Wonderful place! All the reviews are older and we recently moved into the area. We love this place and highly recommend it! They have remodeled and everything has always been fresh and tasty with great service! Also one of the best plain cheese pies in the area!!
Dont let the small size of this establishment fool you. The portions are large and the taste is even bigger. I never leave here hungry or disappointed. The staff is incredibly nice and personable. I recommend the Chicken Casa & The Shushuline Sub.
I wish that I could give them 10 stars. To say that we had an amazing experience would be understatement. I had a reception dinner for 30 people on 11/14 and Everyone loved not only the food especially the penne with vodka sauce (hands down the best around) but the atmosphere was also great. They made sure that everyone was taken care of right down to the guests allergies which believe me a lot of restaurants are not that considerate when it comes to allergies but Stefano Junior was on top of the situation. I would highly recommend them for any type of event that you are having.
I can’t say enough about Stefano’s , the food is off the charts , closest to homemade without being in your house . If you want just a quick slice or a sit down meal , you won’t disappointed. Started coming here when we moved into the neighborhood 20 years ago , it’s a family atmosphere because it’s family owned and they welcome you in as apart of the family. Come sit down and eat !
This is my lunch spot. I love the special pizzas I can get by the slice. My favorite is portobello, roasted peppers and fresh mozzarella. So many great options. Now they have gelato and the cannolis have always been delicious with at least 14 flavor options
We have been to Stefano’s many times for private eating, with our kids, and for events. Every time we have thoroughly enjoyed all aspects of our experience! The staff is amazing and you will never see me turn down one of their cannoli’s! Can’t wait for our next visit!
Have been coming for the vodka sauce for two decades! I like to substitute it on all parm dishes/subs. The cannolis and gelato are newer additions to the menu which are excellent!
I have only had reheated slices of awesome pizza, rice balls, and one plain cannoli here, but I cannot wait to come back to get the full affect with dinner. Always good food and service. Outdoor and indoor dining. They do party events too in a section I have not seen yet.
The Pizzeria is a very good looking location. It makes you want to stop for pizza and once inside you will crave a cannoli. Surprising when inside, you can see that they have so much to offer. Great looking specaility slices with all kinds of cannolis and other options. I can see all of this , but nobody took the time to provide any kind of welcome. So went about the business of the regular slice for the Pizza Hunters App. The slice was above average and looked great on the plate. I tasted a hint of garlic in the sauce which provided a very good after taste to the slice. I would go back again for the slice.
We had the Stefano special pie. Delicious
The best italian food around ,amazing variety of homemade cannoli and gelato.
The staff is very friendly and they have excellent service highly recommended
I have been since 2008 and they are so nice and very delicious Italian restaurant.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Pompton Plains
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes