Christa Tsoukalas Danisewicz
+5
Stopped in for the first time today--this place is such a gem! Hands down the most delicious cupcakes and whoopee pies we ever got from a bakery ...nothing tastes heavy, syrupy, too sugary or artificial and I just loved everything about the old farmhouse kitchen and friendly owners! Loooooove! Can't wait to go back:)
Sarah made my wedding cake and cupcakes. They both tasted amazing! She is extremely friendly and can design just about anything for cakes. We had a 'birch log' cake and cupcakes designed. I already cannot wait for our 1 year so we can break into our cake again. Sarah is very affordable and I highly recommend her as my baker.
Thank you so much for the best chocolate cake ever!! We've been telling anyone who will listen.
Wonderfull ladies running this bakery. Cupcakes...oh my gosh soooooo yummy. I had the pumpkin and the chocolate flavors and WOW such great flavor.
My mouth is watering from the thought of hose huge and delicious cinnamon rolls!!! To die for treats!!
Wonderful bakery! Great customer service, was even called by name, and not to mention the food is delicious! I’ve tried a variety of their baked goods but the most recent was the lemon squares I brought to an event. They were a great hit with everyone there!
We used Wicked Good Bakery for our wedding. We had 3 different flavors of cupcakes with 3 different frostings, all with different designs, too. And they were all delicious- especially the frosting (some of the best I've ever had!). Our guests raved about them, and there wasn't a single cupcake left at the end of the night. Before the wedding, Sarah invited my mom and I to come by for a tasting, and she was so welcoming and accommodating. Loved working with her!
We had the most adorable & delicious mini cupcakes, whoopie pies & cookies at our wedding thanks to Sarah at Wicked Good Bakery! They had so many yummy flavors to choose from & their prices were unbeatable, highly recommend!!
Angie Terriquez Gannett
+5
What an amazing bakery! Wonderful customer service, friendly atmosphere, and delicious baked goods. They made me two cupcake cakes for my twins 1st Birthday and two separate cupcakes for them to enjoy. I went in with an idea and they recreated it with no hesitation and it came out beautifully. They are amazing!
I finally found this bakery. I bought Halloween cookies which were very good, but the blueberry pie was excellent. I have already ordered Thanksgiving treat.
We had a perfect dessert table at our wedding thanks to Sarah and Wicked Good Bakery with the most delicious pies, mini cupcakes, cookies, and cutting cake. Lots of flavors, reasonable prices, and Sarah was amazing with responding to my many questions and creating wonderful desserts!
After Angie Gannett told me about this bakery, I had to try it. So I stopped by Saturday morning while out running errands. A chocolate cake was in the oven while I was there and the aroma wafting both inside and outside the bakery was incredible! Sarah greeted me and was delightful and fun to talk with. The bakery case offered several tasty treats and I chose a sticky bun that looked loaded with nuts. In addition, it was flavorful, tender, and melted in my mouth. The Wicked Good Bakery lives up to its name and I'm looking forward to going back!
Leslie Allen Rosewarne
+5
THE BEST cupcakes & eclairs around! Actually everything they make is good... but my hubby can't get enough of the red velvet cupcakes and eclairs!
Oh My Goodness. My wedding cake was beautiful and delicious! The chocolate covered strawberries matched my daughters' bridesmaid dresses perfectly. Exactly perfect. And Sarah was a joy to work with. I recommend her work to anyone who will listen. The cinnamon buns, muffins, and sticky buns for the day after brunch were so very yummy. Thank You Sarah!
Love the apple goo bars and their frosted sugar cookies are the best
Wow, went into pick up some cupcakes and I was shocked! It's been here for this long the cookies were amazing as were the cupcakes! The two ladies were very nice as well. I would highly Recommend this delicious bakery
Whoa- the best baked goods we've had and such wonderful people to chat with.
Cake was absolutely delicious! I had emailed her my dream wedding cake and she made it on with my budget! Simply elegant! Cookies were yummy! Perfect size for our wedding!
Sarah, Jean, and everyone at WGB are so friendly, welcoming, talented, and helpful! The only thing better than the owners and staff are the goodies, treats, pies, and cakes they prepare. We have used them over and over again during the last couple of years, and it's always a 5 star experience! LOVE having them right in Plymouth, but they're certainly worth the trip if you aren't as lucky to be so close!
My husband ordered a cake for my 50th birthday and it was SO YUMMY!!!!! Everyone raved about it. 25 people devoured a cake that fed 40 people. That's how good it was. She nailed the design too. I highly recommend the cakes here.
I was desperate to find a small cake for my intimate wedding, as there was no one available to accommodate me for our day.
I found Sarah and trusted to purchase her cake and cookies site unseen by photos and google reviews.
She is located right off the highway so it was easy to pickup on our way more north to Bretton Woods!
She had great communication the whole 6+ months we were planning and I only got to try the caramel latte cake we ordered on the day of our wedding and it was PHENOMENAL! The dogs loved their pup cake as well.
Thank you for adding a piece of love to our day Sarah!!!!
(Cakes are gone but here’s the best snickerdoodle cookies I’ve ever had!)
Oh my goodness! We were looking for a cake for my son's birthday while visiting the area. We come every year and have been disappointed in the past by highly rated places. We took a chance on wicked good bakery and OMG! The cake (chocolate with Oreo filling and vanilla icing) was truly exceptional. My second chocolate hater child gobbled it up and asked for seconds. The birthday boy's eyes lit up with the first bite. Even the adults were thrilled and we are all looking forward to the leftovers (which I'm told also freeze very well). You can stop looking. This is the place you want!
This past week the Wicked Good Bakery provided the most beautiful wedding cake and fresh assortment of delicious pies for our wedding. They were so good that everbody gorged about all of it, and we had to hide some in order to have a bit later on. Thank you, Wicked Good. We love everything about you!
We have used Wicked Good several times, the owner is super nice and the cakes are always delicious with an outstanding appearance! Highly recommend for any baking needs!
Their goodies always taste amazing and we order from them for all our children's birthday cakes! Always been given exactly what we asked for on flavor and decoration. We really love their eclairs as well, definitely recommend.
We used Wicked Good Bakery for our wedding desserts and they were absolutely amazing! From the very first email, Sarah was so communicative and helpful. She made the process so fun and stress free. We had a variety of mini desserts and a small wedding cake for us to cut and everything was delicious! Our guests couldn’t stop raving about them! Thank you so much to everyone at Wicked Good Bakery who helped us have exactly what we wanted for our wedding day!
For our wedding we opted for cupcakes vs cake. Omg to die for! All the guests loved them! My husband has a very picky sweet tooth and loved the cupcakes! They looked beautiful! We got vanilla, chocolate, strawberry and a mocha one, definitely recommend. Sarah was so nice and made everything so easy!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes