Denise Stark
We visited for a family dinner with 9 adults. They were very accommodating. We ordered multiple dishes and had them served family style. They split and plated all our dishes table side for us. This required help from most of the staff. The service was amazing.
The food was top notch and the best Italian I have had. All pasta is made in house and amazing. Best gnocchi I’ve ever had. My favorite was the signature carbonara. It was rich and flavorful. Prices are high but worth the quality and flavor. Great spot for a special occasion.
Tony Pizza
Had Patrick as our server. It was a romantic, authentic experience. Food was divine.
Some might get frustrated at the wait, even with a reservation, but it’s a dining experience and the idea is that nobody is rushed. It invites conversation around food and is more charming for it.
The food is authentic and so flavorful and thoughtfully created. Huge wine selection. 100 percent recommend.
Dallin Gleed
Our food was amazing! The cheese, the pasta, the steak!! 🥩 We came for my wife’s birthday and Patrick our waiter was nothing short of hospitable and made us feel so special! This restaurant’s food and experience is nothing less of exquisite! 200/10 will come again and recommend it to everyone!
Christy L
Sicilia Mia was a refreshing and delicious dining experience! The restaurant was cozy and nicely styled. The service was excellent! Stein, our server was attentive and guided us to the best menu options. The food tasted incredible! We started off with a charcuterie board. The meats and cheeses were fantastic. We ordered the Bistecca Alla Toscana, which was out of this world! With our first bite, we both said “Wow!” The Carbonara was finished to perfection inside a wheel of aged Parmigiano-Reggiano. The steak and pasta were a perfect pairing. For dessert, we enjoyed the chocolate covered cream puffs.
This meal was such a lovely experience! We cannot wait to return again to Sicilia Mia!
Sachiyth A
Hint of Italy in Utah
Sicilia Mia Italian restaurant exceeded all my expectations! From the moment we walked in, we were was greeted with a friendly smile and a warm atmosphere. The menu offered a wide variety of authentic Italian dishes, and the flavors were simply divine. Each course was a culinary masterpiece, and the presentation was impeccable.
A special thank you to Karen, our server, for making the evening even more enjoyable with excellent service. And also taking our pictures 📸. Make sure to ask for her on your next visit. 🤩
Karem was knowledgeable, making helpful recommendations that suited our preferences perfectly. I also appreciated the attention to detail in the decor, which added to the overall charm of the place.
Whether you're a fan of classic pasta dishes or seeking more adventurous options, Sicilia Mia has something to satisfy every palate. I can't wait to return and try more of their delectable offerings. If you're in the mood for an exceptional Italian dining experience, look no further than Sicilia Mia. Highly recommended! 🍝🍷👌
Victoria Ieradi
A wonderful Italian restaurant! Our server took time to recommend a few wines that would pair well with my meal and based on my taste preferences. The food was fantastic, full of flavor and effort. The atmosphere was nice too with great decor, music, and staff. I've had amazing Italian food on the east coast in New York and New Jersey, and this is up to par for my standards of a good Italian restaurant.
I would recommend this place for any occasion.
Kaleb Hansen
Amazing food! Love this place! Authentic and delicious Italian food. One of our all-time favorites! ♥️
Mary Brown
This is the best Italian food I have ever had. Some of our good friends took us to Sicilia Mia a few months ago, and I can't get it out of my head. Service was impeccable. The portions were smaller, but the food was phenomenal. Each person at our table got an Italian soda and were not disappointed. My husband and I split a panna cotta (also fantastic). I am sad we moved out of state and away from this place. Definitely on the top of my list of where to eat if we are ever back in Utah.
Cheyenne Bigler
We loved Sicilia Mia!! We started with the arancinette which tasted just like the ones I had in Italy a month ago! The carbonara was so yummy and great presentation in the cheese wheel. My only thing is it could have had a little less bacon but still great. We were so shocked how much we loved the lasagna too. It was so rich and creamy and had perfect ratios. Service was great and we were constantly checked on. Will definitely return!
Roger Johnson
Delicious authentic Italian food with a welcoming atmosphere. The service was responsive and never made us feel rushed. Great for a romantic dinner or a fancy family night out.
sione tenifa
5 star all around food was amazing. Super fresh and authentic. Service was top notch. And the atmosphere was perfect for my wife’s birthday.
Kirsten Abbott
We had an incredible time and were so impressed with everything. Our waiter, Stein, was fantastic, welcoming, funny, and helpful! we had a member of our party with a tree nut allergy and he ensured everything was tree nut free for us. We were well taken care of!
The food was outstanding, we loved everything we tried. The signature carbonara was rich and creamy, the caesar salad was really good, the Italian board gave a great taste of their in house cold cuts, the cream puffs were so good and definitely great for sharing.
Will definitely be coming back!
Keith Christiansen
My wife and I went her for a date night and absolutely loved it! The bruschetta was the best I have ever had! The customer service and interactions with the waiter was top notch! We loved the food and the atmosphere, I can’t wait to come back!
J D
I was a little nervous with it being in a strip mall. As soon as we walked in, all that changed. The atmosphere was great. I do not think it gets any more authentic than this. The prices are a little high. The food is fresh and made to order as the wait was a bit, but definitely worth it. Our waiter made it a great experience and was very friendly. The family wants to go back. Definitely one of the top Italian places we have ever been to.
