The cheese bread is amazing. Except, using the Slice app you have to choose between ranch and marinara. Then when it arrives...there are TWO marinara. Damn, we need the option to have one of each.
This extra unwanted marinara that could have been a ranch, distracts me from all other topics tonight. ;)
The small Combo pizza I also ordered is ok, But it could have been baked like the AMAZING CHEESE BREAD and the awesome looking crusts in the pictures that had me choosing this place. That would've been something special.
Delivery from the Slice app was an hour ahead of estimated time!!! Awesome! Set my expectations low and then astound me.
Bring me a ranch so I can care about my thin crust Combo pizza. JK
Lovely place within a nice vibe and delicious pizza. A true five star.
Owned by a transplant from NYC, this restaurant feels like its belongs somewhere else, but fits perfectly. Nice ambiance but with some flair.
We shared a 16" pie with our topping choices and a side of pesto. Delicious. Delightful cheesecake also, and the availability of drinks was a nice plus.
Can be hard to find parking, but only on the weekends. It's a block from TRAX, so park elsewhere.
We absolutely loved this place, the white sauce on the pizzas, and in the pasta was amazing. Probrally the best white sauce pizza I have ever had. The lady who seemed to be running the place was extremly sweet. Seems like a family owned restaurant right in downtown. Also highly recommend the deserts
Amazing food! Very friendly and accommodating. We enjoyed 2 different kinds of pizza, 2 different types of pasta & several desserts and all of it was great. And the staff was so friendly!
Very friendly and family atmosphere. The owners were nice and helped out a lot with my food choices. They have absolutely amazing cannolis ! You have to get one, even more important than the pizza.
I come here as it's a comfort place. One night while going about my shenanigans, I stopped in and got myself a slice of pizza that was wonderful. Recently I was feeling a bit under the weather, and didn't want to search far and wide for a good piece. So I came in and got myself a Chicken Parmesan slice, immediately I felt warm as each flavor melted together to great some a homey familiar sensation. My night was exceedingly better after that. I love the atmosphere and will definitely keep coming back. 😁
The crust was great, which is the most important thing for me. The meat, cheese, and sauce was all pretty good as well. The garlic bread was good as well.
The soda fountain was out of carbonation and despite "fixing it", it still didn't work. I had to pay for a glass bottle of Coke instead ($5.69ish), despite the fountain not working.
They were also very accommodating of our group of 13 and both ladies taking orders and running food were fantastic.
I would definitely come back.
It’s good. Way better than average. The slices I got on a Saturday afternoon may have been sitting around for a while.
SLC’s pizza scene is weak, so don’t get me wrong—Sicilia is a massive upgrade over virtually anywhere else. If you want the best NY style pizza in town, try Villagio.
The staff were super friendly and comfortable. The crust is thinner but not crunchy - perfect! No line when we got here a little after 1pm on a Tuesday but then people came in for slices. Staff cleaned stables and brought out parm and red pepper flakes with silverware and napkins when our food was ready. Quick, delicious and they have pink (white and red) sauce on pizzas if you want!
Hands down the best place for a mouthwatering slice of pizza, offering an unforgettable blend of flavors and friendly service that keeps me coming back for more!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Salt Lake City
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes