This is your real deal seafood market. And it was well priced too. We got two lobster tails, a set of crab legs, two steaks, and a lemon and it was only $70 and in amazing quality. Upon entering the shop the employees are working fast and moving through customers. Very happy with my experience here!
We visit this market atleast twice during our vacation stay, all I have to say mouth-watering. Best money spent. GO,GO,GO,GO. FRESH DELICIOUS
The food was amazing here! All of the seafood is fresh and on display. I got raw oysters with salmon. The salmon was cooked to perfection and sitting in butter. The oysters were good, and they tasted fresh. The food was a bit expensive but it was very good. A great place for vacation! I would recommended it!
Called ahead for 2 dozen oysters. They don’t take raw orders over the phone, but assured me they would have them if I came in. They took and filled my order quickly. Picked up a lemon and Tabasco, plus 2 dozen unshucked oysters for about $30. Oysters were delicious.
Some of the best and freshest seafood down the shore but very pricey, you get what you pay for
Best seafood market around. Clams, crab cakes and salmon fillets are favorites! Very reasonably priced.
Friendly place and alots of fresh seafood options. Great seasoning for blue crabs cajun garlic!
They have the best fried scallops I’ve ever had and they’re coconut shrimp is unbelievable
My friends and I are were down for a short vacation, one is a fisherman .
As we googled seafood restraunt, we came up the Ortley Fish Market were you can buy, take out ,or eat in.
We decided to eat in. As we wait we can see all the fish seafood being sold. All the workers very polite and extremely helpful.
As the food came out the wafting fresh smells of a shore dinner was so inviting.
Even though it came out on paper plates, nothing fancy, the taste of the fresh seafood was delious. We all enjoyed our meals and highly recommend a very, very causual ,relaxed setting.
Very good, very consistent. Stop reading reviews and just go. (But call first in the middle of summer if you don't want to wait...) Been coming here for a few years and we have never had a bad experience. Don't take bad reviews seriously - there is good chance the reviewer has issues. Fyi - It's not cash-only anymore, they take card.
Open for the summer season!
Great fresh fish.
Carlos sells only the best!
Ask him about his great recipes.
Dish was perfect and I look forward to going here
During all of this, I have to say it's one of the few seafood spots that stay consistent in their quality. Their cooked dishes may be smaller portioned but their rich flavor overcomes that small obstacles.
Note: there is a line outside and a mask is mandatory.
Fish and chips are not "traditional fish and chips", more like a fried fillet, not battered cod. took a while to get order. Good takeout option - give you utensils, etc.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes