mike the IT Guy” Johnstone
Wife and I ordered a carryout and tried a Ham Calzone and small size pizzas of Meat Lovers and the 49th Street Special. We also had the bread. Very easy and the marina sauce was excellent! I highly recommend them and it was worth the money. We had left overs for 3 days. Very filling. Can't comment on the "NY Style" as I have never been there. Thanks for reading.
Sam R
My new favorite pizza spot! The pizza is delicious, always hot when I get home after picking it up. The prices are reasonable too. You don't find many pizza places like this in town. Definitely worth trying if you're looking for a new pizza place to try. Still need to try the rest of the menu items out. The service given is always great too!
Katy Schultz
Stopped in with my daughter and her friends to celebrate her birthday. Clean facilities, pizza was delicious (great crispy crust) and wonderful staff! They brought my daughter cake and sang Happy birthday without me even having to ask. Very pleased with my experience- I can hardly wait to eat the leftovers 😊
Chao Chang
Love their pizza and alfredo fettuccine! Cake was also good.
Parambir Singh
I am originally from New Jersey and two things I missed when I came down here was good NY Pizza and NY Bagels. As for Pizza, this is quite possibly the BEST NYC style Pizza place in San Antonio. These guys make a serious New York Style thin crust pizza. When I get a classic large Cheese or Pepperoni Pizza, I am transported back to my favorite Pizza place in Queens. Pure nostalgia!
There are other places in town now that make a pretty good NY pizza, but this place is by far the most consistent. Excellent Pizza. I don't have much to say about other things on their menu as I haven't really deviated from the Pizza, as its the reason I keep coming back to this place!
KaityGirl Smith
Just relocated from NY so I had to check this place out. Met the owner and told him if this is not like NY, I'm going to let everyone know he's a fraud. Well been going there at least once a week. 46th St. Pizza is legit. The service is good and people are very nice. If I could, I'd give them 1/2 of another star. Can't give them 5 because they still don't top my favorite back home but they are definitely good. They have a great 2 slice and a drink lunch special.
dora carreon (dbrii)
Love this place especially when SAM makes the pizza. Perfect crust to topping ratio. There sauce is perfectly seasoned. The atmosphere is great and the place is always very clean. Very welcoming. The pricw is right for the quality of the food. You will not be disappointed!
dmarie
They’re so generous! And their pizza is amazing. Me and my boyfriend went in to order a pizza and we accidentally got splashed JUST A LITTLE with water (the guy in the back was fixing the soda machine I’m guessing). It literally wasn’t a lot of water, just a drop or two, and they gave us our meal on the house. They didn’t have to do that but they did it anyways. I recommend this place to anyone. The quality is great and the prices are so convenient (especially for those college students like me and my boyfriend). And plus, the employees are just overall amazing and sweet people. Thank you so much for your kindness.
Zapps Acct
As with most places not very consistent however when you get the right guy at the right time
You can pick up some outstanding thin and crispy pie here well cooked to Golden Brown perfection.
Yeah they know how to develop some flavor here.
However if you get the new guy or the other guy that's just in a hurry and pulls the pie out too soon you just end up with some mediocre soggy Pizza. As seen in those two pictures both are Greek pie one was left in and developed some gorgeous color and flavor the other one was removed prematurely and was just flat and Soggy.
Well they do have some really nice toppings.
I'll give them V stars when they make their own homemade beef bacon and kosher beef sausage. And get more consistent with their cooking time there should be no pie before its time...
Km Br
I have been here plenty of times being that my job is close by, the spaghetti is great but the pizza tastes like Little Caesar's pizza to me( jusy my opinion - I expected a more New York feel/taste). The service is great. Their lunch specials are the best. - the chicken Parmigiana is a win !!
Mianie Dean
Just tried for the first time and wow. Food took a bit of time to make but tastes amazing and the portion is huge! I’m pregnant so i am always “starving” lol and didn’t even finish it all. Will definitely be coming back. I ordered the Alfredo btw.
Kat
"Amazing Real New York Pizza"
This is the closest thing to all the pizza spots here in San Antonio claiming to be "NY Style" My Fiance & I moved here from New York about 8 months ago, he was born and raised in the Bronx, NY & this is the only Pizza place he will go to. You can tell cheese is fresh, toppings fresh and anytime I order a pasta dish its delicious and has that Italian authentic twist to it. Cheese bread is fantastic with marinara sauce that they serve and comes out piping hot!
Another Pro would be its actually set up like the pizza shops they have in NY but a little fancier. You can order by the slice instead of ordering a whole pizza like all the other "wannabe NY pizza places"
The crust could be a little more thin and have a little more cheese on top and it would directly hit the spot!
Thanks 46th Street Pizza for giving us a taste of home!
Savannah Miller
The pizza was AMAZING! It truly lived up to the pizza in New York. The baker looked like a real proffessional and could make a pizza in less than 5 minutes. Overall very impressed with the food here.
Laura Tomerlin
was running late to pick up my to-go order. they kept it super hot for me, and my greek salad cold! I had never been here before, and tried the eggplant parmigiana sandwich and the greek salad with the greek dressing. It's amazing, and the staff were super kind and friendly! I can't wait to try their pizza!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes