Review Mia's Pizza Cafe - Ortley Beach

Mia's was recommended by a friend and hands down the best spot for dinner after a day on the beach. Alexis, our waitress, was amazing! Great personality and knew the food. We tried something different and were very pleased with our orders. We would definitely come back!

Five stars. Great food. Classic Coca-Cola fountain soda. Pizza is doughy but not soggy. The pizza sauce is awesome, too. Mia's daughter is incredible. Friendly, attentive, and energetic. This place is a great stop.

One of the best food places around! Food and service is great! Prices are very good. Take out service is spot on and quick.....(unless you call in on a Saturday night in peak summer season). Definitely worth a try if you have never eaten here before.

Location was perfect and easy to access. Salad was very fresh and had crisp greens and tasty chicken. I also had soup, which was tasty as well. Included was soft warm bread perfect for dipping. The staff were very busy but also kind. Pizza slices were available by the slice- once ordered, the slices were heated in a deck oven

We came back from the seaside, just passing by. We were very surprised and popular here. You can hardly see anyone outside the town, but it's hard to find a seat in this restaurant because it's so popular that many people are ordering. This is the first time for our family to eat independently in an American restaurant, and it is very meaningful. It's delicious. I'll come again next time.

How have I not rated this place yet? We've been ordering from Mia's for years, great takeaway beach food. Lately we've been getting the Brooklyn Sicilian thin crust pie which is tremendous. But other food is great too. Garlic knots, whoa. Keep up the good work 👍🏼

Was in town for a short trip and our 1st night we wanted pizza so we tried this place and glad we did. Both pizzas were awesome, very tasty sauce and crust , couldn’t have really asked for more oh and delivery was fast which was a huge plus as we just drove 9 hrs, will definitely be ordering again on our trip in June. Thanks for the great service and awesome pies!

Update: There tacos are out of this world i love the chicken and pork & pineapple. They put actual tacos restaurants to shame Today I ordered there grill chicken ceaser salad and had them add hot peppers and red roasted and this is one the best salad I had in very a long time. You haven't had a proper grilled chicken salad until you eat it hot pepper and roasted red pepper hands down the absolute best

I chose Mia’s for Father’s Day lunch because I love pizza. I ordered a deep dish pepperoni and sausage pizza, and was blown away by the size and taste of this pie. Deep, chewy crust that was perfectly crispy on the bottom. They also brought bread to the table with marinara dipping sauce. All delicious. The building appears to be brand new, and is right on the bay.

Went for a familly diner with the kids while on vacation. Foods was delicious and service was really great. Don't forget to bring you own booze (we did)! Simple and awesome place!

I can not say enough about the friendly staff, excellent food and all around good vibes we all enjoyed. I recommend their delicious meatballs. The pizza...perfected. I cannot wait for my next opportunity to visit and dine there again.

I really enjoyed the garlic knots and penne primavera. Our waiter was very nice and accommodating to a few specific requests. I also recommend the Vodka Sauce as a topping. I'm looking forward to returning to try the pizza.

Excellent pizza. Well worth the wait. Chicken parm dinner excellent for the price Nice size portion

This place was fantastic! Quick service and very friendly workers, awesome experience and great food

Make sure you go at off times as this place gets really busy, and rightfully so. The bread here is to die for and the sause is some of the best I've had. We make sure to come here every time we are in town.

Nicest people at the shore (excluding one indifferent female worker). Great food and a pleasure to eat in as well. The chicken dinners will surprise you - really great. Naturally the italian is awesome and love getting pizza dough bread with sauce on the side app. Now also serving tacos that we love. Only criticism there is they get soggy with take out as expected. Been going here many years and year round. BYO!

Don’t be fooled my other places claiming to be “Mia” This is THEE Mia! And she’s got the best Chicken, Bacon, Ranch Pizza east of the mississippi. I invented the Grandma’s Sicilian with crumbled sausage everyone i show it to is blown away

Such a cute, family- friendly and delicious restaurant! My family and I dined here for the first time while vacationing in Seaside Park and it was a hit! We sat outside in front of the restaurant. There is also Inside seating which was pretty full for a Wednesday night. The waitress was super sweet and attentive. We ordered the fried calamari, Mia stromboli, white pie, and margherita/plain pie. Everything was delicious! Prices are very reasonable as well. This will definitely be on my list of restaurants while in the area.