Papa Johns Pizza - Pickerington - Photo album

I had ordered via the app and there was a glitch/error with my order and my card was charged despite the order not going through in the app. I called the store and Mike, the assistant manager, answered the phone and I explained my issue. He was very courteous and empathetic, and he took care of the

The picture is supposed to be a Philly Cheese steak (Papadilla?)... But it's missing the steak..horrible, horrible experience..will NOT be back

Good location, nice employees, great tasting pizza! I always order carry out through the Papa John's app. Most days, I receive emails for 40% or 50% off large pizzas or any pizzas. I never pay full price for Papa John's pizzas and I love it!

Worst experience ever! And manger was rude as hell lucky I didn’t have a baby sitter or would have truly driving up there. Ordered 2 pizzas, a peproni and a stuffed crust and they both came burnt. Stuff was flat, and that’s suppose to be the best part of papas pizza l, was hard to even chew for the

0/10. Manager was extremely rude. he didn't get me my order, he called us LIAR, He hung up on me while I called him for my refund because he didn't give my order to my friend, While I called him and back and asked him that y you hung up on me than he replied that I will gonna do that again. And he

3.5 stars. They have really yummy stuffed crust, just inconsistent sometimes… also never answer their phone… I always order online.

Burnt our pizza and manager was rude. Never again will I return

New NY Style is awesome. Ordered online, always ready. Staff is not super friendly, but efficient.