Review Nicolinni’s - Poland

Peolpe, you just don’t understand and some people underestimate that receiving of a super hot plate of food at a Restaraunt when it’s packed … I’m telling you the food comes directly off the stove directly to your plate. It is amazing this restaurant has it going on. The food is so amazing, the staff is so kind and helpful. A 20 out of 10 every time. You cannot go wrong with any of the desserts I’m telling you these things are homemade and fresh every day I can’t give enough praise to this restaurant. Every time I come here it’s better and better.

I live in Florida now, but always stop here when back in the area. Chicken marsala was the best as usual, along with peppers in oil that i can't ever get in Florida!

As far as food goes we were quite pleased. The bread with olive oil/herbs and the family style house salad were both excellent. Everyone in our party enjoyed their food and the waitress was attentive and professional despite being quite busy. The only complaints I have are they offer chicken and steak salads but no assortment of salad dressings, only the vinaigrette based one that comes on their house salad. They also can’t accommodate a party larger than six at one table and make you split up. I understand fire code etc but they had no other solutions to this and in my opinion they would have been totally fine if we (a party of 8 that spent about $250) had just walked out the door. From what I observed there was a large booth sitting area on the other side of the restaurant not being utilized except to hold random items that made it look untidy. Quality food and waite staff great though.

This was the best ribeye steak and Alfredo that I had in a while! Will be back

Went to celebrate our 25th Anniversary ♥️

It's one of my very Favorite places! The Food is a 10 Star 🌟. The portions are Huge! Staff is Awesome. LOVE this Place!

Their Briar Hill pizza is EVERYTHING. And I usually do not care for Briar Hill pizza. Red and green peppers that are grilled and sauteed with a nice char, a nice amount of sauce..perfect crust. Crunchy where it should be, soft where it should be. Not too thin, not too thick. Right amount of Parmesan. My daughter loves it too and she's particular, like Gordon Ramsey. We will be getting this at least once a week.

A very great eating experience and the chicken and greens are superb. The potatoes and greens pizza is my family’s treat.

Food was absolutely amazing as always

Looks like this restaurant has two locations. The food is amazing as always. The bread and oil is so good you’ll probably want to get 2 or 3 helping. I love the mozzarella marinara! We had a pretty big group and the service wasn’t as fast as I thought it would be. The pasta giada is delicious.

In my opinion, this is unquestionably the best Italian restaurant in the area. Chicken al Vino, greens, Eggplant parm and Linguini Nicollini are all a must-try. I've had good experiences with both dine-in and takeout.

Food was amazing. Service was fantastic! One of my favorite restaurants in the Youngstown area now!