Amazing pizza! We had a large cheese and a large pepperoni. Both were cooked perfectly. Loved the crust, great sauce, cheese was almost commercial-perfect coming off the pan.
I don't think the dining room gets used often enough - which is a shame: it was a nice and cozy atmosphere. Our family took up most of the room, but we had it all to ourselves.
There was a small miscommunication at the beginning, but everything turned out great at the end!
Some of the best pizza 🍕 in Rochester, Ny💯
Pizza is always done to perfection and when I say you can taste every flavor ....omg I mean it!
So Delicious with very original seasonings.
There's a reason why Pontillo's has been around for years!
You just can't go wrong ordering from here.
The staff is amazing and friendly. Customer Service...always on point.
Yes I highly recommend 👍🏾
Went there when visiting cousins from England, Pontillos was my first pizza back in 1962 on lake avenue just before 42 school on the same side, best pizza we’ve ever had, it’s all in the sauce, would love to know the recipe.
I'm visiting Rochester again and I needed to order pizza and wings. These were delicious! The wings were perfectly sauced with some extra in the bottom of the container to sop up with the pizza crust. My only downside was the pizza crust was a bit tough for me, but the toppings were great and everything tasted good.
Really nice small dining area, friendly staff, and the pizza is classic and saucy!
The best pizza in all of Rochester! I grew up down the street and have eaten here every week for many years. Amazing every single time!
The owners are awesome and so is the staff. Highly recommend 😁
Excellent pizza. Would recommend the white pizza. The pink is great too. Every time we're in the Rochester area we make sure to stop by to grab a pizza.
If you zoom in on Tiffany Searles pizza. You can clearly see mushrooms. Those gray brown things that are in the shape of mushrooms, are clearly mushrooms. This place takes pride in pizza, we do not mess around after 46 years in business.
I ordered pizza for my grand kids and then realized I was without a car seat for the baby. The manager delivered it for me because they had no delivery person at lunch. I’m thrilled with their service!
Christopher Cahill (Soulful Warrior Rescue)
+5
Best pizza i have eaten in Rochester so far!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Rochester
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes