Reviews Stumpy's Pizza & Subs

Facebook
Shayla Maynard
+5
I didn't think I was ever going to find a good pizza place since I left Ohio, then I came into Stumpy's & wow they not only have amazing pizza but everything on the menu is wonderful! They make almost everything homemade where can you find that? Not to many restaurants actually get to know the customers but at Stumpy's they take the time to get to know you while still making sure that you have fresh hot food! So if you have never visited here please find time to stop in & try anything on the menu I promise you will not be disappointed! Also if you just moved into the neighborhood you will get a coupon for a free pizza from here, so you get to try their food on them!
Facebook
Shirley Benedict
+5
Robin and I have been there twice. Great pizza, and wonderful hot sandwich today. Was recommended to us by Greg. and now we keep going back, because the food is great. Little hole in the wall, with wonderful service and terrific food. Had their The Classic Italian Sub...hot Salami, pastrami, pepperoni, and provolone cheese, comes with lettuce tomatoes, red onions, and Italian dressing. Delicious!!
Facebook
Stephanie Wauters Moody
+5
My #1 favorite for pizza, but they also great (large portion)lasagna made with Italian sausage and a lot of cheese in a fabulous maranara served with fresh hot garlic bread. The subs are made with a delicious bread and they have well priced combo deals. The $1 extra side salad is very generous and I would recommend the house Italian dressing. For a stand out pizza, I would recommend The White Out. Check them out!!
Facebook
Ron Sanchez
+5
This is an amazing place for a lil fast food italian style. Pure taste, it's a busy lil joint so be prepared to wait a lil longer, But it's well worth it.
Facebook
Tammy Alford
+5
Love this place the food is stellar. Best manicotti and antipasto salad and pizza bar none. Just wish they delivered to 32nd st and Thomas Road
Facebook
John Pilger
+5
The food is fantastic, had the wings and the hot Italian sub. Hard to beat. The owners Debi and Chase seem to know everyone who walks in. Great hosts and makes it fun to eat there.
Facebook
CJ Neuenschwander
+5
Tried Last night for first time, and well YES YES YES. That was one of the best pizzas I've ever had. I had to give them 5 stars. Had a large Butchers pizza and DEFINITELY will order again. Yes, it is more than all your "chains" you can get, but you def get what you paid for! Staff was amazing and nice even for short interaction of carry out! Well Done!!! <3
Facebook
Tim St John
+5
Best Pizza in Phoenix hands down. All this hype about NYPD I honestly don't understand. Stumpy's blows them away. Stumpy's chicken garlic pizza reminds me of NYC. I grew up in Newark and am spoiled when it comes to pizza. Patrons of this establishment need to understand WHO is qualified to review a NYC style pizza. If the person reviewing has never spent time eating pizza in NYC, their opinion...at least to me isn't worth much. No business is 100% perfect. Stumpy's has gone through some changes like any other business, but their pizza is second to none in the metro area and beyond. Worth every penny.
Facebook
Amber Elexia Haag
+5
What great food and great people! The Italian dressing was freshly made and delightfully garlicky. Very generous with the toppings, too! I can't wait to come back to Phoenix and bring my family!
Facebook
John Osborne
+5
Best pizza place in town I've been eating at stumpys for over 14 years they have the best chicken wings around!
Facebook
Ramses Ja
+5
Stumpy's is the best! I usually go for the toasted tuna sub! This place will continue to be a favorite of mine!
Facebook
Steve Pamperin
+5
Stumpy's is our favorite local pizza. We've been going there since we moved into the neighborhood. THe pizza is great, the homemade italain salad dressing is great, the canoli's are great, the staff is friends, and service is quick.
5
Louis Lioncourt
+5
The atmosphere here is small but the restaurant is clean. The staff is attentive. I enjoy there two slice pizza combos, and there deserts rice crispy is amazing. I recommend you try this restaurant. They also sell subs and salads.
5
cesar carreto
+5
Tastes just as well as I remembered. I used to come here when I was in Boy Scouts. Amazing Pizza. Years later I came back and the pizza is still fantastic! The staff were amazing and patient despite making a large order right before closing. The Works Pizza had a great amount of toppings and there was even a good amount of cheese pull when grabbing your slice. The Wings were easily better than other chained pizza places. Overall their quality hasn't dropped since I was a child and it's worth giving this place a shot!
5
Nicole Poppell
+5
The best slices in town. I live for that crispy crust. Everyone is super friendly. The only thing that would make this place better is if they had traditional wings. (Baked wings only)
5
Julian DeMiguel
+5
This has been our local spot. The pizza is amazing! They play great classic rock and Emily is so sweet ❤️. I bring my crew in and we always have a great lunch.
5
Larry Brown
+5
My wife had the big dipper, I had 2 slices of sausage and pepperoni pizza. So, if you tell them to give you a second because it's your first time. They ring a bell. Don't get used to it. It's just for the first timers. The pizza was some of the best I've ever had! That sauce is amazing! The big dipper was a little salty for me, but my wife enjoyed it! I wish we would have known about this before but a new go-to!
5
Nader S.
+5
Great little spot with good pizza! Came in with a coworker for lunch and we had ordered online for pickup. We arrived on time and the food was ready for us. We decided to end up eating at the place outside. Will definitely be back, the food was great and service was stellar! Thank you for an awesome experience!
4
Bruce Sherman
+4
This place came to my attention from a published list of "Highest-Rated Cheap Eats in Phoenix" and had to go check it out. Had it not been on that list, I would have never found it. It's a tiny spot tucked in a small plaza on Northern which makes it difficult to see if you weren't looking for it. It is, as they claim, a typical neighborhood pizza joint. A handful of tables and a selection of full pizzas, slice combos, sandwiches, and other items. We ordered some slices and an Italian sub. The slices were very large with lots of sausage and pretty typical of a NY style pie. They were reheated a bit too dark and crispy, but we're still very good. The sub was also like you would find in NY/NJ and was very good. We were there at lunch time and it was lively with a good vibe. No table service and nothing too fancy. The staff was busy and very pleasant. We may stop back in to order a fresh whole pizza. Pretty sure it will be excellent. Perfect lunch spot if you're in the hood. And yes, cheap too!
4
Ryan Lange
+4
This is a good hole in the wall pizza shop. They have good quality, and consistent pies. We used to order a lot more from here and even for smaller house parties. The staff are all great and always friendly and super fast. My only gripe is, and maybe from the pandemic, but they have much more limited hours now. I’d come more as I used to if they were open more weekend hours and all. But even with that, great pizza and friendly and fast staff.
5
Carley Kay
+5
Stumpys is amazing 🤩. They have the best and biggest foldable , cheesy slices ever. Seriously one of the best pizza places in the valley for me. I Come here for their lunch specials a few times a week and they never disappoint. Great customer service and cute classic interior. A must try for sure.
5
Seth Darnell
+5
One of the absolute greatest pizza shops in Phoenix. The crust is perfectly crispy and chewy. Sauce and cheese are well balanced and it's possible to eat an entire pie because it's just so good. Wings, subs, and other items consistently deliver. Grab a canoli on your way out.