Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
58/100
Data Completeness
67/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🌳
Outdoor seating
🚚
Delivery
🥡
Takeout
🍽️
Dine-in
🍺
Alcohol
🍷
Wine
📅
Reservations
♿
Wheelchair accessible
♿
Accessible restroom
😊
Casual
🛋️
Cozy
👥
Good for groups
📊 Popular Times
Not busy
Moderate
Very busy
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
475
Google reviews
The brick oven pizza is the best in the area by far. Dough is italian..they must have the ingredients to make it so authentic. They crank them out constantly so your pizza is always fresh and piping hot. I always order the meatballs appetizer and NY pepperoni pizza and they have a wonderful avocado salad that goes great with anything. They seem to have a special drink and last time it was an Apple Moscow Mule. Delicious! No reservations but they take your phone number and turn over is quick. Deserts are simple but effective! Good value for money for sure.
Read more
Google
I've never dined in but have always grabbed slices to go. The closest to a NY slice of pizza one can find in Sag Habor. Pizza always had a crispy crust. Pepperoni slices are the go to. Pepperoni cups have a great char to them.
Google
Sag Pizza was a great place! The only thing I would warn people about is that they are not known for their full-size pies as their main dishes are personal pizzas (12" diameter pies). Another critique is their high prices. However, that is to be expected at a high-end place like Sag Harbor. Out group had a great time! Waiters are very approachable! It looked like a nice bar with a lot of selections, although I didn't try anything.
Read more
Google
Best pizza spot in town - wood fire pizza that tastes great. Pretty busy during lunch but there us usually a couple of spot at the bar where you can enjoy your pizza with a local beer
Google
so i be slitherin my way down this road and this African American guy named Tyrone now says to me “broski come down here and I’ll give you some cream” so basically me and my boys slither in and we see this glorious crème whipped and placed on top of soft serve. 10/10 best cream of my life bro
but Tyrone was kinda wacky ngl and the pizzas were mad cheesy
Read more
Google
Easy place to eat especially with a large group. Food was good and prices reasonable.
Google
The new Sag Pizza is great. We had several pies that were quite good and the outdoor setting was very pleasant on a nice summer day. The pepperoni pie was our favorite, especially when paired with some of the crust dipping sauces.
Google
We ordered the #1 San Marzano, #2 Soppressata and #9 the Vongole. We all agreed that the Soppressata was the best. The Vongole would have been my favorite but I'd rather pay more for more than 5 clams and the sauce wasn't evenly distributed, so two slices were great, the rest was meh.
I ordered the cucumber cooler cocktail, it was AWESOME. Apparently, they can make it "hot" and I highly recommend it. You get the cool cucumber flavor first but then the heat sneaks up on you. It's not overwhelming at all, nicely well balanced!
Read more
Google
Okay okay...We've been a sleep on Sag Pizza and regret ever overlooking this gem.
Adorable inside and the outdoor seating area was lovely the night we came to our senses and visited.
Highlights were:
Summer Squash Pizza
The Farmers Pizza
We added a Ranch3 Crust Dipper and it was yummy.
Google
Came in on a late friday afternoon for a pie. Pretty tasty and only waited around 7 to 8 mins for the pie to arrive piping hot.
Google
Explore more in Sag Harbor
By specialty
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: