Review Sugarfire Pie - Saint Louis

Melinda Campbell

This was our first visit to Sugarfire Pie and it will not be our last!!! The atmosphere is unique and inviting. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable. I walked in expecting to spend $20 on 2-3 items, but walked out away spending $20 on 5 items. Our experience from start to finish exceed my expectations!

D Adams

The BEST Pecan Pie ever - my son and I agree. This is NOT typical store bought or a bunch of Karo syrup and pecans. The crust, the filling, and pecans are fire! Not sticky or overly sweet. It was so worth it. We won't be able to eat other pecan pie. Sugarfire Pecan Pie has ruined us for any other. The absolute best!!!

Jennifer Nolen

I expected there to be more pie choices than the there were - no cream pies were available at all. But everything we had was excellent. Cherry pie, whoopie pie, key lime pie shake, and cobbler with ice cream = yum! Limited seating and the parking was a bit tight, but I'm glad we dropped in. Servings we're generous without being ridiculous.

Danny Wight

Nice stop after eating at Sugarfire Smoke House. Located a few steps away from the awesome BBQ joint....don't forget to stop in here too.... A variety of pies, cookies, and icecreams. We tried a few of the pies that were recommended to us....Each of them had their own unique flavor. The settings is from the late 50's which gives it a diner style experience. They serve coffee as well...

Chip Folendore

The bakery for Sugarfire Smokehouse. You can eat inside as well. Wonderful.

Jason Smith

Guess it was a sign 🤔 riding down olive heading home G7 started going CRAZY FROM SUGAR DROPPED FROM 100TO 60 in 15 minutes. COMPLEX IS PACKED WITH THINGS TO DO & EAT

Kareem Collins

The Pie is great and the staff is nice. They have cobbler, cookies, cakes and pies. They sell whole and parts, they take orders as well for parties too.

Tina Chaffee

Everything we have tried here has been delicious. The staff is friendly and professional, and the selection is interesting and diverse. The classic apple pie is my current favorite, but I am going tonight to pick up a pumpkin pie baked in a pumpkin cake. I am sure it will be amazing.

D Adams

The BEST Pecan Pie ever - my son and I agree. This is NOT typical store bought or a bunch of Karo syrup and pecans. The crust, the filling, and pecans are fire! Not sticky or overly sweet. It was so worth it. We won't be able to eat other pecan pie. Sugarfire Pecan Pie has ruined us for any other. The absolute best!!! Also, the Cherry pies are excellent!

Libby Slawson Tempel

I had the best slice of blueberry crumb pie I've ever had. It was juicy, thickened just enough to not be runny, but it wasn't goopy. The blueberries were tender and melty with no tough skins. The sweetness level was just right. And it didn't have any strong spices to distract from the beautiful berry flavor. The crumb topping and crust were tasty, too, but the filling was the star.

Gary Gay

Great pie

Claire Tessier

Cobbler was great!! It was a bit overpriced for what it was.

Katie Hallock

This place totally rocks!!! I don't even consider myself a big fan of pie, but when I read an article a couple months ago about Sugarfire's Stacked Pie's, I knew I had to check it out! Mostly because none of the pies in the stack involved fruit, because they're just not my thing. But this place has plenty of fruit pies if that's what you're looking for! The stacked pie they were serving the day I went was Crack Pie on top of Mississippi Mud Pie on top of Pecan Pie and between each was a layer of chocolate ganache! The pecan pie had the most amazing flakey crust!! The Mississippi Mud Pie was like a dense, under-baked dark chocolate brownie in a graham cracker crust. And the Crack Pie seemed like a cross between chess pie and gooey butter cake inside of a crumbly cookie crust. The Hello Dolly is pretty incredible, too! It's like a kitchen sink pie - it has everything! Oatmeal, a few different kinds of chips (white chocolate, dark chocolate, butterscotch), M&M's and more! It has a dry consistency, more like a cookie. It's very sweet and over the top in the best way!

Corey J

This place is just plain AWESOME! Shared a sampler platter and I'm stuffed, and the loaded cauliflower was delicious... I'll definitely be back for some of that FIRE BBQ!

E L

Ask for the key lime, it's in the fridge. Good coffee, fantastic house made pies, big pieces, great interior and atmosphere. Go before or after you hit the Sugarfire bbq place next door. Bring bigger pants! :)

Solodad

Best piece of apple pie I have had east of the rockies.

Eric Zumwalt

Absolutely delicious pie and ice cream! Their pecan pie is my favorite by far. The SugarFire pie is also super tasty.