The best Fish Sandwich in Oswego | Sluurpy updated in May

Rudy's Of Lake Ontario Inc.

88/100 (3964 ratings)

Quick Bites

Fast food

Seafood

American

Fast Food

Dinner

Lunch

Late Night

French Fries

Hamburgers

Poutine

Fried shrimp

Shrimp

Fish

Lobster

Salad

Fish & chips

Wings

Crab

Scallops

Clams

Chowder

Fish & Chips

Haddock

Fried Clams

Cheeseburger

Fish Sandwich

Burger

Sit down

Seafood

Fast food

American

Takeout

Waterfront

Seating

Wheelchair Accessible

Serves Alcohol

Parking Available

Accepts Credit Cards

Outdoor Seating

Dinner

Late Night

Lunch

Cheap Eats

"My first time. The service was fantastic and the menu advice was perfect. Salt potatoes are amazing! The haddock sandwich and clam strips were very..."

Mike Kelley

"I had the center cut haddock sandwich and it was delish. Had a side of mac salad which i also enjoyed. My father had the haddock tail sandwich and..."

Stacy Lape

"We had an amazing meal. The fish was flaky, tender and cooked perfectly. The clam strips were excellent as well. It was packed when we got there and..."

Jeff Surine

"Beautiful place on the water, not a long wait even whe packed, loved being in the open with family and friends, great service, great location, room..."

Diane Bianco

"It was so great to get the season started ! My family loves this place.Best fish dinner around and what a beautiful view of the..."

Cheryl Purdy-Porter

"Service was quick and pleasant. Blue plate was good, but the haddock on that and my sandwich was blah. French fries were perfect. The day was great..."

Ron Mikels

"Great food,service was fast and being by the lake was amazing. Will be back soon ( live near Auburn, but well worth the..."

Paulette Filkins Jones

"Awesome... love the food and the setting, watching the sun go down on Ontario or listening to the waves hitting the shore of which I will never get..."

Robert Mitchell

"Fantastic center haddock sandwich and a side of equally delicious fried clams, and topped it off with a cold drink. Great..."

Frank Kunzwiler

"Location was right on the water. Outdoor seating was nice. Fast, efficient ordering. Food was mostly fried. We had claim strips, max and cheese,..."

hannah D

"A great location with plenty of outdoor picnic tables in the lake, plus some limited indoor seating (no a/c that I could tell🥵). They are very..."

Gina Marie Acker

"I have never been to Rudy's, what I ordered was very good. The only reason I went there was to watch the fireworks at the harborfest. I will be going..."

Tammy Centrone

"Beautiful place to eat outside, picnic tables by the lake. Takes me back to a simpler time enjoying fried food by the water and watching the gentle..."

Mrs. J

"A local hot spot favorite for views of Lake Ontario and great food. My friend and I dropped in during a rain storm that shut down Harbor Fest......"

Sue P

"First time here with my hubby and son for my son's bday and we all loved it!! From start to finish the service and food were amazing!! Went there for..."

Lisa G

"I had the haddock and scallop plate. It was amazing. We ate outside in the setting sun. Just..."

Roger Nolan

"Rudy's is a nice place to go on a sunny day or if you want something quick for takeout. You order food inside and can then take it to-go or eat at a..."

Jubilee Olah

"Gluten free menu attached. Great baked gluten free option with fries; the only thing is that it is not seasoned much if you’re used to that. Make..."

Jon Guidry

"I've been visiting Oswego for 30 years and never knew this place was here right on Lake Ontario. On the water dining, Excellent menu, they know how..."

Rob McDonald

"Outside dining on the shore of Ontario Lake makes Rudy's a spectacular experience. The sunsets are something you don't want to miss. The food is..."

Paul Chapman

"I hadn’t been to Rudy’s since the start of COVID, but I went today and got a Yankee Plate (fried clams, fries, and I chose apple sauce as my..."

Andrew Gemmell

"Beautiful lake-side location, friendly staff, and delicious food. The hot dogs are my favorite, as they are always cooked to perfection, and are not..."

Madison Cruz

"Fried smalts? Delicious seafood? Sign me up. They don’t make places like this anymore. This no frills establishment has a wide ranging menu for..."

Ioana Staicu

"First timer and I loved it. Food was awesome and exactly what I was in the need of. Couldn't get enough. This will be a regular stop anytime we're in..."

Dean LaDeaux

"Great place to sit by the lake and eat. Plenty of outdoor seating. Limited inside seating. The wood comes out quick for how busy they always..."

Lizzie Sheehan

"Great place to enjoy the waves and lake views. Great food and easy ordering. Fried scallops were..."

Nadine Titus

"Line was out the door when we arrived. We waited approximately 10mins. To get to the point where we ordered our food. Young man that took our order..."

Scott Russo

"Everything was amazing. Salmon burger, blue plate, crab cakes, the crab & shrimp roll!!! And the atmosphere is the perfect laid back family..."

Reset

There is only one restaurant

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Fish Sandwich in Oswego

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters