I recently moved here and found out they were doing this promotion where they are giving away free cheesecake! I came here to try them for the first time and it is some of the best cheesecake I’ve had ever, and i would consider myself a cheesecake connoisseur! I got the plain vanilla and it was so p
I have tried two sugar-free cheesecakes from Cheesy Eddie’s: Marble and raspberry swirl. Both were delicious! I wish there would be more sugar-free options in the future for other cheesecake flavors and other baked goods.
Open one hour later on Saturdays than the South Ave location. Large store, clean and well organized. There are a few stairs to get in, which should be considered for someone who has issues with mobility. Their carrot cake is unbeatably the best ever.
Update: I found out that they do have a ramp fro
Great selection! Friendly staff! Their carrot cake is insane! Loved the sampler tray!
Thee best freaking cheesecake cupcakes in Rochester!!! Cheesy Eddie’s has 2 locations here but I want to review the Henrietta location because the girls there are Always friendly and informative of different flavors. My absolute fav is the apple pie cupcake 🧁 but unfortunately it’s seasonal 😔
This was my first time at Cheesy Eddie’s (I’m from out of town). We ordered 5 cheesecakes for our wedding. The cheesecake was a hit and everyone loved it, it’s perfectly creamy with the perfect amount of crust.
Pick up was a breeze, they had everything ready on time and even helped me out to my car
We went for the freebie on cheesecake day. Both flavors were delicious. I'm definitely going back for a full cheesecake soon. Problem is what flavor!!
Oh my, their original cheesecake is definitely worth the trip! Well made, soft, creamy and decadent - it's no surprise that they had a queue! Nice atmosphere and lovely space - can't wait for the next one.
Would highly recommend Cheesy Eddie's, perfect 5 star for customer service-Stephen helped me with my order. Aside from making my mini present possible, the person who picked up the cake was really happy- it was soooo gooooooood!!!!!
Literally my favorite cheesecake place ever! Staff is friendly with suggestions, lots of cute variety of other desserts too 👌🏻
Best cheese cake I have ever had. I have it sent to me in Florida and I purchase it when I’m Rochester
Definitely not just your average cheesecake. This is how cheesecake is supposed to be. Well done. I will be back.
Wow! We preordered the Carrot Cake Cheesecake and it was ready at the time we scheduled to pick it up. The person at the counter was friendly and professional. It smells amazing in there!
Highly recommended and we will definitely be back.
Best cheesecake in Western NY. You won't find anyone best. Everything is fresh and staff is wonderful
This is what my friend Darryl had written on his belated birthday carrot cake. Impressive piping by Cheesy Eddie's in Henrietta.
Visited the Friday morning before Christmas Sunday. The line was winding and snaking around about 15+ people deep and remained at this steady volume of customers while I was there. But amazingly, everyone was in beautiful spirits and extremely helpful!
You can pre-order online or phone for a pick u
If you haven't tried Cheesey Eddie's, you've yet to have the best cheese/carrot cake there is! Best deserts anywhere!
Clean, pristine with friendly service! I ordered/paid online and picked up the next day. Lots of wonderful choices. The carrot cake might be one of the best I’ve had and it’s nice that there are no raisins or nuts so my daughter could have it. Thats hard to find.
The best cheesecake ever! We love the key lime, cherry cheesecake , Oreo, amaretto and of course the original is amazing. Had a chance to try their cookies and fell in love with them. Wish we lived a lot closer so we could treat ourselves more often
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes