Reviews The Pie Hole

Facebook
Mike Twiggs
+5
My daughter found the place today, and she brought me a PIEce (see what I did there) of Chocolate Bourbon Pecan. For the 15 minutes it took me to put away that slice of beauty, I was in freaking heaven! Everyone that knows me, knows me as a connoisseur of Pecan Pie, and I can safely put your pie in my top five. Easily! I'm hoping my wife is not working this weekend, because I'm going to drag her ass to your shop and put myself into a diabetic coma! PIES!!!
Facebook
Sharon E Cummings
+5
The Chocolate Bourbon Pecan was to live for!...The pie crust melts in your mouth!...#DeliciousđŸ„§
Facebook
Matthew Matuse
+5
Bought the Derby on a whim at a bake sale for a missions trip to Guatemala. Wow was it good. And chocolate chips are not high on my favorites list but in that Derby...Wow. Thanks for the great pie!
Zomato
Kitchen33
+4.5
Awesome pies. Small family owned business. Extremely nice. Downtown Roswell , hidden from main road.

What to order:
Pecan pie
Apple crumble pie
Chocolate pie
Dec 28, 2015
Zomato
Foodlover
+4.5
What a Treat. I love stopping by this delightful shop for a tasty treat of sweetness, or I preorder one of their chicken pot pies for dinner. I love the updates being made. Warm and cozy all around. Make sure to go by early for a better selection or preorder a whole pie if you have your heart set on a particular pie, as these delicious pies are baked daily without any preservitives. I'm dreaming about their apple pie and banana cream pie... I guess I'll need to stop by again real soon.
Sep 30, 2012
Zomato
Mssbowers
+4.5
Blind Sided. I had heard about The Pie Hole a while ago. Since my 9 yr old loves sweets we decided to find the place. We decided on the strawberry/rhubarb pie (of which I was very sceptical). Sweet Jesus! That pie was awesome. I am a little weird when it comes to pie crust. I do not like dry crust edges, so I almost always break them off. Not this time. I didn't leave a crumb on my plate and neither did my daughter. I won't buy a whole pie because I will eat it all. It is worth every dollar.
Apr 30, 2012
Zomato
Michael Agurkis
+4.5
Fantastic place. Pies are amazing. Super nice staff. Reasonable prices. This is a true hidden gem of Roswell.

Try the Amond Joy pie!!!
Nov 23, 2011
Zomato
Providence1
+4.5
Ummmm....PIE!. Fruit pies are fantastic...others are equally wonderful. Haven't had the chicken pot pie yet but have heard it's excellent. Have been told Alayne can whip up a beef pot pie too, if you give her some advance notice...
Oct 07, 2011
Zomato
Brit P
+4.5
Welcoming, Cheap, and DELICIOUS. I've been here a couple times and it is absolutely one of my favorite places in the metro area. The staff is always incredibly nice, the pies are plentiful and perfect, and the coffee is great. I recommend this to anyone. Every pie I've tasted from them is phenomenal. Go as soon as possible, it's amazing.
Jun 24, 2011
Zomato
Mrs. Consumer
+4.5
Yum!!!. Well worth the high price!!!
Jun 05, 2011
Zomato
Rev Lauren Kelley C Ht
+4.5
I am NOT a pie-lover. In fact I could probably count on my hands how many pies I bought or ate my whole life - that is until I found Alayne's pies! You can taste the love baked into these pies and every pie I'd fantabulously delicious! The service is the best you'll find and so are the desserts'
May 07, 2011
Zomato
Blittle
+4.5
Two thumbs up! My husband and I shared a strawberry rhubarb and an almond joy. They were both delicious! We saved half of each for a late night snack!
Apr 09, 2011
Zomato
Clori Rose-Geiger
+4.5
Great Pie, Great Place. Tried the pie for the first time today. Had heard a lot of great things, and this little bakery, devoted only to pie, to delicious, lovely, heavenly pie, is wonderful. We tried the lemon chess, white chocolate macadamia nut, and the coconut -- each was delicious and perfectly made. The owner is sweet and friendly, and the building is charming. This place offers no frills -- just honest, down home, out-of-this-world pie. I am now in love! Everyone must try this pie!
Jan 22, 2011
Zomato
Aubree Caraline Clark
+4.5
I don't even LIKE pie all that much,. And I LOVED this place! Went there a few months ago. The owner was so nice, and I had choc. chess pie, I think? It was ridiculously melt-in-your-mouth good. I've sent so many people down there, and always will. It will definitely become a staple of Historic Roswell if it hasn't already.
Jan 17, 2011
Zomato
Diane Schuler
+4.5
I dreamed of a place like this. For years, I cursed the disappearance of really, really good pie. I moved to Roswell... and found The Pie Hole. I have purchased 2 pies so far; pumpkin (for Thanksgiving) and Chicken Pot Pie (for a mid-week family meal). Both were over-the-top good. There's no substituting for homemade goodness. I will be back... and I will tell everyone who will listen about how great this place is.
Dec 09, 2010
Zomato
M.matteson
+4.5
Wonderful Pie!. I bought an apple & pear pie on November 20 to take to a Thanksgiving dinner and had to freeze it to keep it fresh. Of course when it thaws it gets a little damp, so I popped it in a 325 degree oven (uncovered) for about 20-25 minutes and the crust was restored to its original texture. It was a huge hit at the dinner because it was not overly sweet, and with 3 lbs. of Granny Smith apples in the pie, plus the sliced pears, it was visually eye-appealing because all the layers of apples and pears were visible when it was cut (NO PIE FILLING in these pies) and elicited lots of "oohs" and "ahhs." The top of the pie also had apple and pear cut-outs ("applique") attached made from more pie crust. Can't wait for a cold rainy day to try the chicken pot pie! Wonderful little shop!
Nov 27, 2010
Zomato
Bill Klausmeyer
+4.5
All home made, delicious, inventive, like hardly describes my affection for the pie hole. Just do it.
Sep 10, 2010
Zomato
RDubya
+4.5
Good pie is hard to come by.... Really well done pie is hard to come by, and this place is a gem. The owners are very friendly and the place is no frills, all about the pie. My young kids could not decide, and they gave them a bunch of samples to help them pick.

Buttermilk and coconut pies were really good. Both chocolate pies were good, and the crust on all were heavenly.
May 31, 2010
Zomato
Barney
+4.5
Great Pie!. It's really nice that they're setting up at some of the Farmers Markets. I found them yesterday at the Marietta Square FM and I grabbed a piece of the Franken Pie (2 crust pie w/ apples, pears, raisins, cranberries, & walnuts) that was out of this world. HEAVY with fruit, great combination of sweet, tart, crunchy and creamy.
May 16, 2010
Zomato
Grasshopper
+4.5
Really good pie!. They make everything fresh, they make what they want with the freshest ingrediants. Their pies are really good and unusual. My husband got a pinapple strawberry pie, I never would have tried it but it was amazing. Old standards are breathed new life. I heart pie!
May 16, 2010
Zomato
365Atlanta.com
+4.5
The June/July issue of Garden and Gun magazine arrived in my mailbox a couple of weeks ago with a saliva-inducing photo of a perfect cherry pie on the cover, advertising “An Insider’s Guide to Pie Shops” in “The Secret South.” Imagine my surprise that Ros
Sep 21, 2010
Zomato
Foodnearsnellville
+4.5
The Pie Hole is Alayne Graham's homage to one of the oldest and most treasured desserts, the pie. The shop is small, neat, and pretty, but clearly the work of a single individual. The day we arrived she was replacing her freezer. She had managed to outgro
Jun 10, 2010
Zomato
Jennifer Zyman
+4.5
Hello lovelies. It's been quite a busy-and trying-past few months for yours truly. I won't get into the all the gritty details, but I was going through lots of medical stuff including having a tiny piece of my tongue cut off. All is well, but blogging has
May 03, 2010
5
Alison Hertz
+5
I absolutely love this business. The owner is great and the pies are amazing. I highly recommend ordering a pie now and when the pandemic is over, stop by for a slice or two. She changes up the variety all the time, but you can almost always find apple, cherry, chocolate chess, and many more. My family loves the fruit pies, the chocolate silk and coconut cream, but we have tried at least ten of her different kinds and they were all excellent.
5
Don Abraham
+5
I contacted The Pie Hole for help preparing desserts for a group surprise birthday party for my wife. The owner just was fantastic talking through what I was trying to do, options, and so on. We ended up going with a family recipe dessert, and the owner suggested individual portion mason jars, which worked fantastically. The owner then scaled the recipe on her own time to figure out the portions needed across our order. It just came out terrifically. I almost never am completely unrestrained in my appreciation, but here The Pie Hole just knocked this custom dessert catering out of the park - So grateful that I got their help. Thank you!
5
Eileen Ronninkat
+5
Best sweet pies in metro Atlanta. The peanut butter with chocolate crumble crust is just decadent. The chicken pot pie is a bit on the sweet side and not as creamy as the one by Southern Baked Pie, but is filled with nice meaty chunks of chicken, carrots, beans, and potato. Only the operating hours prevent us from coming here all the time. If you have a regular 9-5 job you'll have to take time off or go early on Saturdays to get a pie as they're not open on Sundays.
5
Jeremy Doxtater
+5
A religious experience Savory or sweet, The Pie Hole has it. Their chicken pot pie will make you say "Marie Calendar who?". It's truly epic. The crust is perfect. This is the crust on the pies your grandmother made at Christmas. Yes, it's that good, sorry grandma. Now let's talk sweet. From perfect crust to exquisite filling, every pie is something sent from heaven. The apple pie measures almost 6 inches in the center. That's right, HALF A FOOT OF PIE! And the chess pies, chocolate and lemon. The word trancendent almost captures it, but not quite. If you're within 50 miles of Roswell Georgia and you don't make the trip to the Pie Hole on Canton Street then it's painfully obvious that you hate kittens, bunnies, and everything good in this world.
4
Ashley Wallace
+4
I love pot pie but cannot really find a good one - this has been an issue in every state I've lived in. Most places don't have a good crust or don't have enough veggies in the pie or tastes 'fake'. So I wanted to try this pie place to see. I live a bit a way so I wasn't familiar with it at all. It is literally just a little pie shack on a little dirt road in the built up part of downtown Roswell. The owner, I think, is the only employee as I recognized her voice on the phone and was the only person in the shack. She was stressed and not very friendly (at least on the phone) but it was mother's day weekend so I understand. She was friendly at the pickup window but was doing everything off of a notebook piece of paper. The great - the pot pie was amazing. Huge, tasty crust, well seasoned, tons of chicken and veggies that were real and fresh. The not so good - the website looks like it was from the 90's with not much info on it - just the possible pie list, contact info, and no prices. The place needs to update/streamline their ordering process and website. The price of the pie was $34 which was really high. I got it because I drove all the way up there and wanted to try it but I wish I knew that before hand. I would totally eat it again but I'm not sure if I would pay that much for it again. $25 I think is my limit for a pot pie.
5
Daniel Crouch
+5
We ordered 4 pies from here for Pi day yesterday for work, and we're blown away by the quality. The apple pie is one of the best I've ever had. I never knew of this place before, but now I'll definitely be ordering on special occasions. They are a bit pricey but they're absolutely worth the money.