Reviews Boniello's

Facebook
Veronica Danyo
+5
The butternut squash ravioli were the best. The plate came with 10 ravioli which was plenty to fill me up even though I would have eaten more because it tastes so good. The staff was very friendly and my two boys loved the candy that came with the check.
Facebook
Bill Glass
+5
This place rocks. Friendly staff, awesome food, and byob. Our only regret is that it took us this long to give it a try. Highly recommend to our local friends and neighbors.
Facebook
Anthony Angelillo
+5
The food the pizza and the salads are amazing here. (best around ) the chicken wings were the best wings i had by far .
Facebook
Brianna Crockett
+5
Seasoned crust pizza is the best!! And the chicken vodka sliders! Yummmm
Facebook
Alfred Sterphone III
+5
The staff is super friendly and make me feel welcome every time I come in to pick up my takeout order. The food is always super delicious, and they make the best and most consistently great pizza. If you haven't had the seasoned crust, you're missing out. Don't wait - eat here now!
Facebook
Frank Casciola
+5
If you have not had the pleasure of dining at this establishment yet, you owe it to yourself to do so. The food is amazing and the wait staff is friendly and attentive, it's a win-win situation, you will not be disappointed. Last night we tried the new meatball pizza Fri Diavolo as an appetizer and homemade Zeppoli for dessert and both were delicious. So BYOB and enjoy.
Facebook
Megan Mary
+5
Greatest restaurant ever!!!! The food & staff are absolutely amazing ����! Highly recommend
Facebook
Claudia D. Baker
+5
Best Italian food in this area!! Staff are super friendly and the pizza, garlic knots( regular, buffalo or cinnamon) and dinners are beyond delicious!! Don't forget to request the home made pasta.
Facebook
Bruce Manheim
+5
My wife and I had a wonderful dinner there tonight in this real family owned, operated and welcoming restaurant. The food was great, The service was friendly and efficient but beware.... seating is limited and that's a good thing! Don't forget to bring your own favorite bottle of wine and ask for Jeannie. It was our first visit but we already feel like regulars. Say hello to Matt also...and the cousins.
Facebook
Jefferson Campoli
+5
Great food! The homemade fettuccini is incredible! Vodka sauce rocks! Everything was fantastic! We will be back!!!
Facebook
Mike Connolly
+5
I've been told for some time that I had to try this restaurant. My wife and I got the chance today. We were welcomed as soon as we walked through the door. We could tell that this was a real family environment. And it is ... The food was fantastic .. you have to try the Crusted Meatball ... the marinara sauce is delicious! We agreed that we found our new favorite restaurant!
Facebook
Chelsea Jordan
+5
This is my second time using Boniello’s for catering. They did not disappoint! We will continue to use them anytime we need catering done. They were extremely efficient and not to mention their food is quite delicious! We always get compliments.
4
Diane Fegley
+4
I wish I could give this place all five stars because the decor is adorable and the food was plentiful and amazing. (See my pics) so first of all, please, please, please go. They have an incredible menu selection with all sorts of fun, novelty items like the pizza cone and fried oickle on a stick. But to the management… We walked in the door on the side which says for dining, and we waited several minutes before finally popping our head over to the other side of the dining room or the staff was all congregated talking, to ask to be seated. The waitress was very patient with us as we made our way through the menu to order but after that point, we had to consistently call her to get her attention. She sat at a table with other staff with her back to us. We were one of two tables she had. In addition, we ordered a wings appetizer, and when we were done, we put our plates at the edge of the table, and she repeatedly came back and did not take them, until we finally asked her to at which point she seemed indignant. We could see that they had a busser, so I guess she planned on letting them sit there until the end of the meal and until he retrieved them. It was also disappointing that we finally had to ask for our meal at which point she had indicated that I guess she had the kitchen holding it waiting for us to finish our wings. As per our picture they were huge and there was no way we were going to finish them. We were in a rush, so that kind of held us up. And once again we were given the check and had to get up and get the waitresses attention to get boxes and our check to go. Final point, I appreciate that they are using paper straws and no plastic bags as per New Jersey law, but then they are using some type of disinfectant wipe in packages on the tables, instead of a reusable cloth and spray, or even paper towels.
4
U. R.
+4
Generous portions, and great food for family style Italian. Pretty much everything we ordered was good. Service was delayed at times but guess that is to be expected with staffing shortages and whatnot. Would go back.
5
Raphael Intrieri
+5
Small, family-run, Italian restaurant with traditional foods and also foods with a twist like the cones. Service was great and so was the food and atmosphere.
5
Camp Clarke
+5
My wife has wanted to go here for quite some time as our friends love the place. I have passed the restaurant lots of times and always thought it was just another pizza place in a strip mall. Thankfully, I was completely wrong. My wife decided we would give ot a try for her birthday dinner. There wasn't an item on the menu that we all tried that wasn't a quality freshly made dish. They have many menu items that I would expect most pizzerias to have, but then they have great traditional and unique appetizer and dinner plates found at purely dine-in only Italian restaurants. The quality of the food explained the ridiculous amount of people on line to pick up to-go orders as nearly every table was full. Restaurant was very clean and staff were great. I believe they may have been a bit understaffed for a Friday evening, but you wouldn't know it as they hustled to make sure everyone was happy and well served. It's BYOB! Make reservations! Fyi, calamari was attacked by my kids before I could snap a pic. Good size portion
5
dawn berg
+5
One of my favorite places to eat! Good variety on the menu. Everything I’ve tried is delicious, and very generous portions! Service is great! And I love the family vibe there. I gave five stars… would’ve given 10 if I could!!!
4
Cheri Nienstadt
+4
Great portions and tasty food!
5
Sara T
+5
Cute BYOB, with plenty of parking. This was a great spot for a girls night out, staff was great and the menu was varied. I had the calzone and it was amazing! Def recommend!
4
james luski
+4
They catered our FD dinner the other night and everything was great. The penne vodka especially was fantastic. Chicken francaise was really good, even without capers, eggplant parm on point, meatballs were a little dry, still good though.
5
Jet Villarta
+5
Food was delicious. Portions were huge! Our server was very attentive and easy to talk to. He gave recommendations and it turned out great. The horseradish aioli was to die for! We enjoyed our dinner overall.
5
Mary Jane Harrington
+5
Food was delicious. The staff was super friendly and helpful. Great place to have dinner.
5
samantha bach
+5
If you haven’t tried there Nutella pizza you’re missing out!!!! Everything was amazing. We can’t wait to come back next time especially for the calamari.!!!
4
Angela Sposito
+4
Went for Valentine’s Day since our neighbor gave us a gift card. Got the “rice ball” app and it was super crispy on the outside which I loved. I do believe it was homemade. The rice in the rice ball could’ve used a bit more salt, it was a bit bland but all in all it was good. I got the Porpora with veal which was delish. Do be warned that the portion is huge! I could’ve easily shared it with my boyfriend. Will be going back to try more stuff on the menu.
5
John C
+5
Had a really nice lunch here the other day. Service was super friendly and the Greek salad and meatball sliders were awesome.
5
Rachel Milito your Realtor
+5
Such a wonderful lunch with the girls !! This restaurant has amazing food and a very chill atmosphere! BYOB! Warm bread to start off the meal with a delicious olive oil dip. I ordered the beet salad ( no beets) && it was fantastic ! I also had the pasta carbonara with chicken! My friends had the pasta carbonara as a main course as well as a nice big salad. You have a choice of any kind of pasta you’d like for your dish. DELICIOUS FOOD!! We were all stuffed afterwards. If you bring your own wine you get to write your name on the cork and put it on the wall which is a super fun idea. All the waitresses were super sweet, smiling and attentive! Looking forward to going back here or lunch/ dinner or a yummy slice of pizza !!!!
5
Samantha Lake
+5
One of my father's favorite places. He tells everyone it's some of the best Italian food in the state. We celebrated his 80th birthday there and had a wonderful time. Had enough leftovers for a whole week!