Top notch establishment. Comfortable, casual, and delicious. Humble ownership that made it feel like you were visiting family for a meal.
It's a pleasure to be able to support local businesses. They are appreciated for what they do.
The small Caesar salad is big enough for two people. And it's good. We also got the eggplant pizza, my family liked it, but I'm not an eggplant fan. Free parking in back. Gulf station with inexpensive gas about 100 feet down the street.
Excellent family pizza restaurant with a full Italian menu. The food is fresh and well prepared and portions are huge. BYOB with a convenient liquor store next door. Prices are typical and reasonable. Plenty of seating available
Very Good Slice of Pizza here. Parking is located off Main Street behind the building. The slice was super greasy, but had a lot of flavor. The sauce was really good..They offer many different variations with any topping you cN imagine. There is a separate dining area from the pizzeria. Both were re
We used to go to Anthony’s years ago until we moved down south. Best food we have ever had!! Flounder Francesi, eggplant rollitini, pizza, salad dressing! It doesn’t matter it was all so delicious. Wish we had the recipes. Miss your food so much!!
Good price for the amount of food you get (large portion sizes in my opinion). I got a small/regular baked ziti and it took me 3 days to finish it. We also enjoy the calamari. We’ve tried other places in Rockaway and this place is always a good option to go to.
Ate two pies this weekend, and both didn’t disappoint. Amazing food. Grew up eating this pizza, and the taste and quality has not changed a bit. Keep up the good work team!
We have always loved the food from Anthony's... Consistently excellent. And then to top it off, Anthony hosted my daughter's girl scout troop for a FREE pizza making class. He and his staff were absolutely wonderful with them and created a lasting memory. The girls left with a free kit to make anoth
We moved practically across the street a couple years ago and we order here frequently. Amazing service, amazing pizza. Tried everything else in this area and nothing compares. It’s great to know this is the place my little ones will grow up to. A really cute spot to dine in as well, window seats pr
I think the 4.7 rating is somewhat accurate. The pizza here is pretty good, which sets it apart from the rest of the horror show pizza places in this area. This is one of the only places in Morris county I would recommend. I lived in Rockaway for years and went her a lot, both dine in and take ou
My parents have been going on dates here for many years. Today we had my sister's baby shower here and the service was absolutely wonderful. Thank you guys so much for treating my parents so well over the years and for hosting the party today. Oh of course, DELICIOUS FOOD AND GREAT PORTIONS !
I don't write reviews often, but I had to hop on here and give this place the props it deserves. My husband and I just moved into the neighborhood in December. This is my top go-to place when ordering food. Best catering experience I've ever had. Best penne vodka I've ever had. So far I've had the p
Beyond grateful to Anthony’s Pizzeria for opening his doors on his day off for our Daisy's Girl Scouts pizza making class, The reason I love this town so much. It’s a community here, and small businesses like Anthony’s make it all worthwhile. Thank you so much, Anthony and staff. 🫶🏼P. S the pizza an
Food was exceptional and portions outrageous, so happy to have leftovers. Highly recommend
Best kept secret pizza spot, only locals know how great this place is, I used to live in rockaway so I’ve had the pleasure of eating there frequently, whenever I’m in the area I always stop in!
I had pasta w/ broccoli. For such a simple dish it was so tasty. Must be that garlic! And such a large portion which i thought i would have to doggie bag, but being there with friends and chatting for a few hours i finished it. So yummy. My husband had the seafood combo and said it was very good. He
I have to say today was such a long day. My kids had activities, but we also had soccer pictures to take and it was a late night!!! Kids wanted pizza and this mamma was ok with that. But, of course they didn’t want any pizza , because they love Anthony’s. So we got there at 8:45 not realizing they c
You can’t beat the quality of the food coming from here for the price. Thin crust pizzas are amazing and pasta dinners are always more than enough to share. Staff is great and always friendly no matter how busy they are
WOW! This is my new favorite pizzeria. My husband's job is not far from Anthony's pizzeria and he often gets lunch from them. Recently he brought home dinner for us and I was absolutely floored. I had the muscles with marinara sauce. It was delicious and the muscles were abundant. My husband had th
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes