Stefano's Pizzeria

569 Route 23 South, 07444-1419 - Pompton Plains
€€ Pizza
★★★★★ ★★★★★
74/100
479 recommendations

Verified Dish

Add Missing Dish

74/100
Sluurpy Score
479 total reviews
Tripadvisor
4.5/5
3 reviews
Google
4.0/5
362 reviews
Facebook
4.0/5
8 reviews
Zomato
3.8/5
20 reviews
Grubhub
4.0/5
78 reviews
Menupix
2.0/5
8 reviews
🌳 Outdoor seating 🚚 Delivery 🥡 Takeout 🍽️ Dine-in 📅 Reservations Wheelchair accessible Accessible restroom 😊 Casual 🛋️ Cozy 👥 Good for groups

💬 What people say

Italian 39 Cannoli 21 Party 12 Gelato 10 Pie 10 Food and service 9 Vodka 6 Subs 6

Contact Information

📞 Phone: +1 973-616-6620
📍 Address: 569 Route 23 South, Pompton Plains

🕐 Opening Hours

Closed Opens at 10:00 AM
Monday1 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Tuesday2 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Wednesday3 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Thursday4 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Friday5 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Saturday6 12:00 PM - 09:00 PM
Sunday7 Closed

Google Reviews (10)

E

Erica Hadley

6 days ago
★★★★★ 5/5
This is my lunch spot. I love the special pizzas I can get by the slice. My favorite is portobello, roasted peppers and fresh mozzarella. So many great options. Now they have gelato and the cannolis have always been delicious with at least 14 flavor options
Google
J

Justin Sheerin

a week ago
★★★★★ 5/5
Have been coming for the vodka sauce for two decades! I like to substitute it on all parm dishes/subs. The cannolis and gelato are newer additions to the menu which are excellent!
Google
M

Michael Cornwell

3 weeks ago
★★★★★ 5/5
I can’t say enough about Stefano’s , the food is off the charts , closest to homemade without being in your house . If you want just a quick slice or a sit down meal , you won’t disappointed. Started coming here when we moved into the neighborhood 20 years ago , it’s a family atmosphere because it’s family owned and they welcome you in as apart of the family. Come sit down and eat !
Read more
Google
D

Dana Mara

a month ago
★★★★★ 5/5
I wish that I could give them 10 stars. To say that we had an amazing experience would be understatement. I had a reception dinner for 30 people on 11/14 and Everyone loved not only the food especially the penne with vodka sauce (hands down the best around) but the atmosphere was also great. They made sure that everyone was taken care of right down to the guests allergies which believe me a lot of restaurants are not that considerate when it comes to allergies but Stefano Junior was on top of the situation. I would highly recommend them for any type of event that you are having.
Read more
Google
T

Taylor Moffitt

2 months ago
★★★★★ 5/5
We have been to Stefano’s many times for private eating, with our kids, and for events. Every time we have thoroughly enjoyed all aspects of our experience! The staff is amazing and you will never see me turn down one of their cannoli’s! Can’t wait for our next visit!
Google
G

Goce Todorov

2 months ago
★★★★★ 5/5
The best italian food around ,amazing variety of homemade cannoli and gelato. The staff is very friendly and they have excellent service highly recommended
Google
E

Emily Seils

2 months ago
★★★★★ 5/5
Delicious food, great staff, super pleasant here.
Google
L

Lydia Escobar

3 months ago
★★★★★ 5/5
We had the Stefano special pie. Delicious
Google
B

Brad Clinton

a year ago
★★★★★ 5/5
Been going here for many years. Definitely the best Italian in the area. Love all their chicken dishes. Everything is made fresh to order. They use a quality cutlet, not like some places with a paper thin and stringy cutlet. The gnocchi and the Rigatoni Stefano are awesome pasta dishes. Love that you can see the thinly sliced garlic throughout both dishes. My go to for anything Italian. Tried the Gelato and can’t eat ice cream any more.
Read more
Google
Y

Yekaterina Snitkovskaia

a year ago
★★★★★ 5/5
Great tasting pizza and large variety of canolli
Google

📊 Compare with Other Restaurants

Restaurant Score Google Tripadvisor Reviews
Sun Far Restaurant 70% 4.0/5 1.0/5 270
Mr. Sam's Ice Cream 70% - - 0
Pequannock Deli 70% - - 0
Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen 72% 3.6/5 - 54
7-Eleven 70% 3.9/5 - 35
The Little Food Inn 86% 4.6/5 4.0/5 578

Other Restaurants in Pompton Plains

Hoboken's Pizzeria

⭐ 90.0 (57 reviews)

Jersey Mike's Subs

⭐ 89.3 (247 reviews)

The Little Food Inn

⭐ 86.0 (578 reviews)

Kc's Bagel Express

⭐ 86.0 (247 reviews)

Tavern 5

⭐ 85.3 (1485 reviews)

Playa Bowls

⭐ 84.7 (697 reviews)

Help us improve

← Back to all restaurants in Pompton Plains

🍽️ Suggest a dish

⚠️ Report error

🚫 Report closed

Do you confirm that Stefano's Pizzeria has permanently closed?