Sluurpy > Restaurants in Put in Bay > Frosty Bar Incorporated

Frosty Bar Incorporated - Put in Bay - Photo album

Breakfast was super expensive and not good. Eggs overcooked and tasted nasty. Bacon tasted like the detergent they use to clean the oven trays (I used to wash dishes, it's a very distinct smell). Absolutely sub-par, would not recommend

Great pizza. Anytime of day. Especially late night bites.

Their Food is a rip off. It's definitely not worth what they are charging, especially since the pizza market is pretty saturated. Definitely just taking advantage of a bunch of drunk people when it comes down to pricing. Just go somewhere else for pizza. Their drink prices are not too bad, about s

Very crowded on the day we went. Pizzas were fine, but rest of the items are average. Service was faster and attentive. But the food tastes very average. Food was expensive but that’s through out Put In Bay. Over all passable experience.

The pizza was awesome as usual. The price was outrageous...$32 chicken bacon ranch. Had to give 4 stars due to overpriced.

The food lacked any flavor and our biscuits and gravy came out extremely cold. Our server did take the cold food back to the kitchen to have them make a "new" plate and it looked like they took the same biscuits and just tried to reheat the same gravy and topped them again. There was no flavor in

Giving 5 stars for the great pizza! If you like a super cheesy pizza this is for you. Side salad was lacking and cheesy bread was disappointing. But all was good when we dug into the 3 topping pizza! Yes this place is pricey but it's an island and a tourist place. Plus did you check your bill for th

We loved Frosty's! We went for breakfast every morning while on the island. The waitresses are sweet as they could be. They gave us are drinks to go. Just a great place with yummy breakfast. My husband's eggs were cooked to perfection and my biscuits and gravey was delightful. Most definitely will g