This is such an awesome local spot! I don’t know if I like the pizza or the staff better. I appreciate that they’re not afraid to be adventurous with their pizza recipes and beer selection. We celebrated my brother in laws birthday their tonight and it couldn’t have gone better! The owner is awesome and super accommodating. Can’t recommend this place enough!
Hands down Best Pizza place ever !! I was visiting my hometown of Phoenix last weekend all the way from Albuquerque an it was the best pizza ever an also the wings don’t skip does an everything was super fresh an the quality of the ingredients was 10 an the amazing service made it better everything is delicious but my Favorite is the Carne al Pastor and the Carne asada pizza �������� can’t wait to go back !!!
The 'Gotta have Carne Asada' slice was AWESOME! I swear it is one of the best slices of pizza I have ever eaten. The toppings were awesome. What really surprised me was the crust. I picked up the slice expecting it to droop a bit - nope! The crust was crunchy and did not droop. When taking a bite, the crust was the perfect consistency - not too dry - not too dough-y - stayed crisp until I was done! Spoke to the owner (nice guy!) and he said the Carne Asada recipe was perfected by America Corrales (America's Taco Shop) and the crust uses a french process for making the dough. Try it!!
We have literally been here 3 times since Father's Day when we first had it! We are just a no fancy pizza eating kind of family although people rave about all the creative pizzas! Cheese and Pepperoni is amazing! The sauce is amazing and the crust! The wings are so crispy perfect and the sauces delicious. We had salad and it was all so fresh! The owner is awesome! My littlest kid tends to go on no eating spells so we take him here to load up and eat fresh food and thank goodness he loves the wings and gets some protein!
I have to say that this is one helluva great pizza place. I could go into the cool toppings, sauces, and cheese. I could talk for days about the chewy and perfectly cooked crust. But I think I'd rather focus on the people. The service was amazing and the owner, Randy...well he just gets it. Amazing. The whole concept of NY pizza meets SW is genius. And it's executed to perfection. But the time Randy spent with us and the friendly manner his employees exude is truly wonderful. And if you go, you have to try the raspberry jalapeño cheesecake. Yeah, go for it! I'm a customer for life!!
Jennifer Leon - Gammage
+5
We Love the pizza here. The crust is the best in town , the staff is very helpful and will make you the best pizza . Thank you RANDY
Took the family for dinner, very friendly staff. Talked with us about everything they had to offer. Let us sample some sauces for dipping or wings. Meatballs and marinara were amazing, best sauce I’ve ever had. Went with a traditional pepperoni and a couple of side slices just to try. Al pastor pizza! I’m coming for you next time!!
Amazing pizza...amazing sauce, mozzarella and crust! The Caesar salad was fantastic and the meatball sandwich a must have! A hidden gem!!!
Best NY pizza in Arcadia!!! I'd take a picture but we ate it too fast. Owner is a nice guy and there are lots of choices. I recommend their diced sausage pizza.
Great pizza, fantastic atmosphere! Incredible selection, winner of 2016 Phoenix New Times best pizza!
Fantastic pizza and increaibly gracious owner. Immediate favorite.
Absolutely yum! The people are super friendly and helpful plus the atmosphere is great. I didn’t know what I wanted and asked them to surprise me. I’m so glad I did! Their picks were awesome! � planning to go back soon
We got the Al Pastor pizza and it was incredible!! The green sauce was a bit spicy and all the flavors were balanced. It was perfect for 2 people and not a pizza option that you will find anywhere else. We would definitely go back. The location is a bit hidden being in the inner corner of the complex. Once you know you know. I didn’t go inside but from our car it looks like a cool interior with a big painting on the main wall.
I just stumbled upon this place and I'm glad I did. This place is my new favorite pizza place of all time in Arizona. It's definitely a must try. The pizza really does taste like it's from New York. And the wings are way oversized and delicious. Definitely get your money's worth.
I tried the pepperoni pizza, and it was really good! Thin NY style hand tossed crust, pepperoni was super flavorful without being too oily and salty. The guy behind the counter knew what he was doing, much like a car salesman will “butterfly” the car doors for you as display technique, he opened the huge box with a flourish and spun it for my gaze and approval 👏 Awesome confidence and showmanship, pizza was crazy delicious as well!
Update: I tried the Gotta Carne Asada and the Elote Flatbread…omg these were out of this world, a must try Southwest fusion pizza experience!
Looking for a quick, easy, tasty lunch or dinner? This is your place!
Stopped in for lunch for the first time this past week. I was able to get 2 pieces of pizza with custom toppings (jalapeños) and a drink with a side of ranch for under $10. The owner was super friendly and welcoming.
The thing that made me stop in originally was seeing the advertising offering single slices of pizza. Makes lunch quick and easy! I'll be back again soon!
Moved here from N.Y. 5 years ago and this is the first place I’ve tried that gets the crust right!!! 👍Most places that claim to have N.Y. Style pizza don’t and you end up with some weird crunchy crust like your eating pizza off a cracker. Ordered a Supreme being adding meatballs and anchovies. Bonus points for having anchovies! An everything pizza is just not the same without the little fuzzy fish😋
Like I said perfect crust so you can do a proper N.Y. Fold, great sauce and toppings, nice staff , Thank You For A great pie!
This was a fantastic stop for lunch! My coworkers and I really wanted to get a couple slices and a coke for lunch, and this was above and beyond my expectations. We drove all the way from Biltmore to visit this place, and for the price, it was well worth it. Super quiet, which tells me this place is heavily slept on! If our lunch break was a little bit longer, I would have loved to have been able to grab a draft beer. I will definitely be returning, and soon! My only concern is that the bathroom isn't ADA compliant with the extreme ramp going straight up into the narrow room. I probably wouldn't recommend this place for granny, or for any person bound to a chair. But other than that, I have nothing negative to say about this place. The server was an absolute treat!
Randomly stopped here for a bite to eat and the food was absolutely delicious! We had the habanero wings and the Al Pastor pizza and both hit the spot. Everyone was friendly, food came out quickly, and we enjoyed the sweet/hot and crunchy taste of the wings. We definitely will come back here. This place is a hidden gem!
Creative and unique take on pizza! We loved all the pizzas we tried, but the El Blanco and Al Pastor were exceptional! On top of that, the crust is crunchy, chewy, and so delicious!! Can’t wait to try everything else. Highly recommend if you want to explore a new take on pizza.
Had the opportunity to try out this little gem.
The cashier was really nice.
I got 2 cheese pizzas. The cheese was really good. The crust was crispy and very chewy. Wasn’t a fan of the sauce.
We also got wings the medium. They were good. Also the cheese bread was good.
Super intimate and friendly spot here for some delicious and innovative pizzas and more. Some of the best New York style pizza I’ve had since moving to Arizona. And all of the other off-the-wall creations they have won’t leave you hungry. I really enjoyed their Elote Flatbread. Also, good beer selections to boot, and checkerboards built into their high top tables!
Always good. Such a good twist between SW meets NY. Super polite staff and owner. The 12” and wings are good for 2. Decent choice of beers on draft. Or take to go and eat at many beer places around the area. Slices available too
Crust: thin and crunchy, definitely my favorite kind of crust
Flavor: Bomb! Full of flavor and fresh ingredients
Service: 5 star service, they pay attention to details and they really care about their customers
Honestly coming from MA to AZ its been very hard finding a really good pizza shop. This place has it all and will now be my go to spot even after trying it one time! Everything about my pizza was spot on so please go try it!!!!
This was my first visit and the gentleman (the owner I think) at the counter recommended the El Pastor pizza and I have to say that is the best slice of pizza I have ever had. I know it's not a traditional pizza but man that was amazing! I will take that over any other slice of pie any day. Definitely going back to try their other pizzas. Great and friendly service to boot.
Great food I love that the owner makes quality pizza and invests customer flavors and pizzas great customer service very responsive and accommodating this is great food at a fair and affordable price. One of the top pizza place in town
Nice local place. I love the elongated table with the built in checker board and the detailed mural on the wall, it's an awesome vibe.. but what really shocked me was the menu!! Homemade wing sauces, carne asada pizza, elote flatbread, I couldn't decide what to get! Everything hand crafted and unique. I'm definitely coming back to try it all! And Daniel is amazing! Customer service on point
Enjoyed slices at " My Slice of Pie Pizzeria", a friendly litte restaurant offering Traditional NY Style, Southwestern Style, and Gluten Free pizza. They also have salads, toasted sandwiches, wings with 5 different sauce choices & more. Now to the pizza-- It's really good! We had the cheese, Italian sausage , and our favorite, a specialty slice, if " You Gotta Carne Asada". A must try. I love a thin crust slice of pizza that you can hold out and it doesn't collapse, it was crispy and good. Please support our local businesses.
If the Doctor told me to Medicate myself with pizza this is what I would choose. It’s also dangerous because its in the same center as Bosa donuts Which I shall now call-food crack corner.
The Dough was exactly as it should taste for a New York style pizza, the sauce flavoring was on point, and I should’ve ordered extra cheese because it was that good. I don’t know what I’m gonna do with myself because it’s only five minutes from my place but I appreciate the fact that I have the option. 🤤🤤🤤
I tried a standard slice of pepperoni, the home made sauce is zesty and flavorful, the cheese and sauce ratio to crust is generous. I also had one of the specialty slices with al pastor, purple onion and pineapple, nice combination topped with a delicious chile sauce the owner said that he got from a vendor in Culiacán. They've got the full size fried drumsticks, and you can't go wrong with any of the sauce options. The meatball sandwich is delicious, housemade sauce and 14 ingredient meatballs on a soft bollilo bread that holds it all together.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes