The best Reuben sandwich in Pensacola | Sluurpy updated in May

Mcguire's Irish Pub & Brewery

87/100 (26607 ratings)

Restaurants

Gluten Free Options

Vegan Options

Irish

Vegetarian Friendly

Irish

Gluten Free Options

Vegan Options

Vegetarian Friendly

Dinner

Lunch

Late Night

Brunch

Reuben sandwich

Salad

Lamb

Crab

Fish

Pork

Cheesecake

Sandwiches

Fish & Chips

Burger

Filet Mignon

Hamburgers

Ribs

Fish & chips

Nachos

Shrimp

Omelette

Beef

Corned Beef

Cheesecakes

Bread Pudding

Meatloaf

Sit down

Irish

Highchairs Available

Full Bar

Accepts Credit Cards

Takeout

Television

Private Dining

Live Music

Seating

Table Service

Wheelchair Accessible

Serves Alcohol

Parking Available

Brunch

Dinner

Late Night

Lunch

Mid-range

"This place is the best ever!!! On vacation and have ate at many places but this exceeds them all !! Great Root beer too! Food, service, atmosphere,..."

Becky Lincecum Flowers

"My absolute favorite place to eat when in the area! Amazing food, wait staff, drinks. Our whole family of 9 had an amazing meal while in town to see..."

Cheri Charles Miles

"Everything on the menu is SO GOOD!! Great service. Fast seating. Great environment! It’s my favorite place to eat every time I am in Pensacola!!..."

Uluwehi Purcell

"We all enjoyed the atmosphere, food, service, history, and touring the place. Our party ranged in age from 8-74 and we all raved about it. It was the..."

Kristina Keller

"Always a treat to visit McGuires! Everything on the menu is delicious and the atmosphere is always..."

Melissa Vinson

"Ate here yesterday visiting from Colorado!!! My 11year old loved the pretzel 🥨. All the food was amazing!! Blue Angel chips 👍👍👍 We loved..."

Shannon Crosby Jensen

"Excellent!! Excellent!! Excellent!!! Great food..great service...great..."

Tracy Dunaway Haynes

"McGuires is my favorite place in Pensacola. With all of the new restaurants that have opened up here this is always my go to place. Best steaks in..."

Chris

"We read several of the reviews. Both good and not so good. This is my first time at McGuire’s. Service was great. Our waitress was very friendly..."

Anthony

"One of my favorite places. Stopped by for the lunch special, fish and chips. Asked what type of fish and was told Pacific Dory, hmmm? I find that is..."

Jack

"This is one of my favorite places. Nice atmosphere(a bit dark though), very comfortable, good service and the food/Irish coffee is delicious! Highly..."

Dora Vee

"Enjoyed the meatloaf lunch special. The restaurant itself is very unique - $1 hanging from all surfaces and dimly lit. Our server, Kenzie was super..."

Lisa

"Do yourself a gigantic favor and download the Nowait app...it'll cut down on your chances of standing outside for 45 minutes like a commoner. The..."

Cody Slyter

"Bean soup; killer! Shared fish and chips special with wife and well filled with a Cosmo for her and Classic martini for me. Good stuff. Bar..."

J. Hed

"I visited Pensacola this past weekend and this place was probably my highlight of the whole trip. The atmosphere was outstanding. Service was great...."

Jake

"The food is good but I believe it's just a bit overrated The corned beef and cabbage are very good! And the bean soup is quite tasty! The atmosphere..."

Ashley McArthur

"Food is pretty good. They have a large range of hamburger choices. Love the bean soup and the boxleys. Prices are a little steep. I also feel like I..."

Traveler

"Kiss the moose! Great times at Mcguires Irish Pub. Excellent food and microbrew! Great service, friendly and fast. Senate bean soup. Best Steaks..."

Mike T

"Went here with some coworkers on a Tuesday night at about 5:30pm and we got right in. When we left a little after 7pm the line was out the door! ..."

GT

"Stopped here for a late lunch and were pleasantly surprised at the menu choices. We were just going to have a sandwich, but decided to split a rib..."

Bsmart

"Great, great and GREAT!! The Reuben sandwich is by far the best I have ever had and it is huge. Two people could share. The potato wedges are..."

Patricia Corkren

"Love this place! We go frequently and we have always been satisfied. The food is delicious and the staff is very friendly. Get there early bc there..."

Allison Bryan

"McGuire's is a must for us when we are in Pensacola. It never disappoints. Not many places bring complimentary bread anymore. McGuire's does. The..."

LC

"On our way back home to Texas, we stopped at McGuire’s for lunch because of the great reviews we saw. Totally exceeded expectations!We..."

Om And Nom

"Family vacation in the Pensacola area (or Destin for that matter) wouldn't be complete without a trip to McGuire's. As always, the homemade root beer..."

Eric Barnes

"Beer, Burgers, Steak. I've eaten here a ton of times and have come for just beer even more times, but I wanted to wait for a recent visit before I..."

Checks And Balances

"Wow! What an experience. If you are ever in Pensacola, You must visit McGuires. And even better, the food is delicious! I had fish and chips, and my..."

Tim Smith

"Everytime I go to McGuires it is always a fantastic time. Normally, I order a custom burger and I have one of their house beers. Last night, I..."

Micahroe

"I absolutely love this place. The place is still as great as it was when I was back here in 2009. I recommend any of the steak burgers as well as the..."

Ron Baldonado

"I'm not a steak person but their prime rib always does it for me. 16 oz is a big portion, enough to share but I always finish it. I wish they have..."

Anh Kim Baldonado

"Always great food and great service! Unique and fun atmosphere with a good variety on the menu and reasonable prices. Live music most nights......"

Reba

"Fun Restaurant, Large ServingsMcGuire’s has become a Pensacola institution. It is a fun stop if passing through the area. The food is..."

Keith B

"I have been many times and their steaks are magnificent. Took my boyfriend there for his first visit and he loved it. Great food beer and..."

Althea Manor

"Best Shepherd's Pie I have ever had!! Looking forward to next visit. Husband had lamb stew and said it was delicious also. Get there early--parking..."

Karen Hart Valencia

"Comfort food done well. I had never heard of McGuire's until a local told me about it and insisted I try it. Arriving after 8 p.m. on a rainy..."

Wade Kwon

"So delightful. 3 of us, 2 adults and 1 child. Service was excellent and food was delicious. Irish wake was really good and hubby had their IPA...."

Nic

"What can I say about this place that has not already been said, but it ranks as one of the places you must patronize if ever in Pensacola. I have..."

Lkr3515@gmail.com

"1 word: AMAZING! Quite possibly one of the best restaurants I've been to....ever. So good we went 2 nites in a..."

ME

"Staff was great. Go for Sunday brunch. It was very good. We would go back here. Got the eggs Benedict and 6 egg..."

Morgan

"Mixed review great food, mediocre service. I've been to McGuires several times. Love love love the shepherds pie, robust with flavor, best I've had..."

Zoe

"Brunch on Sunday. I have been to McGuire's many times in the past, but had never been there for their Sunday brunch. I ordered the shrimp and grits..."

Faye

"Fun & consistently good food.... I've been here many times and I will say it is very consistent across the board...in a good way. Steaks are..."

FromVA

"Good meal, Good experience. We went here (we are from out of town) because we heard some locals talking about it. We had a bit of a wait and ended up..."

S P Hugbear

"Super bad day. Normally I'm a very big fan of McGuire's. This particular day My wife and I took a visitor from out of town who had never been before...."

Navarre Critic

"Best restaurant in Pensacola-bar none!. McGuire's is much more than food. It's an experience. Their steaks are of the highest possible quality. Staff..."

Earlservicedog

"Best burgers on the planet. No joke. My personal favorite is the Texas chili and cheddar burger. They are big enough for 2 meals too. Also love the..."

The Hungry Chick

"This is my 3rd time eating here and is a must do every time we are here on vacation. The burgers are ginormous and the Irish Wake is amazing. I will..."

Sharon

"Big daddy steak burger was good. You must try the boxty fries potatoes and dipping sauces. Wife's steak burger was burnt, probably should have sent..."

Brian Solomon

"Good stuff. We really enjoyed this place. The only issue for me is that they really don't have much for vegetarians. I ended up having a baked..."

Stephanie

"Pensacola Proud. Everything on the menu is great, well priced, and large portions. Huge. The atmosphere is fun. Out of the probably 2 dozen times..."

Sarahstevenswhite

"Fish and Chips with entertainment. I enjoyed the old world feel of McGuire's Irish pub. I enjoyed the large serving of fish and chips... enough to..."

Sarahfiala

"Oh my God the cheesecake. I've always been a fan of McGuires Steak, but I only recently tried their cheesecake. It was nothing short of amazing,..."

Shannon Mills

"I have been here several times, had great food and a great experience, but have never left feedback here. So here it is....I normally sit at the..."

CustomerServiceGuru

"My friends & I eat here almost every time we go downtown; the service is usually good. I always get the Senate bean soup and Reuben Eggrolls b/c they..."

Katrina_camacho

"I ate there twice. I didn't like the root beer but the boxties were real good and so was the shepherds pie. But the best was the steak. It may be..."

Phillip Hardt

"Always nice environment, good food, some pricey but..."

Elli

"Wonderful Place to Eat. My husband and I just started going to McGuire's a few months ago. I am sad we didn't go sooner. The burgers are phenomenal...."

Birdfeeder

"Enjoyed the food, beer and waitress we had. We just got there for an early dinner and the senate soup and spinach artichoke dip and we couldn't even..."

Ashley Kunz

"Nice experience. Had dinner here last week. Sure was as close to the hype as any place I have ever been. We had the Boxteys, the senator bean soup..."

Justmyopinion

"Absolutely the BEST hamburger I have ever had in my life. I recommend this place to anyone going near..."

Culinaryisanart

"The best burgers (go for the Big Daddy) and beer in P'cola. Great..."

ShanJRocks

"Always a Fun Experience. This is a fantastic place for socializing. The staff is AL WAYS wonderful and helpful (I'm plant-based, and at a..."

Anna

"So fun! Staff is awesome, food is delicious (LOVE THE FRIES!) The corned beef is perfect, sometimes I get it with the cabbage and sometimes on rye...."

GCSunday

"Same as its ever been. I've been going to this McGuire's for as long as I can remember and it's always great. Watch out for the nachos, especially if..."

Kmart

"Best yellow fin ever! Great service & great food! Its a..."

Ashley

"Shepards pie was..."

Brendon

"We ordered 3 filets and they were all 3 cooked to perfection. Great restaurant, environment, etc. Loved it. Beer was great..."

Tubya McRubya

"I can't rave about this place enough!! The handcrafted beer was spectacular, food was outstanding, and the wait staff was friendly and efficient...."

Gabe Frost

"When In Pensacola.... If you're in Pensacola, and you don't eat here, you are doing it wrong. Amazing burgers, an atmosphere like nothing I have ever..."

MmmFood Lover

"First time to eat here... LoVeD it!! Hamburgers are gigantic...can easily be shared. Service was great too & the bill was inexpensive. The atmosphere..."

ExpatGirl

"A must-see in Pensacola. I grew up in Pensacola but moved away 5 years ago. Still, every time I return to visit my family and friends, it's not even..."

Jennifer M

"Thank God some things never change. The bean soup is still 18 cents. Tourists who don't know how to read end up in the wrong washtoom and still argue..."

Bud

"Always excellent!. Love the food and the atmosphere. Highly recommend Janice to serve your food. You will not be..."

CB

"Amazing Burger. Yesterday we were driving back from the beach and discussing what we might eat for lunch and not getting anywhere when I mentioned I..."

Blake

"Great fun and the food was good, plenty of it, and not expensive. The IPA wasn't fave..."

Bkwillings1

"Truly Irish feel. Strong drinks, plenty of food, music, and revelry. I had wasn't quite prepared for how strong they made my Irish Wake though I was..."

Jillian

"Pretty good food--really good beer. We ate here twice while in Pensacola. The first night was just the wife and me. She had a burger and I had the..."

Nathan White

"Great place. Excellent food, huge portions. Friendly service. They are always packed but totally worth the wait. The atmosphere is..."

Laura Jewell

"Freaking amazing!!!! The greatest place to eat in pensacola florida!!!! Amazing burgers that make your taste buds go wild!!!! Cant wait to eat there..."

Andrew Hertel

"Awesome food and service. Food was TOP notch. The tables are a bit irritating ss they are metal and your drink doesn't balance very..."

AimsMichelle

"Awesome, whimsical. Great food, friendly , helpful, professional , knowledgable server ( thank you Gingerlily). Signage on the roads were most..."

Dottie

"Must See!. This is an amazing restaurant that is a must see while in Pensacola. Take a minute to walk around the restaurant as each of the dining..."

Jennifer H

"This place is known for the dollar bills that hang from the ceiling. Many people have preached about the steak as well. My job came here for our..."

Meme Henry

"We had heard this place was quite popular in Pensacola so thought we would give it a try. We loved the Irish ambience and decor! I felt like I was..."

Cindy Gibson

"We love McGuire. It is definitely a splurge, but everything we have tried on the menu, we've liked. The steaks are very tender, well-seasoned, and..."

Stephanie Girard

"McGuires is a fantastic place to eat. This is a very high-quality restaurant and the prices reflect that. I am lactose intolerant and they work with..."

Sarah Faurot

"My husband has great memories at the restaurant from when he lived here years ago, so we had to stop for a meal while visiting. Even on a Wednesday..."

Anjoli Rowe

"This is a restaurant that everyone recommends if you are visiting Pensacola. They have a huge menu and a festive atmosphere. There is a really nice..."

Joe Pezzulich

"One of the best irish pub in town. I love the environment, how they hang the coffee mug and $1 bill all over the ceiling. Staff are very nice and..."

Ha Dong

"Our night at McGuires Pub was amazing! My son had been wanting to bring me and his sister here since his move to Pensacola. He has been here..."

TRAVELIN' YELLOW CHUCKS

"This was recommended by a friend. It is definitely a good place for some great Irish fare. I had the lamb stew, my wife had the fried chicken lunch..."

Kevin Gibson

"Amazing! You will leave with a full belly and a smile. We’ve been many times over the past two years and tried all of the classic Irish dishes...."

Reset

There are 2 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Reuben sandwich in Pensacola

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Kurt Farnsworth

Merry Kuchle

Sammy Jones

Jessica Banian

Cecelia Amos

Maksim Blair

Jerrod Sharp

Timothy Wunrow

Emily Tryon

Tamara Green

Haleigh S

Brandt Nichols

charlene b

Li Le

Dylan Wier

Christopher Davis

Josh Waller

Ingrid Rodgers

Becky Lincecum Flowers

Cheri Charles Miles

Uluwehi Purcell

Kristina Keller

Melissa Vinson

Shannon Crosby Jensen

Tracy Dunaway Haynes

Chris

Anthony

Jack

Dora Vee

Lisa

Cody Slyter

J. Hed

Jake

Ashley McArthur

Traveler

Mike T

GT

Bsmart

Patricia Corkren

Allison Bryan

LC

Om And Nom

Eric Barnes

Checks And Balances

Tim Smith

Micahroe

Ron Baldonado

Anh Kim Baldonado

Reba

Keith B

Althea Manor

Karen Hart Valencia

Wade Kwon

Nic

Lkr3515@gmail.com

ME

Morgan

Zoe

Faye

FromVA

S P Hugbear

Navarre Critic

Earlservicedog

The Hungry Chick

Sharon

Brian Solomon

Stephanie

Sarahstevenswhite