Miguel Sanchez
If you are looking for a romantic night highly recommend this place. The service is really good and they bring the food on time.
Brabby Utah
I've heard a lot of good things about Sicilia Mia but it's always been tough to get in without a reservation days in advance, so we'd never been. We went later in the evening on Saturday (8:45) so we were able to get in without a reservation.
The food was authentic Italian food. We had the prosciutto and melon appetizer along with a caprese salad to start. They were both good but I've had better caprese.
For entrees, my wife ordered the ragu and I had their famous carbonara. We both liked our dishes. The carbonara is finished in the cheese wheel right at your table, which makes it fun. Truthfully, it wasn't my favorite carbonara but it was good and the experience made it enjoyable.
My wife says it's her favorite Italian in Utah. It is definitely in my top 3 for Italian in Utah.
Juventa Vezzani
Really expensive restaurant but the food is “oh my” yummy. The Parmesan signature pasta dish was amazing!! I’ll be dreaming about that creamy melted Parmesan for some time now. SO much fun for an anniversary celebration.
Juan Magana
We love coming back to Sicilia Mia. This one of our regular places. It never disappoints. The service is great, food is delicious and fresh, drinks are always well done and their wine selection is good. Not the fanciest venue, however, great quality and delicious food!!! A local gem!
Candace Miyake
This place is the best! Loved the pizza and the carbonara dish we ordered. Our waiter, Eduardo, was top notch! This restaurant is now one of my favorites! The entire staff was friendly. I called for reservations. That's a must for this restaurant as they are very busy. This place is well worth the time and effort to place a reservation. EXCELLENT! 5 stars from me!
Mario Garcia
Absolutely delicious, food was great, customer service awesome!!! I definitely recommend this place best authentic Italian food.
Shawn Peterson
This place is AMAZING!!! The best most authentic Italian food I've ever had. Reasonable prices and a great staff, I would highly recommend to anyone.
Scott Bennett
just now
Pricing is a bit on the higher end, but the food is excellent and service is exceptional. Someone in your group should get the Carbonara for the tableside presentation and fantastic flavor, but be warned - I doubt they will share. Note: some of the best restaurants in New York City, Europe, and Italy especially - wonderful small family owned restaurants found on side streets in small facilities. The Highland Drive Sicilia Mia is in a strip mall - and it's easy to imagine your in Italy at a friendly small family restaurant - just enjoy the feeling while your here. Also, call ahead and make reservations instead of just showing up. Being a wonderful restaurant makes them popular, busy and definitely crowded at peak dinner time.
Sarah Benson-brown
Best Italian I've had in years and the servers and atmosphere we're so great out server went beyond found my new favorite place
Claudia E Gomez
We went for my birthday. It was amazing, i ordered the Cabonara, my daughter had the ravioli with mushrooms. Two different white wines. The server alejandro was great, he recommended the meal options for us. I look forward to visiting again soon. Thank you.
Kayte Dendy Glennon
Great food. Service was a bit lacking and the prices were high being that it’s ala carte. The signature Cabonara dish that was to be served “table side” was prepared several feet away and carried over. Not what we expected, but still tasty.
Krista Miller Loertscher
The best Italian I’ve had in Utah. Everything was rich and flavorful. The staff was amazing. They went overboard for us, and did a special presentation for me when they discovered it was my birthday. Amazing experience- we will be back!
Sally Hilty Bernard
This is a must visit if you are in Salt Lake Utah the food was over the top and so was the service. Thank you Vinnie for treating us like family!
Andreas Haase
Best pizza this side of the Mississippi! Would highly recommend if you know your pizza!
Liliana M Davies
Excellent food excellent service. The best place to have dinner with friends
Heidi Kunzler Greene
We made reservations. The staff was friendly and the service was excellent. The food was as tasty was being in Italy. The carbonara is a must! Very enjoyable experience. We will be back regularly!
Terry Ann Olsen
We had a great first experience at Sicilia Mia for my birthday. I had an entre I had never heard of.. can't remember the name, but it had the squid ink sauce. It looked a little unusual, but was really good. Our server was very helpful in describing the menu items and helping us make a choice. We saw several people who had the Carbarnara prepared at their table and that was so fun to watch! I'll have to come back to try it.
Not your average "American" Italian restaurant.
Sally Steed
Great food, loved the atmosphere and the service was so friendly and top notch. I would absolutely recommend this restaurant - I loved it.
Eduardo Santiago
Amazing food as always! I am always happy to come back to Sicilia Mia for its great food and great experience every time!
Ramona Sulaitis Noble
Fantastico!!! Service, food, hospitality, I can go on. You must try, but I recommend reservations!!!!
Kortni Litster
What can I say about Sicilia Mia?! It is hands down my favorite restaurant in Utah. The food is so authentically Sicilian... it reminds me of my grandma's cooking� The service is beyond compare! Austin, Eduardo, Margherite, Kat, Stein, Giuseppe, Francesco, Vincenzo (before he moved over to Antica!)... everyone makes you feel like you're a VIP.
Kelly Johnson
Amazing! Had the arancinette, the Bresaola salad and the carbonara. Everything was perfect and beautiful. Service was attentive and informative. We will be back!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes