Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

We have only ever had one dish at the Main St Scottsville location that has been wrong. When it was brought to our servers' attention, we were comped for the meal and offered something different if we chose to have that. There's only one server that we refuse to have, and it's because of her attitude. The rest of the staff are awesome, and we recommend this place all the time.

Wow, I must say. That was the greatest service i’ve ever had. There was a young gentleman by the name Anthony who had the best attitude, most integrity and had a great passion for his job. He took great pride taking my order and making my food as fast as he could. I ordered a large pepperoni and a side of calamari, Let me tell you, both were delicious and very tasteful. The calamari though, unbelievable, absolute 10/10. The pizza was cooked to perfection and the kids loved it. I would very much recommend this place to anyone and i’ll be sure to come back again. I hope to see Anthony again!

I just want to say thank you so much to Mike aka Mush aka Portabella and Pat and Montana and Tabitha for being the most courteous and enjoyable and Professional staff that I have ever been happy enough to be served by. They not only made me feel like a super star but cooked food to perfection. THANK YOU GUYS FOR THE BEST EXPERIENCE AND PIZZA IN DA ROC!!!!

We have a salvatore's around the corner from us on Buffalo road, just slightly over a mile from our house. The quality and service there is HORRIBLE, one time we had a push pin baked into our pizza. We decided to give this location a shot. It is amazing, the staff are friendly and knowledgeable. The food is great quality and very consistent when ordering the same product each time. Mind you this location is almost 8 miles from our house, I would rather drive the 30 mins round trip vs the 10 minutes round trip to the location closest to us!