Bagel Buoy
3 Bay St - Sag Harbor
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2021
#18 of 36 restaurants in Sag Harbor
Updated on
€€
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
57/100
Data Completeness
61/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🥡
Takeout
📷 Photos (10)
+2
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 10
100%
Google Reviews
137
Google reviews
Good, inexpensive, loved my spinach everything bagel, but super crowded
Google
The omelet was great. Very busy place so you know it's good. I didn't have a bagel because I can't have wheat but they looked delicious. Only a few places to sit. It's mostly take out.
Google
A favorite in my family across generations! Amazing breakfast sandwiches (the bacon, egg, and cheese is my go-to) and bagels. The bread here just can't be beat.
Google
My favorite place to get a bagel! They also have great wraps and sandwiches if it's later in the day and you need lunch. There is very little seating inside, but if you walk across the street to Marine Park you can find benches or a picnic table (if you have a blanket make it a picnic). Staff is always friendly!!
Read more
Google
This is THE spot to go for bagels in the Hamptons. Be prepared to wait a bit but well worth it. They serve bagels any way you want them and are always helpful.
Google
Fantastic breakfast sandwiches. Can't speak to other things, because I have only tried the breakfast sandwiches, but I hear great things and everything else looks great!
Google
One of the best,"chewy" bagels that I have had! Bonus! Was sitting at front window and Christie Brinkley walked by on an errand next door.(still as beautiful as ever)
Google
Excellent homemade bagels, really good, decent sized egg sandwiches, and some healthy bagel varieties, such as the pumpernickel everything and the spinach everything, which are not found elsewhere in the area. They also offer tofu spreads as an alternative to cream cheese. Easily one the best bagel spots on the East End.
Read more
Google
Best Bagels! Always fresh. Light and airy with crisp chewy crust!
Google
This place is pretty nice, the workplace looks clean enough and the staff is friendly. I was pretty happy with my meal that I ordered, my only complaint is with the chicken cutlet I had. The chicken tasted and felt like it was already a day or two old and not fresh. Other than that everything was good.
Read more
Google
Explore more in Sag Harbor
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: